India Economy Thread

Solar Industries to acquire South Africa’s Omnia for Rs 12,951 crore in biggest global expansion push
 
Uno Minda approves ₹1,415 crore expansion plan across four facilities
 
Car sales growth in a depressed economic growth trajectory, are mostly false positives

after all, why would there be an increase in car sales, if economic growth was so good, before the suppression of growth rate!

further, real test of any economy is always, growth in manufacturing capacity

are these numbers to support that?!
 
Further, recently it was announced, India has achieved 10% growth rate for a quarter (or something like that!)

that could be concern not a good news!

after all, why would 4T economy need a 10% or 9% or 8% growth rate?

it is meant to survive bubbles, not be a ballon themselves!

these numbers dont make sense, sorry!

re. increase in Forex reserves, if forex has increased bec, speculative markets.

that is a bigger concern for 4T dollar economy, not a growth factor!

as speculator have won enormously and now would prefer short term gains!
 
Car sales growth in a depressed economic growth trajectory, are mostly false positives

after all, why would there be an increase in car sales, if economic growth was so good, before the suppression of growth rate!

further, real test of any economy is always, growth in manufacturing capacity

are these numbers to support that?!
It's not just cars.
It's two wheelers also which Indian middle class buys.
1.71 Million in August..

Did you pull that "depressed growth trajectory" theory from your behind ?.
 
It's not just cars.
It's two wheelers also which Indian middle class buys.

Did you pull that "depressed growth trajectory" theory from your behind ?.


war AH WAR!

and AH, re. two wheelers, sure, whats the absolute numbers and rise in cost, how the financing took place etc etc!
 
Car sales growth in a depressed economic growth trajectory, are mostly false positives

after all, why would there be an increase in car sales, if economic growth was so good, before the suppression of growth rate!

further, real test of any economy is always, growth in manufacturing capacity

are these numbers to support that?!
We are not relying on car sales growth to prove growth. Take wider passenger vehicles sales growth, including goods, and small vehicles like bikes they're all showing a growth.
You said manufacturing capacity, why not look at RBI's manufacturing capacity utilisation data. It have been running above their long term average, which is precisely the situation that tends to induce firms to add capacity.
Further, recently it was announced, India has achieved 10% growth rate for a quarter (or something like that!)

that could be concern not a good news!

after all, why would 4T economy need a 10% or 9% or 8% growth rate?

it is meant to survive bubbles, not be a ballon themselves!

these numbers dont make sense, sorry!

re. increase in Forex reserves, if forex has increased bec, speculative markets.

that is a bigger concern for 4T dollar economy, not a growth factor!

as speculator have won enormously and now would prefer short term gains!
What so strange about large economies growing at 10% (real)? China had similar growth rate for a decade or so. It is not unusual especially given the trajectory different sectors are taking.

If you believe it's fake then find associating data discrepancy. Something you can't fake, like exports, electricity consumption.

Forex increases for a lot of reasons. It includes debt like loans, bonds issued, deposits, asset value appreciation, remittance, export growth and more it has no connection with GDP growth. In fact remittance et al is not even counted for GDP growth.
 
We are not relying on car sales growth to prove growth. Take wider passenger vehicles sales growth, including goods, and small vehicles like bikes they're all showing a growth.
You said manufacturing capacity, why not look at RBI's manufacturing capacity utilisation data. It have been running above their long term average, which is precisely the situation that tends to induce firms to add capacity.

What so strange about large economies growing at 10% (real)? China had similar growth rate for a decade or so. It is not unusual especially given the trajectory different sectors are taking.

If you believe it's fake then find associating data discrepancy. Something you can't fake, like exports, electricity consumption.

Forex increases for a lot of reasons. It includes debt like loans, bonds issued, deposits, asset value appreciation, remittance, export growth and more it has no connection with GDP growth. In fact remittance et al is not even counted for GDP growth.


I just point out subtle and nuanced unnoticed differences

not disputing anything!

after all, had there been so much 'advances', there would have not much to hide behind and politicians would have let us known!


speculation kills growth!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

  • Back
    Top