Hardline Rabbi Says Israeli Jews Should Support Pakistan over India in a War

[clutch]

00:00 – Introduction: A Rabbi's Unexpected Position
00:42 – The Rabbi's Religious Argument: India vs. Pakistan
3:05 - When there is a war between Pakistan and India

Indian dreams vanish

 

[K2RULEZ]

It is just a relationship of convenience. There is zero match between Hinduism and Abrahamic faiths including Judaism.

The fake imported Zionist Jews like Netanyahu look at their personal interests. Even the human eating cannibals in the jungle of Amazon will be turned into an ally as long as they serve the interests.

 

[Blain2]

This is not an unexpected position. If you go by their theology, like in Islam, there is no sin bigger than idol worship or holding equals to God Almighty. This is also the reason that while Jews can visit a mosque, they cannot visit a church or a hindu temple.
In terms of the centrality of monotheism, it is Islam first and then Judaism. So lots of key things are left off on account of geo-pols and narrative of the Zionists.

 

[battalion25]

This is what I have been telling the Indians that the Jews are the last remaining monotheistic religion outside of Islam in the world.

Monotheism has faded around the world pretty much but there are still pockets where monotheistism is enjoyed.

The Israelis were relatives of the powerful Qureysh tribe which the prophet hails from thru Abraham they were bloodline cousins and Muhammad even had a jewish wife.

Today the remaining ruling standing house of Abraham include Saudi Arabia, UAE, Kuwait, Qatar, Bahrain, Jordan and Israel the leaders in these countries ruling elite claim to be descandants from Abraham. This is also why Abraham accord is called Abraham accord it is based on tribal concept.

For these who do not know who Abraham was he was the founder of the Abrahamic faiths plus his title is ´´The Friend of God´´

 

[Master Chief]

Pakistan is an ally of US, so this statement from an American Jewish rabbi is hardly surprising. After all, US is already supporting Pakistan, and Israel is an integral part of the US alliance system. So, how is Israel not already indirectly supporting Pakistan through its close alliance with the US?

Are you Indian? I genuinely can't be bothered to check your flags. But I'm sure only an Indian can come up with such a genius theory.

The Jewish rabbi is simply stating doctrine based facts drawn from his religious scriptures. His statements have nothing to do with the political alignments of either Pakistan or Bharat.

Indians will need to just suck it all up, painful as it is. Shouldn't be too difficult for you.

Do you not remember how angry Charlton Heston was in Cecil B de Mille's, The Ten Commandments, when he came down from the mountain to find a group worshipping a golden calf? Mr Heston can be very nasty when he's angry.

 

[PK781]

well.....theoretically the rabbi isn't wrong.........there is simply no acceptance of idol worship in both islam and judaism

as always, indian/india is disappointed......things just not going their way despite brown-nosing the israelis so damn much. LOL

 

[Rattle Snake]

This is what I have been telling the Indians that the Jews are the last remaining monotheistic religion outside of Islam in the world.

Monotheism has faded around the world pretty much but there are still pockets where monotheistism is enjoyed.

The Israelis were relatives of the powerful Qureysh tribe which the prophet hails from thru Abraham they were bloodline cousins and Muhammad even had a jewish wife.

Today the remaining ruling standing house of Abraham include Saudi Arabia, UAE, Kuwait, Qatar, Bahrain, Jordan and Israel the leaders in these countries ruling elite claim to be descandants from Abraham. This is also why Abraham accord is called Abraham accord it is based on tribal concept.

For these who do not know who Abraham was he was the founder of the Abrahamic faiths plus his title is ´´The Friend of God´´

Are you Indian? I genuinely can't be bothered to check your flags. But I'm sure only an Indian can come up with such a genius theory.

The Jewish rabbi is simply stating doctrine based facts drawn from his religious scriptures. His statements have nothing to do with the political alignments of either Pakistan or Bharat.

Indians will need to just suck it all up, painful as it is. Shouldn't be too difficult for you.

Do you not remember how angry Charlton Heston was in Cecil B de Mille's, The Ten Commandments, when he came down from the mountain to find a group worshipping a golden calf? Mr Heston can be very nasty when he's angry.

well.....theoretically the rabbi isn't wrong.........there is simply no acceptance of idol worship in both islam and judaism

as always, indian/india is disappointed......things just not going their way despite brown-nosing the israelis so damn much. LOL

The Jewish Rabbi specifically mentioned Pakistan as an ally, he did not mention Iran as an ally. If we go by your theory that Islam and Judaism are allies, why didn't he mention Iran?

We Indians do not dispute the fact that Pakistan is an ally of US and, therefore, an ally of Israel.

 

[Master Chief]

The Jewish Rabbi specifically mentioned Pakistan as an ally, he did not mention Iran as an ally. If we go by your theory that Islam and Judaism are allies, why didn't he mention Iran?

We Indians do not dispute the fact that Pakistan is an ally of US and, therefore, an ally of Israel.

He mentioned Pakistan because we are the natural enemy of India.

Using the pointed and highly provocative example of India's WORST known enemy, he still implied that from a religious perspective, Jews should NEVERTHELESS favour this mortal enemy of India, rather than favouring their supposed "motherland" friend, India.

Another way to look at this occurrence is that the good rabbi hyphenated our two countries.

Hope this helps your understanding.

If rabbis are not inclined to vocally support the motherland, perhaps you need to do more for phatherland?

 

[Rattle Snake]

He mentioned Pakistan because we are the natural enemy of India.

Using the pointed and highly provocative example of India's WORST known enemy, he still implied that from a religious perspective, Jews should NEVERTHELESS favour this mortal enemy of India, rather than favouring their supposed "motherland" friend, India.

Another way to look at this occurrence is that the good rabbi hyphenated our two countries.

Hope this helps your understanding.

If rabbis are not inclined to vocally support the motherland, perhaps you need to do more for phatherland?

You are trying to interpret his statement entirely through the India-Pakistan rivalry, but that doesn't explain the choice of Pakistan as an example of an ally. If there is no special relationship or strategic understanding between the two, why was Pakistan singled out in the first place?

Pakistan being publicly hostile towards Israel doesn't rule out undisclosed diplomatic or strategic ties. Public rhetoric and behind-the-scenes relationships are two very different things.

And abusing India and Hindus is also to appease Pakistan and further strengthen the Pakistan-Israel alliance.

They need Pakistan in the war against Iran, just as they needed Pakistan during the war in Afghanistan. After all, Pakistan shares a border with Iran and is also part of the Mecca Pact alongside Saudi Arabia and Turkey.

 

[lightning f57]

You are trying to interpret his statement entirely through the India-Pakistan rivalry, but that doesn't explain the choice of Pakistan as an example of an ally. If there is no special relationship or strategic understanding between the two, why was Pakistan singled out in the first place?

Pakistan being publicly hostile towards Israel doesn't rule out undisclosed diplomatic or strategic ties. Public rhetoric and behind-the-scenes relationships are two very different things.

And abusing India and Hindus is also to appease Pakistan and further strengthen the Pakistan-Israel alliance.

They need Pakistan in the war against Iran, just as they needed Pakistan during the war in Afghanistan. After all, Pakistan shares a border with Iran and is also part of the Mecca Pact alongside Saudi Arabia and Turkey.

I think you are missing the point. His making a theological argument which aligns with Islamic principles as well. Belief in something else other than the one creator is the highest level of sin, greater than wiping out all of humanity. That is the point he makes. Israel today is not a religious state, its an ethno nationalist state.

 

[Master Chief]

You are trying to interpret his statement entirely through the India-Pakistan rivalry, but that doesn't explain the choice of Pakistan as an example of an ally. If there is no special relationship or strategic understanding between the two, why was Pakistan singled out in the first place?

Pakistan being publicly hostile towards Israel doesn't rule out undisclosed diplomatic or strategic ties. Public rhetoric and behind-the-scenes relationships are two very different things.

And abusing India and Hindus is also to appease Pakistan and further strengthen the Pakistan-Israel alliance.

They need Pakistan in the war against Iran, just as they needed Pakistan during the war in Afghanistan. After all, Pakistan shares a border with Iran and is also part of the Mecca Pact alongside Saudi Arabia and Turkey.

Pakistan is the perfect example of a country that is politically HOSTILE to Israel but that RELIGIOUSLY IS ALIGNED so much so that religious Jews, such as the good rabbi here, will be inclined to favour Pakistan over India, even though they are citizens of Israel.

To reiterate....The precise point he is making is that despite political hostility, religious similarities will cause him to favour Pakistan against his nation's political friend, India.

Do you need it explaining again? Or have the anti-retardation meds finally kicked in?

 

[Rattle Snake]

I think you are missing the point. His making a theological argument which aligns with Islamic principles as well. Belief in something else other than the one creator is the highest level of sin, greater than wiping out all of humanity. That is the point he makes. Israel today is not a religious state, its an ethno nationalist state.

Pakistan is the perfect example of a country that is politically HOSTILE to Israel but that RELIGIOUSLY IS ALIGNED so much so that religious Jews, such as the good rabbi here, will be inclined to favour Pakistan over India, even though they are citizens of Israel.

To reiterate....The precise point he is making is that despite political hostility, religious similarities will cause him to favour Pakistan against his nation's political friend, India.

Do you need it explaining again? Or have the anti-retardation meds finally kicked in?

I think you are deliberately overlooking the bigger picture. If his argument is purely theological and aligns with Islamic principles, then why is he specifically expressing support for Pakistan and not Iran or other Muslim-majority countries?

You cannot conveniently separate his theological argument from its political implications, especially when he explicitly identifies Pakistan as an ally. Furthermore, calling Israel an ethno-nationalist state does not change the fact that religious and political interests often overlap. The question is not whether Judaism and Islam share certain theological principles; the question is why an Israeli Jewish rabbi is singling out Pakistan as an ally and what political message that sends.

 

[El Sidd]

Very hurtful and hate filled message.

Hopefully this person is some fringe element just like every other youtuber on Clutchs algorithm.

 

[Rattle Snake]

Very hurtful and hate filled message.

Hopefully this person is some fringe element just like every other youtuber on Clutchs algorithm.

I didn't find the Jewish Rabbi to be hateful. It was the Pakistani Muslim reacting to the video who was making hateful comments against Hindus and Hinduism. But that's not surprising.

Anyone making similarly hateful comments against Muslims or Christians in India will end up in jail. But this is Pakistan, so such behaviour is expected.

 

[El Sidd]

I didn't find the Jewish Rabbi to be hateful. It was the Pakistani Muslim reacting to the video who was making hateful comments against Hindus and Hinduism. But that's not surprising.

Anyone making similarly hateful comments against Muslims or Christians in India will end up in jail. But this is Pakistan, so such behaviour is expected.

This whole trivialising of wars where millions of lives are in question is quite hateful.

In India they have a whole music industry dedicated to the hate genre.