Whatever

Its fascinating to me from your and Joe's accounts how languages are actually codified and engineered much like a free flowing river being diverted by dykes and channels. As opposed to natural evolution of terrain and stratum and flow dynamics.

Thanks for the share. You are right of course. Such discussions are a welcome interlude in normal defence forum traffic.

Cheers, Doc

Yes Vedic Sanskrit and Old Avestan (specifically their continued liturgies) offer essentially direct time machines/portals.....unavailable to any other language to this degree "upstream". Because of the liturgical importance attached to the retention of the intrinsic sound as sacred dating to pre-writing era (a feature shared with the Jews and their original oral transmission of the Torah, but those phonologies are lost due to their specific intense trial and tribulation..... and can only be reconstructed in a backwards way from what we have now regd mostly medieval "classical" Hebrew - which inevitably leaves a lot of gaps/doubts on the specific sounds, but the meaning is near fully understood since we are using written records, scripts and sound interpolation). Ancient Greek also is reconstructed backwards phonologically this way (given the homeric hymns + epics on record etc).

The India-China relations thread will be interesting one to follow for you and others with time too. As Chinese for example (without such time portal) relies on things like rhyme tables (of older extant written work, with the known phonologies of today or of the time of analysis done earlier by a Chinese linguist scholar say in Qing or Ming period etc with regards to the Tang , Han et al.)

That's how we are able to deduce pretty substantial phonological shifts that occured between types of Chinese (causing the unending debate if they are dialect vs language, again with its contours of politics involved)...because things "rhyme" better (as written in the old text) with one set of phonologies compared to another set....and thus say middle or old chinese can be reconstructed to some degree.

There is a whole interesting study as well (using rhyme tables again) regarding when tones appeared (in middle chinese) as substitutes for coda-phonologies that were dropped from old chinese (which is largely agreed upon as a non-tonal language).

But with presence of Vedic Sanskrit and Avestan (in respective liturgies, and retained faithfully and as unbroken as possible), there is a unique direct overpass highway (given preservation and transmittance of original sound and original phonology faithfully) that is a portal to the phonology directly....that bypasses what every other language has to do (and needs writing to have commenced as well).
 
Election season DP change - although I have a strong feeling that this farce election would bring even more instability
 
Faith is an acquired attribute

No it is not.

Not per my belief and that of my people. And I guess it is the same for Hindus and Jews as well.

Answered you here because I made a promise to Musings.

Cheers, Doc
 
Also @Developereo

Ashkenazi Jews are not exactly inorganic converts.

They have maternal Jewish ancestry, with European fathers.

Blood

Faith

Soil

Cheers, Doc
 
Also @Developereo

Ashkenazi Jews are not exactly inorganic converts.

They have maternal Jewish ancestry, with European fathers.

Blood

Faith

Soil

Cheers, Doc

Well, before we even go into who has how much Canaanite DNA, this whole concept that genetics confers land ownership rights is your thesis, and it is based on faith so I am not sure what legal validity it has.

It is not much different than the Zionist claim that Abraham's Covenant reserved that land for them.

Sure, so what?
 
LOL.

@Developereo
@vsdoc

You've both made powerful points, but guess what can happen if the pi-dogs get to it.
Just sayin'.

For me, Doc's point contains a peculiarly poignancy.

Regarding the poignancy, you should then go to the thread where this discourse started and was moved from.

I was pretty direct.

And then disengaged.

Cheers, Doc
 
Regarding the poignancy, you should then go to the thread where this discourse started and was moved from.

I was pretty direct.

And then disengaged.

Cheers, Doc
Ah, I see.

I am from the village of Bejgaon, in the sub-division Munshiganj, district Dhaka.
On my mother's side, we are from Kulokathi, in district Barisal.

We are not wanted there any more.

We did not want to be wanted at the cost that was asked.

So here I am, reading your posts.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Latest Posts

Back
Top