BJP Labels All Muslims in India As Traitors

My Urdu isn't great but I thought "namak haram" meant ungrateful as opposed to traitor.🤔
 
No Different Than Us Labelling Afghans As Namak Haram
There is a significant difference. Indian Muslims are "Indians", they are not some outsiders/refugees.

*Some* Afghans being branded as such is different because in Pakistan, they are foreign nationals living on the soil, taking from it, and abusing the hospitality and in extreme cases, joining hands with inimical forces against Pakistan and murdering/destroying Pakistanis/Pakistani property.
 
No Different Than Us Labelling Afghans As Namak Haram
Different.

Afghans are not Pakistanis. They are guests in Pakistan and should behave as such, i.e. with gratitude for the hospitality offered to them.

Now Indian muslims are Indians. Their ancestors built that nation. Who does chai walla think he is insulting them and degrading them to a caste level beneath dalits? Indian muslims have every right guiding civilisational discourse in that nation state, yet, they remain fully dalitised, beyond recourse even.
 
So let me get this straight, a "senior journalist" says that a "minister" of govt (no names, no designation, no official bayaan) said that Muslims are namak haram and in the same program a SP leader says BJP and RSS are the biggest namak haram and the conclusion is that entire BJP is saying all Muslims are namak haram....

The level of IQ is there but the will to apply is not or should I say this is deliberate misrepresentation - matlab kuch bhi... *slow clap*

I would just say - can you point one govt policy which is discriminating against Muslims? Any one bayaan (on official or unofficial channel) of Modi or any of the top cabinet members? You won't find because that's not how India operates. India elevates a scientist such as APJ to top position while we all know what Pakistan did with Abdus Salam. Guys seriously - do better
 
So let me get this straight, a "senior journalist" says that a "minister" of govt (no names, no designation, no official bayaan) said that Muslims are namak haram and in the same program a SP leader says BJP and RSS are the biggest namak haram and the conclusion is that entire BJP is saying all Muslims are namak haram....

The level of IQ is there but the will to apply is not or should I say this is deliberate misrepresentation - matlab kuch bhi... *slow clap*

I would just say - can you point one govt policy which is discriminating against Muslims? Any one bayaan (on official or unofficial channel) of Modi or any of the top cabinet members? You won't find because that's not how India operates. India elevates a scientist such as APJ to top position while we all know what Pakistan did with Abdus Salam. Guys seriously - do better
Unwise to comment on the IQ of others when your government expunges entire segments of established subcontinental history from your school syllabi.
 
Unwise to comment on the IQ of others when your government expunges entire segments of established subcontinental history from your school syllabi.

That is an example of lack of IQ application from Indian govt (in particular Ministry of Education). However, I grew up at a time when the "expunged" sections were taught and discussed at length. In any case, can you/fellow members respond to the substantive part of argument which is:
1. Can you point one govt policy which is discriminating against Muslims? Any one bayaan (on official or unofficial channel) of Modi or any of the top cabinet members?

2. How do you see the contrast between India elevating a scientist such as APJ to top position while Absum Salam leaving Pakistan for good?
 
That is an example of lack of IQ application from Indian govt (in particular Ministry of Education). However, I grew up at a time when the "expunged" sections were taught and discussed at length. In any case, can you/fellow members respond to the substantive part of argument which is:
1. Can you point one govt policy which is discriminating against Muslims? Any one bayaan (on official or unofficial channel) of Modi or any of the top cabinet members?

2. How do you see the contrast between India elevating a scientist such as APJ to top position while Absum Salam leaving Pakistan for good?
I already responded to (1). There are plenty of examples of government policy in Hindustan that targets Muslims. I gave you one but evidently you are slow on the uptake.

Maybe you're new to the forum? We have had numerous threads in years gone by relating to these matters.

State authorities in India have implemented laws and policies which clearly discriminate against Muslims, including the anti-conversion law, bans on wearing headscarves in school and the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), all of which have existed for many years now. More recently there have been "love jihad" legislations and moves to dissolve waqf ownership rights.

We could cite the state sanctioned destruction of Babri masjid and the refusal to reconstruct it but to instead impose some vile "victory temple" on its site as a further act of "discrimination", though many would argue that the following pogroms were more akin to an act of ethnoreligious cleansing rather than simple "discrimination".

As for number (2), these points are of little relevance unless Delhi irons out the discrimination against hundreds of millions of aam aadmi Muslims. Naturally, some top politicians, scientists and bollywood trash will be protected from more direct impacts of islamophobia by virtue of their power and wealth. The status of Kalam or Shah Rukh Khan or Assaduddin Owaisi does nothing for the average musulman of Hindustan.
 
I already responded to (1). There are plenty of examples of government policy in Hindustan that targets Muslims. I gave you one but evidently you are slow on the uptake.

Maybe you're new to the forum? We have had numerous threads in years gone by relating to these matters.

State authorities in India have implemented laws and policies which clearly discriminate against Muslims, including the anti-conversion law, bans on wearing headscarves in school and the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), all of which have existed for many years now. More recently there have been "love jihad" legislations and moves to dissolve waqf ownership rights.

We could cite the state sanctioned destruction of Babri masjid and the refusal to reconstruct it but to instead impose some vile "victory temple" on its site as a further act of "discrimination", though many would argue that the following pogroms were more akin to an act of ethnoreligious cleansing rather than simple "discrimination".

As for number (2), these points are of little relevance unless Delhi irons out the discrimination against hundreds of millions of aam aadmi Muslims. Naturally, some top politicians, scientists and bollywood trash will be protected from more direct impacts of islamophobia by virtue of their power and wealth. The status of Kalam or Shah Rukh Khan or Assaduddin Owaisi does nothing for the average musulman of Hindustan.
Ok. Maybe the nuances of these laws and specific legislative decisions haven't been discussed on merit as there is nothing religious about them. For e.g., CAA is not for one religion. Yes it probably impact more Muslims vs other religions but doesn't mean its against one particular religion. Similarly the head scarf issue is a total non-issue as this is "local premisis" in application not any area/state/region wide.

However, one law i.e., abolishing triple talaq is against Muslims primarily. And that was passed for benefit to Muslim women and progressive men.

Now what I have shared Indian perspective. Can you answer:

1) How do you see flight of Abdul Salem and ahemadias at large in Pakistan?
2) How do you reconcile the dichotomy of your protests towards India with the fact that no non-muslim can lead the nation (no matter how qualified) ? Should Pakistan reform its laws?
3) How do you defend blasphemy laws and the way these laws are implemented? Doesn't blasphemy laws for one religion a) show superiority of a certain religion b) make citizens following other religions 2nd class citizens c) open door to abuse

Thanks,
 
Ok. Maybe the nuances of these laws and specific legislative decisions haven't been discussed on merit as there is nothing religious about them. For e.g., CAA is not for one religion. Yes it probably impact more Muslims vs other religions but doesn't mean its against one particular religion. Similarly the head scarf issue is a total non-issue as this is "local premisis" in application not any area/state/region wide.

However, one law i.e., abolishing triple talaq is against Muslims primarily. And that was passed for benefit to Muslim women and progressive men.

Now what I have shared Indian perspective. Can you answer:

1) How do you see flight of Abdul Salem and ahemadias at large in Pakistan?
2) How do you reconcile the dichotomy of your protests towards India with the fact that no non-muslim can lead the nation (no matter how qualified) ? Should Pakistan reform its laws?
3) How do you defend blasphemy laws and the way these laws are implemented? Doesn't blasphemy laws for one religion a) show superiority of a certain religion b) make citizens following other religions 2nd class citizens c) open door to abuse

Thanks,
So you simply deny the existence of any problem? Well there isn't much to discuss beyond that then is there?

As I already speculated, you seem new to the forum, probably to academic discourse altogether. If you are satisfied with India's trajectory, good for you. We are also very pleased with BJP's performance hitherto. Whoever told you we "protest" about it? We merely point out the hypocrisy of a self styled "secular democracy" wherein so little of the narrative of 20% of its population is given credence or due respect.

By the way, triple talaq?? For real?Pakistan abolished this ages ago.

What are you, barely one step ahead of your new buddies Afghanistan?
 
So you simply deny the existence of any problem? Well there isn't much to discuss beyond that then is there?

As I already speculated, you seem new to the forum, probably to academic discourse altogether. If you are satisfied with India's trajectory, good for you. We are also very pleased with BJP's performance hitherto. Whoever told you we "protest" about it? We merely point out the hypocrisy of a self styled "secular democracy" wherein so little of the narrative of 20% of its population is given credence or due respect.

By the way, triple talaq?? For real?Pakistan abolished this ages ago.

What are you, barely one step ahead of your new buddies Afghanistan?
I never did - all I claimed is no government law based on religion. I have already opined on the disconnect between Muslims and other communities in India.
Either way we can agree to disagree.

Good on Pakistan for abolishing triple talaq. I am aware of Pakistan being ahead of India here. Congratulations.

Don't deflect on three questions I had raised.Putting them below again.
1) How do you see flight of Abdul Salem and ahemadias at large in Pakistan?
2) How do you reconcile the dichotomy of your protests towards India with the fact that no non-muslim can lead the nation (no matter how qualified) ? Should Pakistan reform its laws?
3) How do you defend blasphemy laws and the way these laws are implemented? Doesn't blasphemy laws for one religion a) show superiority of a certain religion b) make citizens following other religions 2nd class citizens c) open door to abuse

And if you don't have a POV, before pointing fingers for once, look deep down within.
 
There is a significant difference. Indian Muslims are "Indians", they are not some outsiders/refugees.

*Some* Afghans being branded as such is different because in Pakistan, they are foreign nationals living on the soil, taking from it, and abusing the hospitality and in extreme cases, joining hands with inimical forces against Pakistan and murdering/destroying Pakistanis/Pakistani property.

Thank you so much for enlightening me, I would never have known 🤣
 
Different.

Afghans are not Pakistanis. They are guests in Pakistan and should behave as such, i.e. with gratitude for the hospitality offered to them.

Now Indian muslims are Indians. Their ancestors built that nation. Who does chai walla think he is insulting them and degrading them to a caste level beneath dalits? Indian muslims have every right guiding civilisational discourse in that nation state, yet, they remain fully dalitised, beyond recourse even.


When you stay somewhere for 40 plus years, you are no longer a guest you practically become a native for all intents and purposes.There is an entire generation of Afghan refugees that have never seen Afghanistan in their life.All the know is Pakistan.

Our establishment likes to tout what a great charity they did by opening the borders for them. How about telling the country how many dollars they have earned destroying their country and forcing them to become refugees in the first place whether it was Afghan jihad or War on Terror.


No doubt there are criminals and subversive element in Afghan community.But many Afghans have started businesses invested and contributed to the economy
 

Users who are viewing this thread

  • Country Watch Latest

    Back
    Top