Bangladesh - India News / Discussions

[LeonBlack08]

I wonder how many Bengali speaking Muslims rejected the two nation theory and chose to remain in India, despite East Pakistan (Bangladesh) being right there and massive riots in Bengal during partition.

If Bangladeshis are to be believed, then millions of Bengali speaking Muslims found in the Bangladesh's neighboring states rejected the two nation theory and chose to remain in India.

There are plenty of Bengali speaking Muslims in India. They have always been there. Just because it doesn't suit your belief system doesn't mean you can push them out into Bangladesh.

Provide proper documentation and Bangladesh will repatriate people who illegally migrated. That has been Bangladeshi official stance before and even now. Foreign ministry and BGB has been reiterating this point.

If you can't provide proof, then you don't get to push people out like you guys are trying to do so. You have to keep them to yourselves.

Would you like it if we push out 20 million Bangladeshi Hindus into India? Just because no Hindu is supposed to remain in Bangladesh after the violent riots in 1947?

 

[Jaeger]

There are plenty of Bengali speaking Muslims in India. They have always been there. Just because it doesn't suit your belief system doesn't mean you can push them out into Bangladesh.

Provide proper documentation and Bangladesh will repatriate people who illegally migrated. That has been Bangladeshi official stance before and even now. Foreign ministry and BGB has been reiterating this point.

If you can't provide proof, then you don't get to push people out like you guys are trying to do so. You have to keep them to yourselves.

Would you like it if we push out 20 million Bangladeshi Hindus into India? Just because no Hindu is supposed to remain in Bangladesh after the violent riots in 1947?

What proper documentation do illegal migrants possess?

What documentation do you need?

There were millions of Muslims in India who remained after partition( but in the interior), but not in border states with Pakistan, especially the states which were divided between India and Pakistan, namely Bengal and Punjab, as these states saw most of the rioting of the partition, these states saw almost complete population exchanges or decimation at the hand of rioters.

There were 50 million refugees at partition who either went from India to Pakistan or vice versa and most of them in these two states.

It defies common sense that millions of Muslims will choose to remain in India in states bordering Bangladesh at partition and complete negates logic behind formation of your country.

 

[Afif]

What proper documentation do illegal migrants possess?

What documentation do you need?

There were millions of Muslims in India who remained after partition( but in the interior), but not in border states with Pakistan, especially the states which were divided between India and Pakistan, namely Bengal and Punjab, as these states saw most of the rioting of the partition, these states saw almost complete population exchanges or decimation at the hand of rioters.

There were 50 million refugees at partition who either went from India to Pakistan or vice versa and most of them in these two states.

It defies common sense that millions of Muslims will choose to remain in India in states bordering Bangladesh at partition and complete negates logic behind formation of your country.

It also defies common sense that millions of Hindus will choose to remain in state bordering india after all the violence and stuff. Yet here we are with 15 millions Hindus in BD.

 

[X-ray Papa]

What proper documentation do illegal migrants possess?

What documentation do you need?

There were millions of Muslims in India who remained after partition( but in the interior), but not in border states with Pakistan, especially the states which were divided between India and Pakistan, namely Bengal and Punjab, as these states saw most of the rioting of the partition, these states saw almost complete population exchanges or decimation at the hand of rioters.

There were 50 million refugees at partition who either went from India to Pakistan or vice versa and most of them in these two states.

It defies common sense that millions of Muslims will choose to remain in India in states bordering Bangladesh at partition and complete negates logic behind formation of your country.

Don’t cry like a bitch when we kick the BD Hindus out.

 

[lightoftruth]

There are plenty of Bengali speaking Muslims in India. They have always been there. Just because it doesn't suit your belief system doesn't mean you can push them out into Bangladesh.

Provide proper documentation and Bangladesh will repatriate people who illegally migrated. That has been Bangladeshi official stance before and even now. Foreign ministry and BGB has been reiterating this point.

Would you like it if we push out 20 million Bangladeshi Hindus into India? Just because no Hindu is supposed to remain in Bangladesh after the violent riots in 1947?

"In the case of Bangladesh, as I had informed you earlier, we have referred 2,680 cases, or more than 2,680 cases, to the Bangladeshi side, for them to verify the nationality of those people whose names we have handed over," External Affairs Ministry's spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said in response to a query during his weekly media briefing in New Delhi.

"Once this nationality verification is done, then we'll be in a position to deport these people, these nationals of Bangladesh. In many cases, I had told you earlier that this verification is pending for more than five years or so. And we expect that we will receive an early response from Bangladesh on this particular issue," he added

https://www.telegraphindia.com/indi...sh-for-verification/cid/2163081#goog_rewarded

Bangladesh is deliberately delaying repatriation, thus making "push-ins" perfectly justified.

Illegal bangadeshi muslims will have no space in India.

We made a law called CAA to accept persecuted Hindus of Bangladesh, they are welcome.

 

[Jaeger]

Don’t cry like a bitch when we kick the BD Hindus out.

You are driven, by communal hatred of your Hindus, you would drive out your own citizens to another country and that is fine by us, this government will accept them.

Nor do you have any love for Muslims even if they were own citizens and illegal migrated to neighboring country.

But in India, our Muslim citizens are as Indian as any, we don't want them anywhere but in India.

What we don't want Bangladeshis illegal migrants coming in guise of Indian Muslims.

If it were up to me, I wouldn't have accepted a single Bangladeshi illegal migrant be he a Hindu or Muslim.

 

[Afif]

You are driven, by communal hatred

Most of the Hindus are today.

 

[Jaeger]

Most of the Hindus are today.

That is not true. Just take this forum as an example, you won't find a single Indian, regardless of religion hating Indian Muslims.

However you will find many Bangladeshi and Pakistani Muslims who have hatred of Hindus, may that be thier own citizens.

 

[Afif]

That is not true.

The things that your elected and rulling party politicians says. Those are very explicit and in large numbers.

 

[Jaeger]

The things that your elected and rulling party politicians says. Those are very explicit and in large numbers.

This ruling party has been in power in the centre for 13 years now, how many Indian Muslims have emigrated to Pakistan or Bangladesh?(countries which claim that there only reason for existence is to accommodate the Muslims of the subcontinent).

How many communal riots have there been?

India is a very pluralistic society, will always will be.

 

[LeonBlack08]

What proper documentation do illegal migrants possess?

What documentation do you need?

There were millions of Muslims in India who remained after partition( but in the interior), but not in border states with Pakistan, especially the states which were divided between India and Pakistan, namely Bengal and Punjab, as these states saw most of the rioting of the partition, these states saw almost complete population exchanges or decimation at the hand of rioters.

There were 50 million refugees at partition who either went from India to Pakistan or vice versa and most of them in these two states.

It defies common sense that millions of Muslims will choose to remain in India in states bordering Bangladesh at partition and complete negates logic behind formation of your country.

Are you from West Bengal? Most definitely not. Clearly you have no idea how many Muslims stayed back in India post partition.

It may defy your common sense, but plenty of Muslims and Hindus stayed put and didn't migrate in 1947. They chose to stay where their roots are.

Will you accept Bangladesh pushing 20 million or so Hindus into India?

Your lack of knowledge about the history of the people in this region doesn't change the reality.

As for documentation - the burden is on you to prove they are not Indian. You cannot just simply push people into foreign country because they don't subscribe to your Hindutva ideology.

 

[LeonBlack08]

"In the case of Bangladesh, as I had informed you earlier, we have referred 2,680 cases, or more than 2,680 cases, to the Bangladeshi side, for them to verify the nationality of those people whose names we have handed over," External Affairs Ministry's spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said in response to a query during his weekly media briefing in New Delhi.

"Once this nationality verification is done, then we'll be in a position to deport these people, these nationals of Bangladesh. In many cases, I had told you earlier that this verification is pending for more than five years or so. And we expect that we will receive an early response from Bangladesh on this particular issue," he added

https://www.telegraphindia.com/indi...sh-for-verification/cid/2163081#goog_rewarded

Bangladesh is deliberately delaying repatriation, thus making "push-ins" perfectly justified.

Illegal bangadeshi muslims will have no space in India.

We made a law called CAA to accept persecuted Hindus of Bangladesh, they are welcome.

Sell your lies elsewhere. Bangladesh repatriated thousands through proper channels over the years.

Here is a small example - https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/news/91-bangladeshi-fishermen-return-india-4192736

You keep trying with your illegal push in, and we will push back. All the best.

You definitely won't be winning hearts in Bangladesh with your push ins.

 

[X-ray Papa]

Are you from West Bengal? Most definitely not. Clearly you have no idea how many Muslims stayed back in India post partition.

It may defy your common sense, but plenty of Muslims and Hindus stayed put and didn't migrate in 1947. They chose to stay where their roots are.

Will you accept Bangladesh pushing 20 million or so Hindus into India?

Your lack of knowledge about the history of the people in this region doesn't change the reality.

As for documentation - the burden is on you to prove they are not Indian. You cannot just simply push people into foreign country because they don't subscribe to your Hindutva ideology.

Not only that, they themselves also don’t have documentation for being a Bangladeshi. So why should we accept people who can’t prove to be a Bangladeshi?

 

[X-ray Papa]

Sell your lies elsewhere. Bangladesh repatriated thousands through proper channels over the years.

Here is a small example - https://www.thedailystar.net/news/bangladesh/news/91-bangladeshi-fishermen-return-india-4192736

You keep trying with your illegal push in, and we will push back. All the best.

You definitely won't be winning hearts in Bangladesh with your push ins.

We should take Israel as the role model of being a well equipped military. Small but packs a punch.

The lack of a strong military is the reason why all these shit is happening.

 

[LeonBlack08]

We should take Israel as the role model of being a well equipped military. Small but packs a punch.

The lack of a strong military is the reason why all these shit is happening.

Israel is not a role model to follow for any country.

Without the limitless US aids they would be nothing. We don't have such luxury.