If the Chinese civil war's result were reversed, would "democratic ROC" give up the sovereignty over Taiwan?

Beijingwalker

VIP Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2011
Messages
91,330
Reaction score
112,587
Reputation
2,290.9
Country of Origin
Country of Residence
If the Chinese civil war's result were reversed, would "democratic ROC" give up the sovereignty over Taiwan?

Food for thought. If the Chinese civil war's result were reversed, ROC retained the control of mainland China and communists were defeated and fled to Taiwan. Would the " democratic" Republic of China ( ROC) relinquish its sovereignty claim over communists occupied Taiwan?

Map of The Republic of China
alx1avammlp31_proc.jpg
 
If the Chinese civil war's result were reversed, would "democratic ROC" give up the sovereignty over Taiwan?

A very hypothetical question that would be impossible to determine.
 

Retreat of the government of Republic of China to Taiwan​

As the defeated Nationalists fled to Taiwan, they stripped China of liquid assets including gold, silver, and the country's dollar reserves.

The KMT also retreated with artifacts, which are kept mostly in the National Palace Museum in Taipei, Taiwan.

Chiang Kai-shek's mission to take gold from China was held secretly because, according to Wu Sing-yung, the entire mission was operated by Chiang himself.

Only Chiang and Wu's father, who was the head of Military Finance for the KMT government, knew about the expenditure and moving of gold to Taiwan and almost all orders by Chiang were issued verbally. Wu stated that even the finance minister had no power over the final expenditure and transfer.

The written record was kept as the top military secret by Chiang in the Taipei Presidential Palace and the declassified archives only became available to the public more than 40 years after his death in April 1975.

It is a widely held belief that the gold brought to Taiwan were used to lay foundations for the Taiwanese economy and government. Some also believe that after six months of the gold operation by Chiang, the New Taiwanese dollar was launched, which replaced the old Taiwanese dollar at a ratio of one to 40,000. It is believed that 800,000 taels of gold were used to stabilize the economy which had been suffering from hyperinflation since 1945.

However, these beliefs turned out to be mistaken. According to a memoir written by Zhou Hong-tao, a long-term aide-de-camp of Chiang, the gold was consumed very fast after being brought to Taiwan and in less than two years 80% was already consumed for the funds and provisions for the troops.

The National Palace Museum claims that in 1948 when China was going through its Civil War, executive director Chu Chia-hua and others (Wang Shijie, Fu Ssu-nien, Xu Hong-Bao (Chinese: 徐洪宝), Li Ji (Chinese: 李济), and Han Lih-wu) discussed shipping masterpieces to Taiwan for the artifacts' safety.

There are different opinions on treasures that are at Taiwan's National Palace Museum. Some in China view the relocation as looting. Others believe these treasures have been accidentally protected, and might have been lost forever due to the Four Olds campaign during the Cultural Revolution.

Many historians believe that the treasure was taken to Taiwan by the Nationalists to keep it safe from the CCP.Others believe that Taiwan is still part of Chinese sovereign territory so the relocation is not an issue.

 
Last edited:
They took away everything from the mainland China when they left :cry: :cry:, China had been so poor for so long for a reason.
 
They don't even give up The South China Sea, let alone the whole China.

That whole area has been contentious for a long time between many countries, and into today.

Please note I am not saying if anyone is right or wrong in their claims, whatever they might be.
 
That whole area has been contentious for a long time between many countries, and into today.

Please note I am not saying if anyone is right or wrong in their claims, whatever they might be.
But it's ROC made the first claim, if PRC didn't follow this claim, it would lose the support from the Chinese general population. If western media wants to blame someone, go after the initiator, not the follower.
 
But it's ROC made the first claim, if PRC didn't follow this claim, it would lose the support from the Chinese general population. If western media wants to blame someone, go after the initiator, not the follower.

Both sides will make claims that suit their own views and internal audiences. Nothing new or surprising here.
 
I always thought Taiwan is far more territorial than China.
They still insist that Mongolia and part of Russia and half of Tajikstan are part of ROC. They still have Xinjiang and Tibet bureaus although they don't control those lands.
 
They still insist that Mongolia and part of Russia and half of Tajikstan are part of ROC. They still have Xinjiang and Tibet offices although they don't control those lands.

As well as part of Tajikistan which PRC relinquished.
 

Retreat of the government of Republic of China to Taiwan​

As the defeated Nationalists fled to Taiwan, they stripped China of liquid assets including gold, silver, and the country's dollar reserves.

The KMT also retreated with artifacts, which are kept mostly in the National Palace Museum in Taipei, Taiwan.
Taiwan has nothing to be proud of being one of the "four Asian tigers", they robbed everything from mainland China and their prosperity was built upon the sweat and blood of their mainland countrymen who created those robbed wealth.
 
They still insist that Mongolia and part of Russia and half of Tajikstan are part of ROC. They still have Xinjiang and Tibet bureaus although they don't control those lands.

Taiwan is very territorial.
 
For decades Taiwan accuses PRC of giving up Chinese traditional lands.

When China dropped claim to the eastern half of Heixiazi island nearly every Taiwanese had a heart attack.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top