India's Most Advanced Nuclear Reactor Approaches Finish Line

DDG-80

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2023
Messages
2,848
Reaction score
5,557
Country of Origin
Country of Residence
1722528246469.png
India is close to completing its most advanced nuclear plant, marking a major step forward in the country’s nuclear energy programme.

The Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor (PFBR) at Kalpakkam in the southern state of Tamil Nadu has received approval from the country's atomic regulator to begin loading nuclear fuel.

The PFBR is a 500MW liquid sodium-cooled reactor which has been in development for the past 20 years. This approval marks the start of a controlled chain reaction in India's most advanced and complex nuclear reactor.

While there have been concerns over the use of sodium, a hazardous material, as a coolant, the country’s atomic board said it has conducted safety reviews and assessments of the PFBR, complemented by periodic inspections.

Once operational, India will join Russia as the only two countries in the world with commercially operating fast breeder reactors.

“It is a huge milestone for India’s self-reliant atomic energy programme,” Dinesh Kumar Shukla, chairman of the Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB) said, according to NDTV.

Mr Shukla said the PFBR is an “inherently safe reactor”.

The PFBR has been entirely designed and constructed domestically, with contributions from over 200 Indian industries, keeping the Indian government’s push for self-reliance in mind.

Due to its complexity and the need for indigenous technology, the project has faced delays and cost overruns, now amounting to ₹68,400m (£651.43m).

The Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) states that the PFBR, a third-generation reactor with passive safety features, ensures safe shutdowns in emergencies. It utilises spent fuel from India's nuclear programme, reducing nuclear waste, and the need for geological disposal.

Despite its advanced technology, the PFBR's capital and electricity costs are comparable to other nuclear and conventional power plants.

The PFBR's approval also signifies India’s use of plutonium as a nuclear fuel and paves the way for the future use of thorium, a resource in which India has abundant reserves.

Unlike uranium, which is limited in India, thorium presents an opportunity for long-term energy independence, potentially lasting over 300 years. Experts believe that mastering the technology to use thorium could secure India's energy future.

Fast breeder reactors, like the PFBR, are unique because they generate more fuel than they consume, earning them the reputation of being an almost limitless energy source.

The term "fast" refers to the high-energy fast neutrons used in these reactors. India already operates a Fast Breeder Test Reactor (FBTR) at the same location, which has been functional for 39 years.

The board's approval allows for the commencement of fuel loading and low-power physics experiments, with the reactor expected to become operational in the coming months.

The PFBR will initially use Uranium-Plutonium Mixed Oxide (MOX) fuel. A uranium-238 "blanket" surrounding the core will produce more fuel through nuclear transmutation. This process, known as breeding, is what gives these reactors their name.

In the future, thorium-232 may also be used as a blanket, creating fissile uranium-233 through transmutation, which will be utilised in the third stage of India's nuclear programme. This stage is crucial for harnessing India's vast thorium reserves.

Nuclear energy is considered a reliable and low-carbon source of electricity, helping to reduce greenhouse gas emissions that cause climate crisis and diversifying energy supply. However, there are concerns regarding safety and waste that researchers are trying to overcome with new technology.

Recently China unveiled the world’s first “meltdown-proof” nuclear power plant.

So far, nuclear energy only accounts for 3.11 per cent of the country’s total power generation. But India aims to have nuclear power account for nearly 9 per cent of its electricity by 2047 and it is rapidly investing in the technology.

While presenting India’s latest annual budget, finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman told parliament that nuclear energy would “form a very significant part of the energy mix” for India’s development.

The government plans to increase India’s nuclear power capacity from 6,780MW to 22,480MW by 2031. This will involve building 18 new reactors that can produce a total of 13.8GW of electricity. After PFBR, two more fast breeder reactors are in the pipeline.
 
View attachment 57687
India is close to completing its most advanced nuclear plant, marking a major step forward in the country’s nuclear energy programme.

The Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor (PFBR) at Kalpakkam in the southern state of Tamil Nadu has received approval from the country's atomic regulator to begin loading nuclear fuel.

The PFBR is a 500MW liquid sodium-cooled reactor which has been in development for the past 20 years. This approval marks the start of a controlled chain reaction in India's most advanced and complex nuclear reactor.

While there have been concerns over the use of sodium, a hazardous material, as a coolant, the country’s atomic board said it has conducted safety reviews and assessments of the PFBR, complemented by periodic inspections.

Once operational, India will join Russia as the only two countries in the world with commercially operating fast breeder reactors.

“It is a huge milestone for India’s self-reliant atomic energy programme,” Dinesh Kumar Shukla, chairman of the Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB) said, according to NDTV.

Mr Shukla said the PFBR is an “inherently safe reactor”.

The PFBR has been entirely designed and constructed domestically, with contributions from over 200 Indian industries, keeping the Indian government’s push for self-reliance in mind.

Due to its complexity and the need for indigenous technology, the project has faced delays and cost overruns, now amounting to ₹68,400m (£651.43m).

The Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) states that the PFBR, a third-generation reactor with passive safety features, ensures safe shutdowns in emergencies. It utilises spent fuel from India's nuclear programme, reducing nuclear waste, and the need for geological disposal.

Despite its advanced technology, the PFBR's capital and electricity costs are comparable to other nuclear and conventional power plants.

The PFBR's approval also signifies India’s use of plutonium as a nuclear fuel and paves the way for the future use of thorium, a resource in which India has abundant reserves.

Unlike uranium, which is limited in India, thorium presents an opportunity for long-term energy independence, potentially lasting over 300 years. Experts believe that mastering the technology to use thorium could secure India's energy future.

Fast breeder reactors, like the PFBR, are unique because they generate more fuel than they consume, earning them the reputation of being an almost limitless energy source.

The term "fast" refers to the high-energy fast neutrons used in these reactors. India already operates a Fast Breeder Test Reactor (FBTR) at the same location, which has been functional for 39 years.

The board's approval allows for the commencement of fuel loading and low-power physics experiments, with the reactor expected to become operational in the coming months.

The PFBR will initially use Uranium-Plutonium Mixed Oxide (MOX) fuel. A uranium-238 "blanket" surrounding the core will produce more fuel through nuclear transmutation. This process, known as breeding, is what gives these reactors their name.

In the future, thorium-232 may also be used as a blanket, creating fissile uranium-233 through transmutation, which will be utilised in the third stage of India's nuclear programme. This stage is crucial for harnessing India's vast thorium reserves.

Nuclear energy is considered a reliable and low-carbon source of electricity, helping to reduce greenhouse gas emissions that cause climate crisis and diversifying energy supply. However, there are concerns regarding safety and waste that researchers are trying to overcome with new technology.

Recently China unveiled the world’s first “meltdown-proof” nuclear power plant.

So far, nuclear energy only accounts for 3.11 per cent of the country’s total power generation. But India aims to have nuclear power account for nearly 9 per cent of its electricity by 2047 and it is rapidly investing in the technology.

While presenting India’s latest annual budget, finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman told parliament that nuclear energy would “form a very significant part of the energy mix” for India’s development.

The government plans to increase India’s nuclear power capacity from 6,780MW to 22,480MW by 2031. This will involve building 18 new reactors that can produce a total of 13.8GW of electricity. After PFBR, two more fast breeder reactors are in the pipeline.

This will lead to Thorium Reactors
 
First of all, congratulations to India for its breakthrough development in the field of nuclear power. For the people of India, this is indeed something to celebrate.

I don't understand why India always likes to compare China and always find self-excitement in some strange angles.

China ranks first in the world in annual electricity generation, twice as much as the second-ranked United States and four times as large as India.
Nuclear power is only one type of clean energy in China, and hydropower and solar power account for a very high proportion in China.

So, what is the author of this article trying to express? India's nuclear power technology far surpasses China's? Or is India's clean energy technology far superior to China's? Or, India has the world's largest power generation capacity?
 
First of all, congratulations to India for its breakthrough development in the field of nuclear power. For the people of India, this is indeed something to celebrate.

I don't understand why India always likes to compare China and always find self-excitement in some strange angles.

China ranks first in the world in annual electricity generation, twice as much as the second-ranked United States and four times as large as India.
Nuclear power is only one type of clean energy in China, and hydropower and solar power account for a very high proportion in China.

So, what is the author of this article trying to express? India's nuclear power technology far surpasses China's? Or is India's clean energy technology far superior to China's? Or, India has the world's largest power generation capacity?
I do not see any comparison being made to China. Where did you see?

There is only one statement in this article on China and that is :


And that's all! There is no comparison, so why are you so fixated on it?
 
I do not see any comparison being made to China. Where did you see?

There is only one statement in this article on China and that is :



And that's all! There is no comparison, so why are you so fixated on it?

He wanted to bring china into the discussion somehow so decided to make it look like India was comparing itself to China or someti=hing. He's just being an attention *****.

Basically his balls were itching to say how China is the biggest this or that. And @Michael wanted to use some excuse to say it.
 
There is no advance reactor, they all have the same setup. The only issue is environmental protection during disasters or security measures.
 
@DDG-80 have they indicated any timeline for criticality?

No specific timeline given as it depends on the control loop reaction to this phase one ramp. Then phase 2 ramp etc....dunno how many ramps they have till neutron flux stability (i.e criticality). Hopefully this year its achieved.

Then they have to overpower it afterwards to produce the flux for the breeding in the blanket/pit of surplus U-238 introduced. The Pu-239 loop is then achieved with its use in Pu-239 reactor....which will be great news when it happens. Then all rests with final step of recreating this with thorium and U-233 to get homi bhabha vision finally in operation.
 
Recently China unveiled the world’s first “meltdown-proof” nuclear power plant.

So far, nuclear energy only accounts for 3.11 per cent of the country’s total power generation. But India aims to have nuclear power account for nearly 9 per cent of its electricity by 2047 and it is rapidly investing in the technology.
What is it ?

We are not interested in comparing ourselves to India in any way.
 
View attachment 57687
India is close to completing its most advanced nuclear plant, marking a major step forward in the country’s nuclear energy programme.

The Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor (PFBR) at Kalpakkam in the southern state of Tamil Nadu has received approval from the country's atomic regulator to begin loading nuclear fuel.

The PFBR is a 500MW liquid sodium-cooled reactor which has been in development for the past 20 years. This approval marks the start of a controlled chain reaction in India's most advanced and complex nuclear reactor.

While there have been concerns over the use of sodium, a hazardous material, as a coolant, the country’s atomic board said it has conducted safety reviews and assessments of the PFBR, complemented by periodic inspections.

Once operational, India will join Russia as the only two countries in the world with commercially operating fast breeder reactors.

“It is a huge milestone for India’s self-reliant atomic energy programme,” Dinesh Kumar Shukla, chairman of the Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB) said, according to NDTV.

Mr Shukla said the PFBR is an “inherently safe reactor”.

The PFBR has been entirely designed and constructed domestically, with contributions from over 200 Indian industries, keeping the Indian government’s push for self-reliance in mind.

Due to its complexity and the need for indigenous technology, the project has faced delays and cost overruns, now amounting to ₹68,400m (£651.43m).

The Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) states that the PFBR, a third-generation reactor with passive safety features, ensures safe shutdowns in emergencies. It utilises spent fuel from India's nuclear programme, reducing nuclear waste, and the need for geological disposal.

Despite its advanced technology, the PFBR's capital and electricity costs are comparable to other nuclear and conventional power plants.

The PFBR's approval also signifies India’s use of plutonium as a nuclear fuel and paves the way for the future use of thorium, a resource in which India has abundant reserves.

Unlike uranium, which is limited in India, thorium presents an opportunity for long-term energy independence, potentially lasting over 300 years. Experts believe that mastering the technology to use thorium could secure India's energy future.

Fast breeder reactors, like the PFBR, are unique because they generate more fuel than they consume, earning them the reputation of being an almost limitless energy source.

The term "fast" refers to the high-energy fast neutrons used in these reactors. India already operates a Fast Breeder Test Reactor (FBTR) at the same location, which has been functional for 39 years.

The board's approval allows for the commencement of fuel loading and low-power physics experiments, with the reactor expected to become operational in the coming months.

The PFBR will initially use Uranium-Plutonium Mixed Oxide (MOX) fuel. A uranium-238 "blanket" surrounding the core will produce more fuel through nuclear transmutation. This process, known as breeding, is what gives these reactors their name.

In the future, thorium-232 may also be used as a blanket, creating fissile uranium-233 through transmutation, which will be utilised in the third stage of India's nuclear programme. This stage is crucial for harnessing India's vast thorium reserves.

Nuclear energy is considered a reliable and low-carbon source of electricity, helping to reduce greenhouse gas emissions that cause climate crisis and diversifying energy supply. However, there are concerns regarding safety and waste that researchers are trying to overcome with new technology.

Recently China unveiled the world’s first “meltdown-proof” nuclear power plant.

So far, nuclear energy only accounts for 3.11 per cent of the country’s total power generation. But India aims to have nuclear power account for nearly 9 per cent of its electricity by 2047 and it is rapidly investing in the technology.

While presenting India’s latest annual budget, finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman told parliament that nuclear energy would “form a very significant part of the energy mix” for India’s development.

The government plans to increase India’s nuclear power capacity from 6,780MW to 22,480MW by 2031. This will involve building 18 new reactors that can produce a total of 13.8GW of electricity. After PFBR, two more fast breeder reactors are in the pipeline.
Currently generating reactors:
 
A more balanced article:





India is about to witness a significant nuclear milestone in its history of generating atomic energy with the initiation of core loading in the Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor (PFBR) at the Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research at Kalpakkam, Tamil Nadu on March 4.


Why has India focused on Fast Breeder Reactors (FBR)?
The rest of the world has opted for light-water reactors which use uranium as the nuclear fuel. However, uranium reserves are scarce, and India has very limited reserves of uranium. Fast breeder reactors, on the other hand, can use plutonium and thorium. Thorium, when exposed or irradiated to fast neutrons, generate uranium-233, thus converting a benign thorium into a valuable atomic material.


The advantage for India is that it has the world’s second-largest reserves of thorium.


The FBRs also convert “wasted” uranium-238 with the help of fast neutrons into a valuable resource.


What is a breeder reactor?
A breeder reactor is a nuclear reactor that generates more fissile material than it consumes. While conventional reactors use uranium-235 which is rare, breeder reactors use uranium-238 and thorium-232 which are more commonly-available isotopes. The latter two are called fertile materials because they can be bred into fuel by the breeder reactors.


What is a fast breeder reactor?

They are called fast breeder reactors not because they run faster but because the neutrons that sustain the atomic chain reaction travel at a much higher velocity than neutrons that are used in traditional atomic plants.


Which is the world’s only commercially-operated FBR?


The only fast breeder reactor that is being commercially operated at present is the BN 800 FBR in the Ural Mountains of Russia at the Beloyarsk Nuclear Power Plant, close to Russia’s fourth-largest city Yekateringburg. This reactor produces about 800 MW of electricity which is supplied to the Ural region. The Russians are the global leaders in fast breeder reactors since 1980.


What's the FBTR experience at Kalpakkam, Chennai?


India has been running an experimental facility called a Fast Breeder Test Reactor (FBTR) for about 38 years. The Department of Atomic Energy (DAE) has been using this facility to perfect the use of advanced nuclear fuels. Since no country is willing to share the know-how of this sensitive technology, scientists at the Indira Gandhi Centre for Atomic Research (IGCAR) have been developing the technology from scratch.


The FBTR has completed 32 irradiation campaigns in 38 years of safe and successful operation.


What is the Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor (PFBR)?


Using the expertise gained by operating the FBTR for so many years, India has designed the 500 Mwe Prototype Fast Breeder Reactor. It was supposed to be completed by 2010, but has been delayed for various reasons. It has been more than 20 years in the making and about 14 years since the original commissioning date. After one year of successful operation of the PFBR, India plans to construct six more FBRs in the years to follow.


Why is PM Narendra Modi at Kalpakkam on March 4, 2024?

Modi is going to be present for the initiation of the core loading of the PFBR at the ICGAR, Kalpakkam on this date. In order to generate power, the reactor control sub-assemblies, blanket sub-assemblies, and fuel sub-assemblies have to be loaded in order during the core loading procedure.


Why have FBRs been controversial?


In 2010, the International Panel on Fissile Materials said that after six decades and the expenditure of tens of billions of dollars, the promise of breeder reactors remained largely unfulfilled. Breeder reactor development programmes in the US, Germany, and the United Kingdom were abandoned.


FBRs use sodium as a coolant, as compared to the more widely-used technology that uses water as a coolant. A leak in an FBR could lead to a sodium fire, which raises safety issues.


The capital costs of setting up FBRs are about 25 per cent more than light-water reactors.


Why are some TN politicians protesting?


Vaiko, MDMK general secretary, and Jawahirullah, president of Manithaneya Makkal Katchi, have raised concerns against the PFBR launch at Kalpakkam over issues like safety risks, cost escalation, and project delays. They point out that several countries have abandoned FBRs due to safety and financial concerns. They quote the cost overrun of the project from ₹3,490 crore to ₹7,700 crore.


Vaiko has criticised the central government’s prioritisation of nuclear projects over flood relief funds. Jawahirullah targets the project for potentially turning Tamil Nadu into a “dumpyard” for nuclear waste. They also say that nuclear projects are moved to Tamil Nadu because of opposition in BJP-ruled states.
 
What is it ?

We are not interested in comparing ourselves to India in any way.
The rest of the world often compares India with China. Indians also do not want to be compared with Pakistan, but some Pakistanis still compare their country with India.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top