The ‘last great Mughal monument’ vandalized in India

[Maira La]

https://edition.cnn.com/2023/12/13/india/india-delhi-zafar-mahal-mughal-vandalism-intl-hnk/index.html

 

[digitalSurgeon]

Probably an act by some bhakts. They want to erase the Muslim history of India.

 

[Mr X]

Please share the article with the source, not just the link

Thanks

 

[VCheng]

Please share the article with the source, not just the link

Thanks

https://edition.cnn.com/2023/12/13/india/india-delhi-zafar-mahal-mughal-vandalism-intl-hnk/index.html

World / India
This monument stood for hundreds of years before vandals smashed it. Historians say it must never happen again
Rhea Mogul
By Rhea Mogul, CNN
4 minute read
Updated 9:36 PM EST, Tue December 12, 2023

(CNN) -- An act of vandalism at an 18th century monument built by the once powerful Mughal empire has sparked anger in India, with historians urging authorities to provide better protection for the country’s vast cultural heritage.

The destruction of parts of three emperors’ tombs at the Zafar Mahal palace in New Delhi was discovered by historians Sunday during a heritage walk at the site, which is overseen by a government agency responsible for conserving historic monuments.

“It is believed that this is the last great Mughal monument,” said historian Sam Dalrymple, who alerted a security guard to the damage. “Zafar Mahal has been slowly falling apart for years and is symbolic of the wider neglect of Mughal history in Delhi.”

The vandalism includes damage to part of a marble lattice screen, or jaali, that surrounds the empty grave of Bahadur Shah Zafar, the final Mughal emperor, who was exiled in 1858 to Burma – now Myanmar – by India’s former British rulers.

The destruction was “really heartbreaking,” said artist Srishti Rana Menon.

“It’s one of the most hauntingly beautiful place (sic) and those jaalis were nothing short of exquisite,” she wrote on Instagram. “What’s lost is really priceless.”

“Absolutely shocked, hurt and angry at whatever took place,” wrote another user. “Considering myself lucky to witness these before the vandalism.”

The palace, which is free to enter for the public, is among more than 170 heritage sites in Delhi that are protected by the government-run Archaeological Survey of India (ASI).

Praveen Singh, superintending archaeologist from ASI Delhi Circle, said there was “nothing huge” in the vandalism at Zafar Mahal. “No doubt it is damaged. But the whole monument has not vanished,” he told CNN, adding that a complaint had been lodged with police in Delhi’s southern Mehrauli district.

No arrests have been made and authorities will investigate the case, a Mehrauli police official said.

Left to neglect

Delhi, a metropolis of more than 20 million people, has seen rapid urbanization over the past few decades, with a vast, sparkling modern metro system, and a burgeoning middle class that has come to symbolize India’s economic growth.

But between its meandering roads stand centuries-old monuments and medieval ruins that put the Indian capital on a par with the world’s great ancient cities, historians say.

“It is one of the rare cities on the scale of heritage of Rome and Cairo,” said Dalrymple, who grew up in Delhi. “The sheer extent of history is remarkable.”

He also questioned how vandals were able to cause damage at a monument in the capital.

“One of the greatest tragedies is that this is happening in Delhi. What’s happening outside?” he said.

Even before the vandalism, Zafar Mahal had fallen into disrepair, with weeds growing around the tombs and dirt on the walls and other structures, according to amateur historian Shah Umair.

“The ASI have been promising for years they will renovate the palace, but there have been no steps taken so far,” said Umair, who discovered the damage alongside Dalrymple.

Singh, from ASI, said the agency had been expected to start repairs at Zafar Mahal in April, but the work had been delayed as cost estimates had not been set.

“We do regular preservation and conservation of all monuments as and when required,” Singh said.

Mughal heritage

The Mughal empire, which ruled India from 1526 and 1858, reached its pinnacle under emperor Shah Jahan, who commissioned the iconic Taj Mahal in Agra as a mausoleum for his wife and built a wealth of other artistic marvels across the country.

And the destroyed jaali at Zafar Mahal is considered an archetype of the Indo-Islamic art movement that flourished during Mughal rule.

In recent years, however, the rise of Hindu nationalism in India has put some Mughal-era monuments at the center of controversy. For example, anger erupted in 2017 after the UNESCO-listed Taj Mahal was excluded from an official government tourism brochure.

Former Tourism Minister Alphons Kannanthanam dismissed the controversy at the time, stating the Taj Mahal was “India’s pride.”

For many, however, the controversy showed creeping intent by the ruling Hindu-nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party to exclude India’s former Muslim rulers from its cultural history.

Historian Rana Safvi said some of the Mughal architecture found in south Delhi’s Mehrauli district was unique to India and called on authorities to do more to protect it.

“This very typical Indo-Islamic art, you don’t see anywhere but in this region,” said Safvi, referring to well-known motifs like marble jaalis and floral symbols.

Safvi also urged authorities to do more to protect lesser known, but equally significant monuments.

“We should take pride in our history,” she said.

______________________________________________________________
CNN’s Aishwarya Iyer contributed reporting from New Delhi.

 

[Maira La]

Please share the article with the source, not just the link

Thanks

I was trying to do just that, but when I tried to copy-paste the photos from the article I got an error message saying they are too large (never got this on old PDF). So I kind of avoided copy-pasting text only, as I felt it degrades the quality of the article with photos of damages to Zafar Mahal missing.

 

[VCheng]

I was trying to do just that, but when I tried to copy-paste the photos from the article I got an error message saying they are too large (never got this on old PDF). So I kind of avoided copy-pasting text only, as I felt it degrades the quality of the article with photos of damages to Zafar Mahal missing.

I think we need to be patient for all of the old features to gradually become available here. I dislike the photo size limits imposed for uploading images too, for example.

 

[Joe Shearer]

https://edition.cnn.com/2023/12/13/india/india-delhi-zafar-mahal-mughal-vandalism-intl-hnk/index.html

Bastards!

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Well India is home to 250 Million Muslims vast amount , who are clearly not a small figure
Such act of vandalism only will segregate the population

 

[Developereo]

Echoes of Bamiyan statues in a land not so far away...

 

[Joe Shearer]

Echoes of Bamiyan statues in a land not so far away...

...the same mentality. Not hatred of the object harmed, but hatred of the culture that the object represents.

 

[vsdoc]

...the same mentality. Not hatred of the object harmed, but hatred of the culture that the object represents.

A story as old as mankind.

Kill the men.

F**k the girls.

Defile the temples.

Erase the edifices.

Why cry selectively (this is a generic question to the audience at large)?

Cheers, Doc

 

[Sharma Ji]

A story as old as mankind.

Kill the men.

F**k the girls.

Defile the temples.

Erase the edifices.

Why cry selectively (this is a generic question to the audience at large)?

Cheers, Doc

Neverending excuses k lie gaan' prepare kar lo fir

Mai to sheedh foosi marta inki naak me, heh.

 

[vsdoc]

Neverending excuses k lie gaan' prepare kar lo fir

Mai to sheedh foosi marta inki naak me, heh.

I know what the counter is going to be ... but Mughals were Indian born and bred.

Well

So were the born and bred Indians before and during them whose temples were razed and men killed and women f**d.

Karmic cycle.

Cheers, Doc

 

[Guru Dutt]

just asked the police IO of that area who was in owr beat before now is working there as per initial findings looks more like work of drug addicts and beggers who sneak up there during night as in winters footfall is really very low only on holidays some people come to visit or some school excurssions that too on weekends .... nothing much into it its the area under wakf board

 

[Maira La]

and men killed and women f**d.

You mean 1.2 billion Hindus are Mughal (paternal) - native (maternal) hybrid?