Tank131
Registered Member
I agree with your assessment for Goksur over Gokdeniz for Babur. Its 20 missiles and 15km range (vs 9km for HQ-10) will help make up for the low number of CAMM-ER. While Atom Burst Ammo would be ideal for the STOP 25mm guns, i doubt PN can swing for that. That said there is no technical limitation preventing CAMM-ER quad packing in MIDLAS. It is a political and financial issue in which PN will need to approach Turkey/Rocketsan and Italy/Leonardo to integrate the two and pay them to do so but after that, the merger will be superior in range to Hisar RF (G/M-1).No gökdeniz on hayber,like babür,I think Pak navy decided something else.Aselsan göksur or roketsan levent missile systems would be nice,these systems have their own aesa radar systems and have automatic detection and firing without needing main sensors of the ship.Thats the way true close defence should work.This ships have 25mm stop system and can be modified to aselsan 25mm atom burst ammos as you wish,so you can choose classic or atom. ammos when required.It will protect airborne threats against ships and some üwhat fulfill gap of the lack of the 35mm gökdeniz airburst system.Unfortunately shipbuilding takes long times and many thing changes,its hard to adopt,and takes money and time also.Pakistan insist camm-ER on jinnah class,so this is a mistake.Roketsan midlas sytem evolving rapidly so you can fire hisar RF with 40km range,siper1 100km range and even atmaca missiles,ofcourse you have to upgrade cenk aesaradar like our istif class.This upgrade on jinnah not that cost too much,but you can get enormous flexibility.For examle if jinnah have 32 cell you can load full atmaca or full siper1 or hisarD and mixing up between them according to mission profile.Nevertheless babür class and jinnah class will be main net centric warfare of the pak navy,and this means more power than ships indivual characteristics.
As for Atmaca, PN will likely never use this. Its ability to be fired from the VLS not withstanding, PNs own AShM in Harbah, CM-302 and SMASH far our range Atmaca, and are also able to be utilized in Land attack. In CM-302 and SMASH cases they are far faster than Atmaca as well. Also, unfortunately Jinnah Class for now will only have 16 cells vls, not 32 cells (hopefully they will be MIDLAS and not GWS.26/35). PN would be better served with JCF having 8 SMASH AShMs midship and a MIDLAS VLS up front with 8 cells reserved for quad packed CAMM-ER and the remainder (8 cells) for SIPER. Would give 8 long range SAMs and 32 medi range sams and 20 short range sams (Goksur)





