Why is the Pakistani state & army so deeply incompetent? A structural analysis

Status
Not open for further replies.
There's no point in regurgitating crap that even a fiver years old in Pakistan knows and understand...
There's is nothing though provoking in any of the posts including yours ..... it's all trite yada yada that we are hearing since our childhood.

If every 5 year old in Pakistan already knows this, why are you the only one having a meltdown over it?

You’re dismissing the facts as “trite yada yada” not because you’re actually bored, but because you literally don’t have a comeback.

It’s hilarious watching you get boxed into a corner and immediately pivot to pretending the whole debate is beneath you.

Just a minute ago you were sweating over “gora crumbs” to play the ultimate patriot, and now you’re acting totally unfazed while entitled elites, systemic corruption, and a broken establishment bleed the country dry.

Look, I get the knee jerk reaction to get defensive when you feel like your home is being talked down to.
It’s a natural reflex.

But if you can drop the hyper defensive act for a second, I bet we all actually agree that the current setup is completely broken. You don’t have to keep defending the indefensible just to prove your patriotism.

If you’re willing to step off the high horse and actually talk about the mess instead of attacking people for pointing it out, we might actually have a discussion.
 
in what?

they lose every ground war.

2025 it was a airwar won by PAF
Lose every war? Are you getting facts from your ass?

Pakistan has faced and fought two superpowers in its neighborhood that came in and occupied Afghanistan with big plans to achieve their goals at the cost of Pak's territorial integrity. Both had to retreat in disgrace.

Many times bigger enemy, India, couldn't change an inch of the LoC despite having tacit support from many global and regional countries. Rather Modi has been thrown into deep isolation after a clear defeat and humiliation in May 2025.

And stop talking non-sense of only PAF winning May 2025 battle. In fact, that exposes your overwhelming ignorance and stupidity.

You need to stop paddling lies and face the realities.
 
As mush as your idea makes sense we all know Pakistan Generals will do absolutely nothing.
But the idea is not realistic is it. The big military, extra border security, post operation development, infrastructure, education, jobs etc will need billions annually. Also where will clean politicians and leadership come from whom will make sure the funds are utilised effectively.
 
If every 5 year old in Pakistan already knows this, why are you the only one having a meltdown over it?

You’re dismissing the facts as “trite yada yada” not because you’re actually bored, but because you literally don’t have a comeback.

It’s hilarious watching you get boxed into a corner and immediately pivot to pretending the whole debate is beneath you.

Just a minute ago you were sweating over “gora crumbs” to play the ultimate patriot, and now you’re acting totally unfazed while entitled elites, systemic corruption, and a broken establishment bleed the country dry.

Look, I get the knee jerk reaction to get defensive when you feel like your home is being talked down to.
It’s a natural reflex.

But if you can drop the hyper defensive act for a second, I bet we all actually agree that the current setup is completely broken. You don’t have to keep defending the indefensible just to prove your patriotism.

If you’re willing to step off the high horse and actually talk about the mess instead of attacking people for pointing it out, we might actually have a discussion.
Ok , Dr . Phill , you understand human psychology and no surprise with such an expertise you have concluded that I am from some haramkhoor tabar....I don't need to prove anything , I am who I am ..
Good bye
 
Your family friend shall be prosecuted for talking to you about internal secrets...btw , is your family friend an imaginary chirya ?


It’s way above your pay scale and level … just move on .
 
My family friend is assigned to a cybersecurity department operated by the army and I was shocked to find out that they have spent considerable resources and man power tracking PTI supporters and their online presence rather than focus or terrorist threats and dealing with real threats. They spend most of their intelligence resources on political blackmailing and suppression rather than rooting out terrorists and please dont let me talk about incompetence and bravado.......

Today's suicide attack on the train happened after a boggy was joined carrying soldiers ....a suicide bomber causally walked into a train compartment loaded with soldiers and exploded......

I swear I hang my head in shame over such incompetence.....
Enemy powers are using brainless cult followers to get inroads into Pakistani society and spread their tentacles for terrorism in Pakistan. The actions and statements of the enemy mole Zionist son-in-law Imran Niazi make his goals quite clear, the goals of creating political instability, fasad, and terrorism in Pakistan.

The support that is extended to this enemy mole by the Afghan terrorist groups (TTA and TTP), Indian activists and fake news channels, the Irani ass-suckers, and Zionist lobbies make it quite clear whose agenda PTI is following.

It is indeed not a coincidence that Zionists war criminals, Hindutva nazis, Afghani terrorists and mafias, Irani terrorist suckers, and PTI followers are all on the same page when it comes to the animosity towards Pakistan.
 
Another attack in Quetta, more innocent lives lost and once again Pakistan’s security apparatus is reacting after the damage is done. The pattern never changes, a tragedy happens, officials issue loud statements about ‘revenge,’ and then everyone waits for the next attack.

This reactive mindset has become a national curse. If nothing changes, next month the same militants will strike again, more families will bury their loved ones, and the cycle will continue. At some point we must ask, where is the proactive strategy, the prevention, the intelligence work that stops these attacks before they happen?
I'll tell you where this mindset comes from. In Pakistan, average person life is worth NOTHING - neither to the institution nor to the average Joe. In fact there is no law and order, and anyone can do as they wish (for the most part).

Then there are the institutions, everyone that's serving in them is there for one reason: to line their own pockets first, country can go to hell. The average person is no different either, they'll gladly pay what they can afford to get ahead of the queue, to avoid any repercussions, to get a job etc. The entire country is rotten from Bottom to the Top.

Then there is the Islamic ideology in the mix: anything that goes wrong, blame God and move on. Allah ki Marzi.

So when you hear of mass casualty events, no one gives a F. It was Allah ki Marzi (God willed). Its amazing that even the victims' families will forgive, forget and wont question the institutions. No one is ever held responsible.

I thank my Father every single day for getting our family out of that Jungle years ago. I'll forever be grateful.
 
Ok , Dr . Phill , you understand human psychology and no surprise with such an expertise you have concluded that I am from some haramkhoor tabar....I don't need to prove anything , I am who I am ..
Good bye
“Dr. Phil”? Mashallah! , what a deeply rooted desi intellectual you are in dragging in a washed up amrikan daytime TV host to defend your patriotic honor.

But the absolute best part of your little exit speech is the spectacular self report. I pointed out systemic rot and elitist complicity, and your immediate, hyper defensive instinct was to cry, “Oh, you think I’m from a haramkhoor tabar.”

I never actually said that but thank you for filling in the blanks. It’s hilarious how loudly a guilty conscience will out itself when backed into a corner.

You’re right about one thing though and that is you really don’t need to prove anything.

You already proved you have zero actual counter arguments. The second your fragile narrative got dismantled your only move was to fold, drop a tragic “I am who I am,” and sprint for the door while muttering about “delusions”.

Run along then. The exit is right where you started with your arguments.
 
Ok , Dr . Phill , you understand human psychology and no surprise with such an expertise you have concluded that I am from some haramkhoor tabar....I don't need to prove anything , I am who I am ..
Good bye
You are dimwitted moron who cannot handle criticism and thinks his failed state just managing to survive (essentially equivalent to being a homeless man on the streets) with no other ambitions or coherency is something worthy of praise and then begin to seethe in defense when you are told it's pathetic.
 
Enemy powers are using brainless cult followers to get inroads into Pakistani society and spread their tentacles for terrorism in Pakistan. The actions and statements of the enemy mole Zionist son-in-law Imran Niazi make his goals quite clear, the goals of creating political instability, fasad, and terrorism in Pakistan.

The support that is extended to this enemy mole by the Afghan terrorist groups (TTA and TTP), Indian activists and fake news channels, the Irani ass-suckers, and Zionist lobbies make it quite clear whose agenda PTI is following.

It is indeed not a coincidence that Zionists war criminals, Hindutva nazis, Afghani terrorists and mafias, Irani terrorist suckers, and PTI followers are all on the same page when it comes to the animosity towards Pakistan.
You know what the funny thing is? Nobody disputes that outside powers meddle. Of course they do. And yes, a chunk of PTI supporters have gone completely mad. Fair enough.

But mate, this country was being run into the ground long before Imran Khan showed up in his shabby Shalwar kameez and wastcut.

The debt didn’t come from Delhi.
The missing persons didn’t come from Tel Aviv.
The rigged accountability courts, the engineered elections, the generals who somehow always end up owning prize DHA plots in “random” qurandaazi while poor majors didn’t - that process didn’t come in a foreign suitcase.

The “foreign hand” is the oldest trick in the book. Wheel it out whenever someone asks an uncomfortable question about the state. Works every time, apparently.

Seventy odd years and counting.

Go after PTI’s extremists. They deserve it. But the moment you use that to slam the door on every legitimate question about how this place is actually run and by whom and in whose interest, you’re not being patriotic.

You’re just being useful to exactly the people who’ve been picking this country’s pockets since before you were born.
 
At first, Pakistan was considered a Banana Republic, weak institutional capacity but highly salvagable, but now it is fast moving towards a failed state in nearly every fundamental indicator.

National identity has largely been a failure (it is extremely flawed, illogical and self-destructive to its own interests), feudalism reigns supreme in large parts of the country like Sindh, South Punjab, Balochistan, and is deeply embedded in parts of its political elite, its national institutions are rife with nepotism and general incompetency due to low standards, filled with unqualified village idiots, and most importantly, due to the downstream affect of having a failed identity that lacks a nativist core base, its institutions and people lack clarity and direction in their own interests and long term strategical goals to act in. It lacks meaning and conviction.

This is in contrast to every other functional and successful/growing state out there. It has no idea what it clearly is, who it is, and its interests. The corruption, nepotism and low IQ only make the negatives more worse.
 
Would you mind discussing the solutions here? I would really be interested in what approach it would take

Please search my previous posts I have explained everything in detail, from pilot project to completion master plan.

I am the architect of 34 Economist Zone model and this is the only realistic path
that breaks feudal monopolies, industrializes regions, and shifts Pakistan from an agrarian‑feudal economy to a production‑export economy.

1. “Pakistan is stuck because the system is stuck.”

For 30 years, Pakistan’s exports have been frozen around $25–30 billion.
Countries smaller than Lahore export 5–10 times more.

Examples:

• Vietnam: $350B (10× Pakistan)
• Singapore: $500B (15× Pakistan)
• Netherlands: $820B (25× Pakistan)
• Belgium: $600B (18× Pakistan)
• UAE: $430B (14× Pakistan)

Pakistan’s trade deficit in recent years:

• $3.5–4.5 billion per month

• $40–45 billion per year

This means:

Every month, Pakistan loses more money in trade than it earns from exports.

This is why the economy suffocates:

• rupee collapses
• inflation rises
• reserves fall
• IMF dependency increases
• industries shut down

Why?
Because our current provincial system was built in 1970, for a population of 60 million, not 240 million.

This is not politics.
This is math.

2. “Four provinces cannot run a 240‑million‑person economy.”


The 34‑EZ model is built on one core principle:

Economic governance should be delivered by small, efficient, professional units not giant political provinces.

Provinces today create:

• 4 chief ministers
• 4 cabinets
• 4 planning departments
• 4 education departments
• 4 health departments
• 4 irrigation departments
• 4 revenue boards
• 4 police command structures
• 4 layers of political patronage

Current system is too big, too slow, too expensive.

All doing the same work, all consuming billions, all blocking each other.

This is why:

• jobs don’t grow
• industries don’t grow
• exports don’t grow
• cities don’t grow

The 34‑EZ model replaces this with 34 lean, digital, audited economic units.


3. “34 Economic Zones is the first model designed for growth, not politics.”


Economic Zones are not new provinces.
They are engines of jobs, exports, and investment.

Each Zone has:

• its own industrial specialization
• its own digital governance
• its own investment pipeline
• its own accountability
• its own revenue model

This means every region grows, not just Lahore or Karachi.

4. “This model breaks feudal monopolies without touching anyone’s identity.”

“We are not dividing Pakistan.
We are dividing power so people can finally get services.”

Feudal monopolies survive because:

• districts are too large
• people have no alternatives
• bureaucracy is captured
• politics controls resources

34 Zones break this by making every region small enough to manage, big enough to grow.

5. “This model saves Pakistan $20–22 billion every year.”

“We can fix Pakistan without raising taxes.
We only need to stop wasting money.”

By replacing 4 provincial bureaucracies with 34 lean economic administrations, Pakistan can save:

• 50–70% of administrative costs
• $20–22 billion annually

• enough to build 1,000 hospitals or 10,000 schools in 10 years


6. “Every Zone becomes a job machine.”


• Sialkot Zone → sports exports
• Faisalabad Zone → textiles 2.0
• Karachi Zone → finance & ports
• Gwadar Zone → logistics & shipping
• Swat Zone → tourism
• Bahawalpur Zone → solar energy
• Sukkur Zone → agriculture technology

“Every Zone and major city will finally have its own economy, not leftovers from Lahore or Karachi.”

7. “Digital governance means no bribes, no files, no sifarish.”

Explain:
• land records digital
• taxes digital
• services digital
• licensing digital
• policing digital
• courts digital

People want speed, fairness, and respect.

Digital Zones deliver that.
 
Last edited:
At first, Pakistan was considered a Banana Republic, weak institutional capacity but highly salvagable, but now it is fast moving towards a failed state in nearly every fundamental indicator.

National identity has largely been a failure (it is extremely flawed, illogical and self-destructive to its own interests), feudalism reigns supreme in large parts of the country like Sindh, South Punjab, Balochistan, and is deeply embedded in parts of its political elite, its national institutions are rife with nepotism and general incompetency due to low standards, filled with unqualified village idiots, and most importantly, due to the downstream affect of having a failed identity that lacks a nativist core base, its institutions and people lack clarity and direction in their own interests and long term strategical goals to act in. It lacks meaning and conviction.

This is in contrast to every other functional and successful/growing state out there. It has no idea what it clearly is, who it is, and its interests. The corruption, nepotism and low IQ only make the negatives more worse.
Explaining the national identity & ideology part.

An ideology or national identity is meant to serve three main critical purposes for a nation:

1. Mass mobilisation of the masses towards a (beneficial) collective goal, short and long-term.

2. Provide mental/strategic clarity & direction in your worldview (both domestically and internationally). Prevent flawed perceptions that create a warped worldview.

3. Provide a coherent & cohesive core identity base which the state is founded upon and use as a base to build upon.

Pakistan's ideology of 'Muslim nationalism' has been a complete failure in this regard.

It is (1) firstly illogical and makes little sense, since it completely lacks any nativist or local aspect, as religions are not nations - especially not one as super large and diverse as Islam. Bangladesh proved this. (2) it promotes extreme religious dogmatism and regressiveness because social authority of the state now lies in religious figures as that is what the identity is grounded in. This leads to extremism, regressive habits, and destroys smart and intelligent foreign policy, as it is all centred around "Muslim" (meaningless identity geopolitically as explained). And (3) it fails to address or coherrntly confront domestic ethno-nationalistic issues as the population is now indoctrinated in the masses to view everyone and anyone as their "brothers" and create a strategic confusion between friend and foe.

It systematically brainwashes you into a deeply flawed and self-destructive worldview that causes confusion and regressive dogmatism. It is blinding.
 
I merely offer insight, I let the masses decide collectively what they want going forward and what they're willing to pay for it
Politics is a very special field. Like other familiar sciences such as medicine, engineering, computer science, and mechanics, it contains a great deal of specialized knowledge and academic terminology.

The specialized knowledge and terminology of other disciplines are completely incomprehensible to the average person; they often can't even spell these terms correctly. Therefore, they rarely analyze, discuss, or evaluate them.

The political field is quite unique.

On the surface, the language of politics is easy to understand. Therefore, many laypeople are eager to analyze and discuss it, often placing themselves in the position of top-level political leaders to offer grand evaluations and guidance.

In fact, this is precisely the biggest deceptive element politics presents to ordinary people. It is a highly complex professional discipline, meticulously packaged in plain language, representing the most difficult aspects of human society. Furthermore, the methods of packaging politics vary greatly across countries, cultures, and periods, making it impossible to understand using a single standard.

It's like an ordinary person without a computer science background questioning a Pakistani software engineer:
Why don't you use Urdu, but instead use C++ to write your program?
The engineer simply wouldn't know how to answer.
 
“Dr. Phil”? Mashallah! , what a deeply rooted desi intellectual you are in dragging in a washed up amrikan daytime TV host to defend your patriotic honor.

But the absolute best part of your little exit speech is the spectacular self report. I pointed out systemic rot and elitist complicity, and your immediate, hyper defensive instinct was to cry, “Oh, you think I’m from a haramkhoor tabar.”

I never actually said that but thank you for filling in the blanks. It’s hilarious how loudly a guilty conscience will out itself when backed into a corner.

You’re right about one thing though and that is you really don’t need to prove anything.

You already proved you have zero actual counter arguments. The second your fragile narrative got dismantled your only move was to fold, drop a tragic “I am who I am,” and sprint for the door while muttering about “delusions”.

Run along then. The exit is right where you started with your arguments.
I had the misfortune of reading the entire post and couldn't find a single sentence worth responding to , carry on with your meaningless rant that signifies nothing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Country Watch Latest

Latest Posts

Back
Top