Phaderland people love motherland people

[ThoroughPro]

From the "Phaderland's" horse's mouth

 

[PK781]

They(israeli) will only use the indians like tissue paper and then discard after.
Judaism is the strictest of religions and they dont like(or tolerate) hinduism at all.
But obviously the indians as usual are eager to comply/please the israelis at all costs

 

[roger]

What exactly is the “Fatherland” story, and what is its actual context? I have come across this many times, so I am genuinely asking for an honest, evidence-based explanation.
But please spare me doctored images, selective cut-and-paste material, or recycled propaganda presented as research.
Forgive the bluntness, but in an age of AI and almost instant access to information, there is very little excuse for forwarding questionable material without first checking whether it is authentic and understanding its context. What surprises me even more is the confidence with which misinformation is sometimes presented as fact.
People may think such posts make them look informed or clever. Quite often, they have precisely the opposite effect, particularly on people who have taken the trouble to verify the facts.
I am genuinely open to a different view. Just give me the full context and credible evidence, not propaganda

 

[roger]

Oh...I checked it... Using AI ( Whatsapp wala ).
And context changes everything.
What actually transpired was very different from the impression created by the selectively circulated clip.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi was speaking about Indian Jews who migrated from India to Israel in the mid-20th century and the Indian-origin Jewish community now living there. He spoke of their contribution to modern Israel, including in laboratories, hospitals and classrooms. It was about this community that he said they regard Israel as their “fatherland” and India as their “motherland.”
In other words, he was not calling Israel his own fatherland, nor was he describing Israel as the fatherland of Indians generally. Independent fact-checkers who examined the full speech reached the same conclusion: the viral interpretation removed the surrounding context and was misleading.
And this is exactly why context matters.
A few seconds of video can create outrage. A few minutes spent checking the original speech can completely change the meaning.
We can agree or disagree with Modi, his politics, or India's relationship with Israel. That is entirely legitimate. But criticism should be based on what someone actually said and meant in context, not on what a selectively edited clip makes it appear they said.
In an age when verification is easier than ever, perhaps the real question is not “What did Modi say?” but “Why are we so willing to believe and circulate something before checking what was actually said?”

 

[roger]

They(israeli) will only use the indians like tissue paper and then discard after.
Judaism is the strictest of religions and they dont like(or tolerate) hinduism at all.
But obviously the indians as usual are eager to comply/please the israelis at all costs

Sir, India keeps on Voting for Palestine, does not support many stuff Israel has been demanding....for e.g. Classification of Hamas as a Terrorist Organisation..a very simple ask..India has not even when Israel classified all Orgn against India as Terrorist. Even under BJP rule. Who is using who , if you cannot understand it....for a country like India...alas...sad state. But the question is, are you factual when you write these things or it's just an emotional outburst.

 

[Malcolm Reynolds]

@roger

don't try to explain. they are pakistanis. just do what the rest of us do.

 

[RescueRanger]

Why is this nonsense in the strategic affairs section?

Kind refrain from posting such things in a serious section of the forum.