Opinion Piece- Beyond Partition: Imagining an India-Pakistan Friendship

Does this plebiscite have an option for an independent Kashmir.
Kashmir being an independent country is not part of the partition plan. Kingdoms choose either Pakistan or India.

That is what Louis Mountbatten of Burma said.
 
Kashmir being an independent country is not part of the partition plan. Kingdoms choose either Pakistan or India.

That is what Louis Mountbatten of Burma said.
Louis Mountbatten of Burma said that the King of Kashmir will decide. What he said is no longer relevant. If we want to give the Kashmiris what they want, then independence should also be on the table.
 
I'm gonna say some weird shit here, some of you may get it, some may not.

India and Pakistan could do with less frosty than they currently are.

The Kashmir matter is dead and settled in all but name. There is nothing big left to squabble over. Terrorism has left a bad taste in the mouth but both sides did it to each other. We all know that too.

However I don't ever want to see India and Pakistan move towards a 'friendship' and not for the usual reasons. I personally think that the only thing that keeps Pakistan separate from India is Islam. Without Islam in my generation I'm already seeing a resurgence of bollywood-esque kanjar-khana. Not saying it hasn't always existed, but it was never proudly displayed or backed up.

Without that barrier and with friendly relations with India, we risk a cultural infiltration. I don't want bollywood movies playing in Pakistan. I don't want to see Indian songs or memes circulating in Pakistan. None of it.

Not because I think any of it is 'bad'. But I feel it could easily dilute Pakistan's own identity and it almost did during that Aman ki Asha bull crap.
Kashmir issue is not over even if it is a 1000 year long fight.

Pakistan has not given up its claim on Kashmir.

End of discussion.
 
Louis Mountbatten of Burma said that the King of Kashmir will decide. What he said is no longer relevant. If we want to give the Kashmiris what they want, then independence should also be on the table.
No, Louis Mountbatten of Burma also said a referendum will be held in Kashmir to take the will of the people into what they want Pakistan or India.

Nice try though.
 
Louis Mountbatten of Burma said that the King of Kashmir will decide. What he said is no longer relevant. If we want to give the Kashmiris what they want, then independence should also be on the table.
Thats not part of the UN resolutions 80 or 90.
 
Louis Mountbatten of Burma said that the King of Kashmir will decide. What he said is no longer relevant. If we want to give the Kashmiris what they want, then independence should also be on the table.
There is no expiry date on the UN resolutions, partition plan rules, or what Louis Mountbatten of Burma said.

Nice try though.
 
"Senior leaders of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS)—including General Secretary Dattatreya Hosabale, chief Mohan Bhagwat, and publicity chief Sunil Ambekar—have advocated for keeping dialogue channels and people-to-people connections open with Pakistan, as reported by The Hindu and The Wire."

Confused?

Seems like you are a minority.
Not in the slightest. They made a diplomatic response while in position of power (same as a Mod) as expected of them, you ask Modi the same question and he will say the same thing "Dialogue". An average India would want nothing to do with Pakistan except maybe some odd fellas who still see some bhaichara (expect the same on that side as well).

There is simply no benefit for either of us to have a relationship. Our trade partners are sitting thousands of miles away and neither of us are dependent on each other for trade. Basically we can have zero trade and be just fine. You don't produce things we need desperately, we don't produce things you need desperately. So I don't know why there is a great need for reapproachment. We have our disagreements and let it continue. We are not agreeing to your demands for plebiscite in Kashmir, so fundamentally the Indo - Pak reapproachment is a non starter.
 
Not in the slightest. They made a diplomatic response while in position of power (same as a Mod) as expected of them, you ask Modi the same question and he will say the same thing "Dialogue". An average India would want nothing to do with Pakistan except maybe some odd fellas who still see some bhaichara (expect the same on that side as well).

There is simply no benefit for either of us to have a relationship. Our trade partners are sitting thousands of miles away and neither of us are dependent on each other for trade. Basically we can have zero trade and be just fine. You don't produce things we need desperately, we don't produce things you need desperately. So I don't know why there is a great need for reapproachment. We have our disagreements and let it continue. We are not agreeing to your demands for plebiscite in Kashmir, so fundamentally the Indo - Pak reapproachment is a non starter.

As I said, you as in indians are confused. I only want Pakistanis to not forget and forgive.
 
I am not talking of resolutions. I am talking of the wishes of the Kashmiri people. Are the resolutions more important than the wishes of the Kashmiris.
Best you don't go down this route. The OP did not intend this thread as a Kashmir discussion.

Visit one of those more relevant threads, tag me and others. And we will certainly discuss the wishes of Kashmiris, along with the matters of Junagadh, Goa and Hyderabad. No need to tie yourself into a Gordian knot over here.
 
HOLD A PLEBISCITE IN KASHMIR TO SOLVE THE KASHMIR DISPUTE THEN WE CAN HAVE NORMALIZATION OF TIES.
Fair point. Your assertion is that Kashmir must be resolved as a prerequisite to normalisation.

I'm exploring a different pathway, one where better relations are not conditional on resolving the Kashmir dispute first.

In a nutshell, what I'm interested in exploring is what resolving Kashmir as friends might look like, compared to trying to resolve it as adversaries.
 
It took indians, how many, 14 years to realise and then want to normalize the situation?

What are the guarantees, indians won't choose another extremist hindu for next 14 years and believe him wholeheartedly and follow him blindly?

In these 14 years, india has spent each and every ounce of its energy to defame Pakistan, try and spread propaganda against its people, try to isolate it, boycott it and even attacked Pakistan and its citizens twice or if you believe in that surgical strike chooran, then three times.

Are you going to apologize first as a nation? Before we talk about normalcy?

I hope, no Pakistani forgets those more than two decades of terrorism, bomb blasts, attacks and killing. I want these years to be included in our syllabus and become part of our history lectures and each and every Pakistani child taught about how a coward enemy tried to kill us for being Pakistani.
I think you're conflating normalisation with reconciliation.

Normalisation doesn't require either side to forget its grievances, forgive the other or abandon its demands for accountability.

Nor can either country offer guarantees about the disposition of governments that haven't even been elected yet. That's the nature of international relations. The best we can hope for is to build relationships and institutions that make hostility increasingly costly and cooperation increasingly beneficial.

And I don't see why remembering our history and pursuing better relations should be mutually exclusive. We can remember the dead, teach our children about what happened and continue to seek accountability without making perpetual hostility the price of preserving their memory.

Ultimately, my question remains: must we resolve every grievance, establish trust and reconcile our historical differences before we can even begin to establish a functional relationship?

Or can we attempt to do some of those things alongside one another?
 
One guy in PDF that too a Mod. Yeeeah!

Who we elect is our prerogative. This should not be a concern for Pakistanis, partition happened in 47 you can't gaslight us, we elect someone who can deliver results. Indian elections and its leaders have no bearing on you. Our policy regarding Pakistan is irrespective of who raises flag in Red fort.

What did you expect from an "enemy", accolades and praises? Or India Pak relationship was all hunky and dory before 2014? We were all in PDF before 2014 it was worse than this. At least now we kinda have a no contact relationship which a lot of people wanted before 2014 now that it has arrived, all of sudden everyone wants dialogue? I honestly can't remember a time when both India and Pakistan talked less about each other in our history.

Lol!

Most Pakistanis were killed by Pakistanis themselves. You are your own biggest enemy, your national disunity is on you not on us. That doesn't mean India is all united, we have our own problems but we keep a lid on things.
I find this exchange rather illustrative of the very problem I'm attempting to explore.

One poster believes India must first apologise, demonstrate its intentions and provide assurances before relations can be normalised.

The other believes India is perfectly entitled to pursue whatever domestic and foreign policies it chooses, and that Pakistan should simply accept this as the prerogative of a sovereign nation.

Both positions are understandable from their respective national perspectives, but neither really addresses the question I'm posing.

We are neighbours. We aren't going to stop being neighbours, regardless of who occupies the Red Fort or Islamabad's corridors of power.

And if our relationship is to be permanently defined by the assumption that the other is an adversary, what exactly are we hoping to achieve by perpetuating that relationship?

I'm not suggesting either country abandon its interests, overlook historical grievances or extend unconditional trust.

I'm simply exploring whether we can begin to build a functional relationship without first resolving every disagreement that has brought us to this point.
 
I'm gonna say some weird shit here, some of you may get it, some may not.

India and Pakistan could do with less frosty than they currently are.

The Kashmir matter is dead and settled in all but name. There is nothing big left to squabble over. Terrorism has left a bad taste in the mouth but both sides did it to each other. We all know that too.

However I don't ever want to see India and Pakistan move towards a 'friendship' and not for the usual reasons. I personally think that the only thing that keeps Pakistan separate from India is Islam. Without Islam in my generation I'm already seeing a resurgence of bollywood-esque kanjar-khana. Not saying it hasn't always existed, but it was never proudly displayed or backed up.

Without that barrier and with friendly relations with India, we risk a cultural infiltration. I don't want bollywood movies playing in Pakistan. I don't want to see Indian songs or memes circulating in Pakistan. None of it.

Not because I think any of it is 'bad'. But I feel it could easily dilute Pakistan's own identity and it almost did during that Aman ki Asha bull crap.
If I understand your position correctly and please correct me if I'm wrong:

- You're not opposed to reducing hostility or having more cordial relations with India.
- You don't necessarily want friendship or closer cultural ties.
- You see Islam as the principal distinguishing feature of Pakistani identity.
- You're concerned that greater cultural exchange, particularly given India's much larger entertainment industry, could dilute Pakistan's distinct cultural identity.
- You'd rather preserve that distinction, even if it means maintaining some degree of cultural separation.

I can understand the concern, but I disagree with the underlying assumption.

Surely a culture confident in its own identity should be able to engage with another without fearing its own dilution?

I don't see why peaceful coexistence, trade, tourism or even cultural exchange should come at the expense of Pakistani identity. Nor do I think Islam is the only thing that distinguishes Pakistan from India. There are distinct histories, languages, regional identities and cultural traditions that are worth preserving in their own right.

Why should being good neighbours require becoming culturally alike?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Latest Posts

Back
Top