It is not the future or existing governments of india that need to apologize, it is the common street indian who believed lies about Pakistanis and Pakistan, who intentionally jumped the band wagon of "Ghar may ghuss kay mary gay".
Establishing anything prior to that realisation is fruitless, after all it wasn't us attacking the Sri Lankan cricket team, it weren't us refusing to play with each other, it weren't us bragging about our money and we do not want you, the common street indian needs to first apologize for refusing to shake hands and insults. Everything else comes after this.
Should Pakistanis be hypocrite? Is that the question you are asking us?
If I'm understanding you correctly, your position is that:
- It isn't sufficient for the Indian government to change its approach or for diplomatic channels to reopen.
- Ordinary Indians who participated in, endorsed or encouraged hostility towards Pakistan and Pakistanis must first acknowledge their conduct and apologise.
- This acknowledgement must precede any meaningful attempt at normalisation. Anything less would amount to hypocrisy on Pakistan's part.
I fundamentally disagree with making this a precondition. You're effectively making the actions and attitudes of an entire population the determining factor in whether two countries can move forward. This isn't a condition that can realistically be fulfilled, and certainly not one that can be meaningfully imposed on an entire society.
The practical consequence is that normalisation becomes indefinitely conditional on an act of collective contrition that may never materialise. In effect, no change in government, no change in policy and no improvement in circumstances would be sufficient unless this prior condition was met.
And this brings me back to the thought experiment I'm proposing. Let's put aside, for a moment, whether we believe rapprochement is desirable or even achievable.
Let's examine two scenarios on their respective merits: continuing along the trajectory we've followed for decades, and exploring what an alternative relationship might look like without making the resolution of every historical grievance a prerequisite.
What are the respective costs, benefits, risks and opportunities foregone? What does each scenario mean for the ordinary Indian and Pakistani today, and for the generations that follow?
I'm not asking anyone to arrive at a predetermined conclusion. I'm suggesting that both possibilities deserve the same degree of scrutiny.