JF-17 - Updates, News & Discussion

I think my point got a little lost somewhere along the way.......

Pakistan moved from JF-17 Block I to Block II for a reason. The initial version had limitations, and operational experience showed that improvements were needed. That's how aircraft development works. right?
Pakistan's pilots and engineers would have provided feedback, which would have helped Chinese and Pakistani engineers identify areas for improvement and Chinese developed block 2.

My second point is about the airframe itself. Block I has some structural differences/limitations that could make a full Block III upgrade difficult or simply not worth the money, power and cooling and all that good stuff... yes, I'm not talking about changing the radar, putting in a few fancy screens and calling it Block III. I'm talking about the actual airframe, its structure and materials.

Now comes the million dollar question, what do we do with the Block I fleet in next 10 years?
I initially thought some of these airframes might need replacing within the next five years, but I haven't been able to find anything concrete to confirm that. (and no one from PAF will publicly confirm that)

Should Pakistan gradually retire these aircraft over the next 10 to 15 years? Or maintain them properly until 2040 and bring them out if there's a war? After all, Block I isn't going to magically become Block III just because we give it a new radar and a fresh coat of paint.

Wouldn't it make more sense to spend that money producing additional Block III aircraft rather than trying to keep the older Block I airframes flying until 2040?

And yes, I know someone will bring up the Mirages and how Pakistan has managed to keep them flying for decades. But just because we managed to keep the grandparents flying doesn't mean we have to do the same with every new generation of aircraft! 😂

BTW, that was a good attempt. I'll give you points for creativity.

Some good points here. PAF is not averse to getting rid of relatively new platforms if they take up too much resource compared to how much utility we get out of them. In past it has done so with examples like CN-235, F-7PG (Almost retired!), Harbin H-5, Supermarine Attacker. All these planes spent realtively little time in PAF and were then retired.

Can be the case we retire Block 1s before Mirages! Afterall USAF is planning on keeping B-52s longer then B-1s for same reason, it gets more out of the aircraft compared to resources put into it
 
Some good points here. PAF is not averse to getting rid of relatively new platforms if they take up too much resource compared to how much utility we get out of them. In past it has done so with examples like CN-235, F-7PG (Almost retired!), Harbin H-5, Supermarine Attacker. All these planes spent realtively little time in PAF and were then retired.

Can be the case we retire Block 1s before Mirages! Afterall USAF is planning on keeping B-52s longer then B-1s for same reason, it gets more out of the aircraft compared to resources put into it
Haven't read the whole discussion but I just wanted to point out an important role of fighter aircraft, even if they can't be used in front line combat... you need the pilots to stay current, build their hours and experience before converting to hi-tech aircraft... so the numbers are not just important for war only. Other uses like cannibalization for spare parts, training of air and ground crew etc. play a significant part in keeping the warfighting capabilities of a force at top notch.
Mirages and PG are obsolete for modern war, but young pilots need them in absence of LIFT. I think Block 1 will fill this role in next 5 years.
 
Haven't read the whole discussion but I just wanted to point out an important role of fighter aircraft, even if they can't be used in front line combat... you need the pilots to stay current, build their hours and experience before converting to hi-tech aircraft... so the numbers are not just important for war only. Other uses like cannibalization for spare parts, training of air and ground crew etc. play a significant part in keeping the warfighting capabilities of a force at top notch.
Mirages and PG are obsolete for modern war, but young pilots need them in absence of LIFT. I think Block 1 will fill this role in next 5 years.

Sure, but irrespective of the role (build hours, strike, training etc) there will be some types that are simply not worth the cost benefit right?

As you say, with PG it gives hours for currency but who knows, it could be that PAF may decide 1 hour in a JF-17 is worth 3 in a PG, or the fact we have such experiance of rebuilding Mirages, so many spare airframes that its more cost effective for the strike role then a Block 1?

Not saying the above is true, just examples of how some older types may be retained longer then newer types
 
I think my point got a little lost somewhere along the way.......

Pakistan moved from JF-17 Block I to Block II for a reason. The initial version had limitations, and operational experience showed that improvements were needed. That's how aircraft development works. right?
Pakistan's pilots and engineers would have provided feedback, which would have helped Chinese and Pakistani engineers identify areas for improvement and Chinese developed block 2.

My second point is about the airframe itself. Block I has some structural differences/limitations that could make a full Block III upgrade difficult or simply not worth the money, power and cooling and all that good stuff... yes, I'm not talking about changing the radar, putting in a few fancy screens and calling it Block III. I'm talking about the actual airframe, its structure and materials.

Now comes the million dollar question, what do we do with the Block I fleet in next 10 years?
I initially thought some of these airframes might need replacing within the next five years, but I haven't been able to find anything concrete to confirm that. (and no one from PAF will publicly confirm that)

Should Pakistan gradually retire these aircraft over the next 10 to 15 years? Or maintain them properly until 2040 and bring them out if there's a war? After all, Block I isn't going to magically become Block III just because we give it a new radar and a fresh coat of paint.

Wouldn't it make more sense to spend that money producing additional Block III aircraft rather than trying to keep the older Block I airframes flying until 2040?

And yes, I know someone will bring up the Mirages and how Pakistan has managed to keep them flying for decades. But just because we managed to keep the grandparents flying doesn't mean we have to do the same with every new generation of aircraft! 😂

BTW, that was a good attempt. I'll give you points for creativity.
you didn't answer my question dude
 
Sure, but irrespective of the role (build hours, strike, training etc) there will be some types that are simply not worth the cost benefit right?

As you say, with PG it gives hours for currency but who knows, it could be that PAF may decide 1 hour in a JF-17 is worth 3 in a PG, or the fact we have such experiance of rebuilding Mirages, so many spare airframes that its more cost effective for the strike role then a Block 1?

Not saying the above is true, just examples of how some older types may be retained longer then newer types
I did a feasibility study in Plans Directorate at AHQ to replace K-8 in FCU and the cost was enormous for any available platform, from L-15 to T-50... without complete data, I can't know that which decision makes more sense i.e. either we continue flying an outdated platform or buy a modern one. If I have the resources, it is a no-brainer. Otherwise, flying a system that is already in service for years is definitely cheaper than inducting a new one.
 
Last edited:
I did a feasibility study in Plans Directorate at AHQ to replace K-8 in FCU and the cost was enormous for any available platform, from L-15 to T-50... without complete data, I can't know that which decisiom makes more sense i.e. either we continue flying an outdated platform or buy a modern one. If I have the resources it is no brainer. Otherwise, flying a system that is already in service for years is definitely cheaper than inducting a new one.

Yeah, 100% Obviously we will never have the complete data and there are so many aspects that PAF have to take into account, even things such as the vast pool of trained engineers we have on Mirages over the years. Eventually the Mirage will have to go, but maybe like the B-52 and our C-130s, they have another decade or so to go...
 
Yeah, 100% Obviously we will never have the complete data and there are so many aspects that PAF have to take into account, even things such as the vast pool of trained engineers we have on Mirages over the years. Eventually the Mirage will have to go, but maybe like the B-52 and our C-130s, they have another decade or so to go...
Not a decade... 2027 was given as final retirement year, but maybe due to delay in more J-10C and probably J-35, their service will be stretched for 2-3 years...
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Latest Posts

Back
Top