JF-17 - Updates, News & Discussion

Haven't thought much about it, but let's see... 40 J-10C and 36 J-35 by 2030, which means 6 squadrons of PG and Mirages can be retired gradually. We need a LIFT and a Chinese system makes more sense, so L-15E or if any newer model is available to replace our jet trainers.
In mid 2030s, the older F-16s and JF-17s will need replacement. If loyal wingman and stealth jet drones are completely operational by then, we may not need that many manned fighters. Also, hopefully we may see some developments in our own 5th gen platform with help of China and Turkiye.
Bottom line is that we can leverage technology to improve quality and reduce quantity in PAF.

I think there can be a case to be made for PAF to reduce Sqd numbers. Now IAF is only 28 Sqds (and with the Jag retrements will go down by another 6 Sqds)
 
(Ab) Sir, what PAF does with their JF-17s' is their prerogative.

One would assume that with the Block-system, the older variants (Block I & II's) would systematically be upgraded to current variants (structural changes to wings, Radars etc).

But again..., [wo tou PAF he janney].

However, the F-16's aren't going anywhere in the 30s' or even (possibly) the 40s'. And i'm not talking about the Block-52's. [Haan, wo becharey 19 Sqn (Sherdils) ka koi hul nahe. Wo tou bilkul farig hain.]

Yeah, worry is will we want to still be using APG-68/AMRAAM C-5 post 2030? We missed the boat on the V upgrades. Also support for this fit is going to start ti dwindle as customers move on to the F-35 or F-16V. Not like the Mirage scenario where we can source everything from other countries and have in house ability to upgrade and rebuild. F-16 will be a real pain to maintain at the C/D-MLU levek a few years from now
 
I think there can be a case to be made for PAF to reduce Sqd numbers. Now IAF is only 28 Sqds (and with the Jag retrements will go down by another 6 Sqds)
The numbers will be obviously reduced... 2 sqn of J-10 and J-35 each can achieve a lot more than a dozen Mirage and F-7 squadrons.
 
The numbers will be obviously reduced... 2 sqn of J-10 and J-35 each can achieve a lot more than a dozen Mirage and F-7 squadrons.

Yeah, for sure, but at some point we reach a minimum right? One jet, no matter how capable, cannot be in both places at the same time and by all reports we have a JF-17 unit in Saudi (Possibly our only Block II unit?)
 
I am not sure, we still have like 4 Sqds of Mirages. Even if it is not 1 on 1 replacement that is still quite a lot of Sqds to replace, especially considering the worrying fact we have not had any new fighter deiveries for the last 2-3 years, so we do not even have teams working up on new equipment (which takes a long time as we know).

3 years ago I would have shared your optimism, or if the Mirage fleet was only 1-2 Sqds then it may be possible but we would need to induct quite a large number quite quickly for a 2-3 year timeline to work. Maybe Chinese can do that for us? Unsure
3 Mirage squadrons, but we don't have to replace them with 3 squadrons of J-10 or J-35. A single sqn of 4.5 or 5th gen is more than enough to replace whole 3rd gen fleet.
 
Yeah, for sure, but at some point we reach a minimum right? One jet, no matter how capable, cannot be in both places at the same time and by all reports we have a JF-17 unit in Saudi (Possibly our only Block II unit?)
Define minimum. A single J-10C sqn has done more than all others combined in air-to-air role. So 2 J-10C and J-35 sqn each with current inventory of F-16 and JF-17 is more than enough till 2030. Then depending upon development of our own 5th gen and stealth drones, we will see the retirement plans of older 4th gen fighters.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TAC
(Ab) Sir, what PAF does with their JF-17s' is their prerogative.

One would assume that with the Block-system, the older variants (Block I & II's) would systematically be upgraded to current variants (structural changes to wings, Radars etc).

But again..., [wo tou PAF he janney].

However, the F-16's aren't going anywhere in the 30s' or even (possibly) the 40s'. And i'm not talking about the Block-52's. [Haan, wo becharey 19 Sqn (Sherdils) ka koi hul nahe. Wo tou bilkul farig hain.]
Bhai meri taraf se 19 sqn bhi na retire karen 2040 tak. 😅 and I don't think block 1 can be upgraded to block 3 standard. But we need all these cockpits because a newly graduated pilot cannot go directly to J-10C.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TAC
3 Mirage squadrons, but we don't have to replace them with 3 squadrons of J-10 or J-35. A single sqn of 4.5 or 5th gen is more than enough to replace whole 3rd gen fleet.

Not really.

A single squadron cannot be in all the places that 3 squadrons can - even with better platform capability.

The Indian air force is numerically superior and once they sort out their procurement problems of new capable platforms, will pose both a qualitative and numerical threat ..

Also, there is only so much you can expect a pilot to do per day regardless of platform capability, and only so many pilots you can assign to an airframe given the servicing requirements of an airframe itself.

We did see during the 2019 clash, and Sindoor that India was able to open up holes in PAF defences by having more airframes in the air in creating diversionary tactics that the PAF struggled to match in terms of placements of PAF jets and while PAF got the jump on the IAF via the PL15E during Sindoor, that advantage will ultimately be neutralised by matching capability procurements by the IAF.

In the IAF - PAF equation, there is a numbers game with regards to the ratio of forces, and lets not forget the elephant in the room of needing more airframes to meet the requirements of the Makkah Pact itself. If PAF needs to be able to contribute to the Makkah Pact, it needs more airframes now, not less.
 
Last edited:
Define minimum. A single J-10C sqn has done more than all others combined in air-to-air role. So 2 J-10C and J-35 sqn each with current inventory of F-16 and JF-17 is more than enough till 2030. Then depending upon development of our own 5th gen and stealth drones, we will see the retirement plans of older 4th gen fighters.

I dont know, there are many other factors right? Attrition, foreign committments, and as mentioned, at somme point number matter. Even the USAF massively regrets having "just" 180 off F-22s
 
Bhai meri taraf se 19 sqn bhi na retire karen 2040 tak. 😅 and I don't think block 1 can be upgraded to block 3 standard. But we need all these cockpits because a newly graduated pilot cannot go directly to J-10C.
Spent an hour (by luck) with someone from Kamra. One of the topics covered was just that. Apparently, its not impossible, but seems like cost is coming a bit too high.

If we were to retire the Block I's by 2035, would mean that their service life would of been ...what...25 Years (give or take).
 
Spent an hour (by luck) with someone from Kamra. One of the topics covered was just that. Apparently, its not impossible, but seems like cost is coming a bit too high.

If we were to retire the Block I's by 2035, would mean that their service life would of been ...what...25 Years (give or take).
I guess we will be in a better position to guess about that in 2030. If we get 5th gen and a LIFT, manned aircraft squadrons can be reduced if stealth loyal wingman become operational too.
 
I dont know, there are many other factors right? Attrition, foreign committments, and as mentioned, at somme point number matter. Even the USAF massively regrets having "just" 180 off F-22s
Let's not bring in USAF or PLAAF and keep it to IAF vs PAF. Anyway, too many variables right now, but if 5th gen is inducted, we definitely won't need this many manned aircraft.
 
Not really.

A single squadron cannot be in all the places that 3 squadrons can - even with better platform capability.

The Indian air force is numerically superior and once they sort out their procurement problems of new capable platforms, will pose both a qualitative and numerical threat ..

Also, there is only so much you can expect a pilot to do per day regardless of platform capability, and only so many pilots you can assign to an airframe given the servicing requirements of an airframe itself.

We did see during the 2019 clash, and Sindoor that India was able to open up holes in PAF defences by having more airframes in the air in creating diversionary tactics that the PAF struggled to match in terms of placements of PAF jets and while PAF got the jump on the IAF via the PL15E during Sindoor, that advantage will ultimately be neutralised by matching capability procurements by the IAF.

In the IAF - PAF equation, there is a numbers game with regards to the ratio of forces, and lets not forget the elephant in the room of needing more airframes to meet the requirements of the Makkah Pact itself. If PAF needs to be able to contribute to the Makkah Pact, it needs more airframes now, not less.
Nope, that assumption isn't right because you need a certain number of aircraft for a mission. A pair of J-10C can cover more area than 3 four-ship of F-7 PG. And this is without aerial refuelling because PG has less loiter time and not all Mirages have refuelling probe. If you have to escort Army Chief to Iran, that is not possible even with 20 squadrons of 3rd gen fighters.
40 J-10C and 36 J-35 is a good number, supplemented by around 200+ F-16/JF-17. IAF's advantage wasn't numbers in air because they didn't challenge PAF in air on 10th. They could have brought 100 aircraft but they chose to fire Brahmos and SCALP only.
Makkah pact is beyond my comprehension. It looks like it is for optics and nuclear umbrella because Saudis have better aircraft. We have many Mirage/F-7 pilots who didn't get Command of a sqn. Saudis can induct them as fighter pilots, or give me a few billion dollars to buy J-10C that are specifically for their defence. A couple of PAF squadrons can't defend whole Saudi airspace.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top