Pakistan-China Deal for 700 Advanced VT-4B Tanks: A Major Challenge for India

All true. I guess it depends on how much commonality there is between the variants. If it is a major overhaul then as you said it is better off buying whole new tanks instead of modifying the original contract. But if Norinco can provide much of that new capabilities in the form of upgrade kits then this is viable.
Generally, for armored vehicles, different variants within the same product family—sharing a common designation—typically utilize the same chassis architecture, including the powerpack. Even when different engines are employed, they usually possess a degree of interchangeability and commonality.

Based on available photographs, the turrets of the VT-4 and VT-4B exhibit both evolutionary links and distinct differences; it is certain that they are not identical. Specific internal details, however, remain unknown.

From a pragmatic standpoint, a more sound approach for the Pakistan Army would be to procure a limited number of VT-4B tanks to operate alongside their existing VT-4 fleet, or to acquire new short-range air defense systems to integrate into VT-4 formations. Instead of rejecting or suspending the current VT-4 contract and replacing it with the VT-4B contract.

The PLA Ground Force (PLAGF) fields a large number of Type 99A main battle tanks (MBTs), which lack organic anti-drone capabilities. To address this, the Chinese military integrates HQ-17A and Type 625 gun-missile air defense systems into units alongside the Type 99A MBTs, providing them with short-range, localized air defense. Furthermore, this defensive framework is supplemented by other advanced platforms, such as ground-based radar systems and directed-energy weapons—including both laser and microwave-based systems.
 
Last edited:
Ok I am from armoured infantry ! Tell me how not !

Tanks can be seperated from tanks and Tanks can be seperated from IFVs right?

So what is the point you are making? Modern IFVs can keep up with modern tanks. If we were to accept your thesis all tanks would operate alone for fear of being seperated
 
Tanks can be seperated from tanks and Tanks can be seperated from IFVs right?

So what is the point you are making? Modern IFVs can keep up with modern tanks. If we were to accept your thesis all tanks would operate alone for fear of being seperated

Easy:

In defence operations @Signalian is absolutely right that ist very difficult to separate Pakistani infantry from armoured formations/sections because infantry can retreated, regroup in very well prepared defence rooms.

Defence rooms: Bunkers - trenches - urban areas- civilian buildings- firing positions - fox holes- under earth tunnels with firing doors windows - under earth trenches - traps for enemy - Tank holes in earth - Tank bunkers……the list is too long all which are not visible for Indians during peacetime.

In Offense there is no protection when infantry section are running near behind and God forbid in front of Tanks. Our current M-113 is the weakest point - it does not offer any protection against artillery shrapnel’s and Drone attack in his current configuration -

Infantry has limits to fight from within the vehicle and give fire support because the board gun hat not a protected turret.

Configuration of current M-113 must be changed- add better protection - add more fire power - add passive protection.

Explain me how M-113 will operate in current modern drone age scenario against Indian modern warfare. Pakistani armoured personell carrier are configured only as battle taxi for 1970-1980s era. Time has changed. Pakistan has great industry capacity to do better.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_9963.jpeg
    IMG_9963.jpeg
    185.5 KB · Views: 2
Easy:

In defence operations @Signalian absolutely right that ist very difficult to separate Pakistani infantry from armoured formations/sections because infantry can retreated, regroup in very well prepared defence rooms.

Defence rooms: Bunkers - trenches - urban areas- civilian buildings- firing positions - fox holes- under earth tunnels with firing doors windows - under earth trenches - traps for enemy - Tank holes in earth - Tank bunkers……the list is too long all which are not visible for Indians during peacetime.

In Offense there is no protection when infantry section are running near behind and God forbid in front of Tanks. Our current M-113 is the weakest point - it does not offer any protection against artillery shrapnel’s and Drone attack in his current configuration -

Infantry has limits to fight from within the vehicle and give fire support because the board gun hat not a protected turret.

Configuration of current M-113 must be changed- add better protection - add more fire power - add passive protection.

Explain me how M-113 will operate in current modern drone age scenario against Indian modern warfare. Pakistani armoured personell carrier are configured only as battle taxi for 1970-1980s era. Time has changed. Pakistan has great industry capacity to do better.

You did not answer my point about seperating IFVs from tanks in combat. For the record I specically mentioned IFVs (and if you are in armoured infantry you would know the M113 is not an IFV).

I was not debating the point of what would happen to dismounted infantry. That is a seperate discussion, if you can focus on the point in hand it would be handy
 
You did not answer my point about seperating IFVs from tanks in combat. For the record I specically mentioned IFVs (and if you are in armoured infantry you would know the M113 is not an IFV).

I was not debating the point of what would happen to dismounted infantry. That is a seperate discussion, if you can focus on the point in hand it would be handy


I am on focus of this and handy since 2006. I am thinking and debating about this since 20 years in this forum.
The answer is easy Pakistan Army does not have deployed IFV. So the question is answered above. I thought this topic a about Pakistan Army. Which Army are you talking about ? US army ? yes they have IFV mass deployed and very well configurated.
 
Last edited:
I am on focus of this and handy since 2006. I am thinking and debating about this since 20 years in this forum.
The answer is easy Pakistan Army does not have deployed IFV. So the question is answered above. I thought this topic a about Pakistan Army. Which Army are you talking about ? US army ? yes they have IFV mass deployed and very well configurated.

Yes, my point was about IFV/Tank combined arms. It is as hard to seperate an IFV from a tank as it is seperating a tank from a tank
 
Yes, my point was about IFV/Tank combined arms. It is as hard to seperate an IFV from a tank as it is seperating a tank from a tank

You are absolutely right - but in Pakistan case how do think could the scenario look like ?
 
You are absolutely right - but in Pakistan case how do think could the scenario look like ?

Ah! Well, that is simple. Replace M113! No other choice.

Issue is HIT never put the R&D in or we never attempted a JV with the likes of BAE Systems, Doosan or Rheinmettal

We just churned out M113 copies for last 30 years.
 
Ah! Well, that is simple. Replace M113! No other choice.

Issue is HIT never put the R&D in or we never attempted a JV with the likes of BAE Systems, Doosan or Rheinmettal

We just churned out M113 copies for last 30 years.

There also a more realistic solution- see what Ukraine can do with their war torched industrial capacity. Pakistan can do
More and better ! The M-113 not the whole fleet but the strike formations need upgrades. Add on armour, more motor power, more fire power, KI- AI controlled anti drone guns , fighting compartments from inside the vehicle, a turret gun….
 
There also a more realistic solution- see what Ukraine can do with their war torched industrial capacity. Pakistan can do
More and better ! The M-113 not the whole fleet but the strike formations need upgrades. Add on armour, more motor power, more fire power, KI- AI controlled anti drone guns , fighting compartments from inside the vehicle, a turret gun….

Yeah, think Turks did this to an extent and got an M113 on steriods. Truth be told we have what? 3,000 odd M113s?

How we ever gonna replace them all?
 
Every tank needs to have an in-situ "microwave" weapon! It's now a war by the electrical engineers, of the electrical engineers, and for the electrical engineers....

Electrical engineering is now the mother of all technologies. The rest are all details....

Give me a team of good electrical engineers who can implement their imagination, and I will give you a victory....

*Electrical engineering is no coding for the "social media" companies.
**In Turkey, many a top high school grad chooses EE as a major. Turkey's top defense companies are the brainchildren of electrical engineers, including Merhum President Turgut Ozal, ykar CTO Selchuk Bayraktar etc.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, think Turks did this to an extent and got an M113 on steriods. Truth be told we have what? 3,000 odd M113s?

How we ever gonna replace them all?

Yes 2500-3000 exactly !
Don’t need to replace - upgrade !
 

Users who are viewing this thread

  • Country Watch Latest

    Back
    Top