So did slavery...how does encouraging continuing doing things the wrong way because it worked suddenly justify anything?
The question is, what is "the right way" and what is "the wrong way"?
Is it deporting them is "the right way" while having people who are qualified for residency ANYWAY to get what they wanted is the "the wrong way"? I mean those people are going to get residency anyway, and they had been living and contributing to the US economy?
We have been deporting them since 1996, does that solve the issue? If not, how is this "the right way"?
Well then there should be no argument...
There was never an argument to begin with.
Well again how does encouraging doing things the wrong way suddenly justify anything? Can we concentrate on doing things the correct way instead?
Again, what is "the correct way"?
How does taking advantage of people who can't get the same benefits of US citizens the admirable way of doing things???? This is like US companies moving manufacturing of their most polluting products to Asia. This does not seem like the correct long term path of solving problems at all. This is just some quick shortcut at best...and a potentially long term headache at worst.
Dude, this is more complex than what you just said, economy migrate and evolve like people evolved, the issue here is we aren't in 1950 anymore, you can't base a service base economy on manufacturing, that's the reason why we loose all those to begin with.
As living standard increase, there are some job that aren't going to fill like it was used to be, again, if I offer you $40/hr to build a house, would you do it? That's a lot more than some mid level white collar job.
That's fine...deporting illegals wont cure cancer either but that shouldn't stop us from doing it.
Again just because people aren't playing ball doesn't mean we should cancel anything. Why should we bend any enforcement simply because illegals are being uncooperative?
Fear of people being uncooperative isn't a good excuse for loosening enforcement.
You misunderstood my point, I am not saying we need to stop deporting people, again, look at 2024 when Biden deported probably the most people since probably last 20 years, with a record number of arrest. DEPORTING IS NOT THE ISSUE BEFORE.
www.ice.gov
Arrest over time
Detention Over Time
Removal Over Time
See how much different this is? And do you want to know why?
That's because when people are trusting the system, they will throw themselves at it, and they will work WITH the system, attending tribunal, attending court, and if it turns out unsuccessful, they are deported, again, that's because those illegal immigrants believe in the system that work for them
If they start believing the system is going against them, they will work AGAINST the system, again, 12 million illegal, 100,000 DHS agents, you do the maths. You need to have a system that works for them, instead of just going everywhere, arresting people left and right, and without processing them, and you now ask them to trust the system? They will just go underground and it make them very hard to catch, that is the reason why with all these threatric, you see the number wasn't even close to the low point during the Biden Administration.
Now, you are talking about "The right way" and "The wrong way" does those number looks like "The Right Way" to you?
Again that's not a good reason to re-write policy.
Do we knock the penalty for murder down to a slap on the wrist so killers wont go into hiding? Certainly would make law enforcement much easier and less dangerous for police.
Again, it does NOT work because the law and the system
WAS FLAWED, you aren't going to get a miracle and think this is going to be A-OK, murdering is a different issue, because you don't have 12 million murderer out there and you have way more than 100,000 agent to catch these people.
And for a person who keep accusing those Chinese member of whataboutism, you sure use them a lot too.
So? That happens in other countries too. Do you think the answer it to tear the whole thing down because it is 100% useless??
So? The definition of insane is keep doing the same thing and keep failing and still hope it would work, again, I have shown you deportation isn't really the issue here, and it was the law, and your answer is, "oh if that's not working then should we tear down the whole system?" If it stopped working since 1996, then YES, we need to tear down the whole system.
This exact same thing happened in Australia during the the Tempa Affair, asylum seeker/illegal immigration is not an issue just catering to the American, this is a big headache in Australia too and do you want to know how the Aussie solved the problem? It's by changing the law and eliminating anyone that arrive by boat from getting residency in Australia. It's only either deportation or resettlement. We had seen this problem for a decade since 2001 and in 2013 we changed the law, and now boat largely stopped coming.
In his campaign launch speech on August 25, 2013, Tony Abbott pledged: "We'll build a stronger economy so everyone can get ahead. We'll scrap the carbon tax so your family will be $550 a year better off. We'll get the budget back under control by ending Labor's waste. We'll stop the boats." See...
www.abc.net.au
So to answer your question, YES, if something wasn't working in the last 30 years, then it's time to look outside the box and start tearing things down, I am not saying what happened in Australia can be applied to the US, as the situation is different, but keep doing the same thing over and over and over again, won't get you anywhere, you don't need to be a genius to see it.