Can Pakistan Win Bangladesh’s Trust Without Apologizing for the Genocide of 1971?

he meant generous or open minded or having a big heart, etc. Whenever there is a fight, both sides do horrible things. So, sideling those grievances and taking the first step means being generous enough there.

I hope you posed that out of curiosity and meant well.

I do more than mean well. If transfer of power after elections are completed does not happen, then all round destruction starts, everywhere. Imagine if trump refused to yield biden after loss or vice versa, USA will not exist. It will descend into civil war and burn down.
 
Everyone knows West Pakistani military committed injustices and excesses you, joker.

The point is, Sheikh Mujibur Rehman won the elections, why wasn't he given his mandate then?

It was the fault of the democracy and not of anyone else.

Yes, but the Mukti Bahini of Bangladesh also committed injustices against the Urdu speaking Biharis. That needs to be mentioned.

Any particular reason for your name calling? I am letting you off easy without any warning this time.

Re atrocities on Urdu speakers - I have already acknowledged that in my previous post in this thread and have talked about it numerous times over the years.

https://defencepk.com/forums/thread...g-for-the-genocide-of-1971.32307/post-1301696

Any more verbal abuse and you are getting a time off from this thread.
 
Isn't this overstretched? Do actually read the stuff that was going on since 1906 to 1947.

I simplified and just concentrated on M A Jinnah. I'm aware of the history.

If you asked me, Bd disowned the Islamic history of the sub continent.
 
Last edited:
Yes we can formally apologize. But not for genocide or rape which is just propaganda.
Rape did happen, and between 200k and 300k brothers and sisters of East Pakistan died [including Bengali and non-Bengali speaking]. Call it what may. It happened under the nose of the Pakistani military establishment.
 
I think both nations would benefit if both nations can admit their own faults, offer apology and move on. Bangladesh should apologize for Agartala Conspiracy, then Mukti Bahini seeking help from the enemy and then slaughtering West Pakistanis and Biharis, And in response, Pakistan should apologize for any excess that was committed during military operation to restore order in the Eastern territory and stopping the bloodshed.

If both parties agree to this, only then we can have a proper apology ceremony, otherwise, asking one party to apologize is meaningless.
this is the way
 
I believe Bangladesh did injustice to M. A Jinnah (RA) because without him there wouldn't be a Pakistan. Bd should have preserved his contribution for the creation of Pakistan even though EP separated from WP. Bottom line, he is the original founder of Bangladesh.

Would be bit of a stretch... Jinnah wanted an independent state of United Bengal. Brits didn’t!

Second, as to the premise of this thread... Pakistan has nothing to prove to Bengal, period. People have inherent common cause and that manifests regardless of pain that some pull to avert. Bengal has been through a very rough period of both overt and covert bouts of deceit, propaganda and subterfuge... to shake the core and paint them anew!
There best bet is to sit through the tide... as hindutva dies it's slow grinding death and nations within it start looking more inwards to trace their true identities instead of the one curated for them...
 
Last edited:
Rape did happen, and between 200k and 300k brothers and sisters of East Pakistan died [including Bengali and non-Bengali speaking]. Call it what may. It happened under the nose of the Pakistani military establishment.
Totally agreed. A willingness to acknowledge past wrongdoings is the first step toward building a lasting relationship based on mutual respect and mutual benefit.

The founding father of Bangladesh, the former elected leader of Pakistan, and one of the most influential Bengalis in history, Mujibur Rahman, believed in this principle. That is why, after Pakistan officially recognized Bangladesh as an independent nation, he welcomed Bhutto to independent Bangladesh for diplomatic talks and to begin the process of normalizing relations between the two countries.
 
I thought Pakistan had always shared the same values as the West.
 
The current warmth in Bangladesh-Pakistan bilateral relations is less a product of mutual trust and more a function of geopolitical calculations.

By Siam Sarower Jamil
June 01, 2026

View attachment 199758

On May 8, Pakistan’s interior minister and chairman of its Cricket Board, Syed Mohsin Raza Naqvi, arrived in Dhaka for a two-day visit. His visit coincided with the Bangladesh-Pakistan cricket series, but it was not merely sports-centric. It also carried distinct political and strategic messages.

In the landscape of South Asian politics, the relationship between Bangladesh and Pakistan has historically been both complex and emotionally charged. A political betrayal — Pakistan’s refusal to transfer power, ignoring the mass mandate of the Bengalis in the 1970 election, and the memories of the genocide during the 1971 Liberation War — lingered and kept bilateral relations frosty for a prolonged period. Nevertheless, amidst the shifting realities of international politics, recent times have seen the beginnings of a new diplomatic warmth between Dhaka and Islamabad.

Soon after the fall of the Sheikh Hasina government on August 5, 2024, several Pakistani ministers, including Deputy Prime Minister Ishaq Dar, visited Dhaka. Pakistan’s Chief of Army Staff, Field Marshal Asim Munir, also met with Bangladesh Air Force Chief Hasan Mahmood Khan at Rawalpindi in Pakistan on January 8, 2026. Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif is expected to visit Dhaka in June after Bangladeshi Prime Minister Tarique Rahman visits China. These visits are not merely acts of diplomatic courtesy; rather, they reflect the emerging geopolitical realities of South Asia.

The pertinent question remains whether this growing closeness between Bangladesh and Pakistan signals a new beginning. Or is it merely a fleeting mirage borne of strategic necessity?

Weight of History and the Realities of Bilateral Relations

Undoubtedly, the greatest source of unease in Bangladesh-Pakistan relations remains the 1971 war. Memories of the genocide perpetrated by the Pakistani forces on Bangladeshi intellectuals and masses, and the atrocities committed against women, remain deeply etched in the minds of the Bangladeshi people. Consequently, any initiative aimed at improving relations with Pakistan becomes inextricably intertwined with public sentiments. Political parties have often leveraged this history for their own ends, thereby rendering the issue of bilateral relations even more sensitive.

When the Awami League was in power in Bangladesh between 2008 and 2024, relations with Pakistan were frosty, especially due to the trial and conviction of several leaders of the Jamaat-e-Islami, which collaborated with Pakistan in the 1971 war, on charges of crimes against humanity. On several occasions, Pakistan voiced objections to the judicial proceedings, which in turn, only served to widen the rift between the two countries.

However, the political shifts in Bangladesh following Hasina’s ouster ushered in a new reality. During the interim government, there was a noticeable increase in visits to Bangladesh by Pakistani ministers and military officials, accompanied by a visible surge in diplomatic and military engagement between the two countries.

Nevertheless, the historical burden remains unresolved. Pakistan has yet to offer a full and formal apology for the genocide committed in 1971. A significant segment of the Bangladeshi population firmly believes that genuine improvement in bilateral relations is impossible without Pakistan’s acknowledgment of its culpability. Consequently, while diplomatic exchanges may have increased, the psychological distance between the two nations remains significant.
https://www.actirise.com/?utm_source=thediplomat.com&utm_campaign=intext
On the other hand, the reality of the modern state system dictates that, alongside emotional sentiments, strategic and economic interests are also important. Bangladesh’s burgeoning economic power within South Asia is compelling Pakistan to re-evaluate its approach to the relationship. And concurrently, as part of its multifaceted diplomatic strategy, Bangladesh seeks to cultivate ties with all key regional powers. However, the progress of these relations must be carefully calibrated to ensure that the delicate geopolitical balance with India remains undisturbed.

New Equations in Geopolitics and Security Cooperation

During his recent visit to Dhaka, Naqvi held meetings with Bangladesh’s Home Minister Salahuddin Ahmed as well as State Minister for Foreign Affairs Shama Obaid. The most significant outcome of Naqvi’s visit was the signing of an MoU on security cooperation. Under the terms of this agreement, the two nations are set to exchange intelligence and technical assistance to combat drug trafficking, money laundering, and cross-border crime.

However, given that Bangladesh shares no land border with Pakistan, how far can such cooperation go? The agreements seem to be more of a diplomatic spectacle, with little substantive impact on security.

Furthermore, Pakistan’s security apparatus has long been a subject of controversy within the international arena. Issues such as the prevalence of terrorism, its use of terrorist groups as a tool of its foreign policy, the proliferation of extremist groups, and the instability along its border with Afghanistan have cast a shadow over the country’s international image. Consequently, some analysts are skeptical as to how truly beneficial security cooperation with such a state would prove to be for Bangladesh.

In the context of the ongoing crisis in West Asia, Pakistan is striving to project itself as a significant regional power. Leveraging its position as a close ally of the United States and China and its active engagement in the Afghanistan issue, Islamabad is seeking to enhance its standing in the international arena.

Pakistan frequently exploits regional crises to secure strategic advantages. Consequently, questions persist regarding the sincerity of its sudden overtures toward Bangladesh.

Bangladesh’s foremost challenge lies in maintaining a strategic equilibrium. Dhaka aims to cultivate balanced relationships with China, India, the United States, and the Muslim world. Yet, excessive proximity to Pakistan could generate unease with India — a country that surrounds Bangladesh on three sides. It could pose risks to Bangladesh’s economic and national security interests. The current warmth in Bangladesh-Pakistan bilateral relations is less a product of mutual trust and more a function of geopolitical calculations.

New Possibilities or a Diplomatic Mirage?

Not only has Pakistan not formally apologized for the 1971 genocide, but the issue of assets owed to Bangladesh also remains unresolved. These matters are obstacles in the path of improving bilateral relations.

In addition, Pakistan lacks the robust commercial infrastructure necessary to meet Bangladesh’s import demands. Consequently, positioning Pakistan as a viable alternative to India will not be an easy task.

Nevertheless, new avenues for trade, education, technology, and cultural exchange could emerge between the two nations. There is considerable potential for cooperation in the textile, pharmaceutical, and agricultural sectors, in particular. As Pakistan seeks to reduce its economic isolation within South Asia, Bangladesh is simultaneously exploring new export destinations and investment opportunities beyond its traditional partners. This convergence of economic interests has encouraged Islamabad to court Bangladeshi investment and pursue closer commercial ties. Enhanced people-to-people contact could also help alleviate mutual mistrust to some extent.

However, the sustainability of these relations will ultimately hinge upon political goodwill. If the relationship remains confined merely to formal visits and diplomatic communiqués, it is unlikely to endure. Similarly, if Pakistan continues to maintain an ambiguous stance regarding its history with Bangladesh, it will be difficult to dispel the mistrust prevailing among the Bangladeshi people.


only the military junta needs to apologize this was their scew up....
 
How is this genorosity? Isnt it a basic principle?

Most of us Pakistanis weren't even born then, we were not part of anything related to that incident. No court on earth can hold us responsible for anything related to it. So, even then when we accept that our side was unfair and we apologize for that, it means we are being generous.

May be hard to understand for citizen of the country, where the first thing they do to a foreigner is, plan how to scam them.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Latest Posts

Back
Top