H-1B visas must end’: Wife of US citizen shares plight of landing IT jobs

That is just an extreme copium mechanism for those who were celebrating prematurely. The courts are still going to be slammed with lawsuits and the administration is still going to lose even on the issue of imposing the tax on employers sponsoring new visas because it remains a huge overreach of executive authority that completely changes the fundamental characteristic of a program set up by Congress. It is just that their losses would be less dramatic because they have voluntarily withdrawn the flagrant violation of due process they had initially contemplated.

If the administration were really serious about this, they would have worked with Congress to amend the law to get a legal basis for their action that would have stood in court.
So if I understand this correctly, existing individuals are exempt?

I don't know about the whole constitutionality of the act aspect but it's essentially targeting the newer arrivals right? So the current setup would remain but future hiring will be scrutinized? Fair enough. It's their country their rules.

India benefited 20-25 years from the whole process. Now it's time to diversify services to our own market and in other markets we have FTAs with. STEM is still the most popular choice among new graduates in India. The buffer zone is short but we have to make do with what we have.

There would still be intake of
high skilled professionals albeit in smaller numbers.

This essentially means that hiring from all nationalities will drop. I wonder how big tech in America and the likes of Elon Musk who heaped praise on H1B will counter this. The current American labour force can hardly accommodate all the demand. American graduates prefer to graduate with abstract degrees like "yoga" and "painting", they'll need to produce STEM graduates at a much higher scale.

America is playing the long game, in short run they know the Indians are running the silicon valley. It will be about loopholes and offshoring for now.
 
Last edited:
@A1Kaid

The entitlement, the fraud, the scams by Indians in the West is disgusting and it isn’t perpetrated by a small minority but by a system of companies Infosys, TCS and others.

So why does the US Govt turn a blind eye to the malpractices?

Regards
 
@A1Kaid

The entitlement, the fraud, the scams by Indians in the West is disgusting and it isn’t perpetrated by a small minority but by a system of companies Infosys, TCS and others.

So why does the US Govt turn a blind eye to the malpractices?

Regards

Past politics. That is now changing. Not just Trump but even congress is acting.
 
@BrigSmart

but a face-saving move to avoid humiliating defeats in US courts.

There is such a thing called "Rule of Law." But this concept can be appreciated only by those who are citizens of or originate from nations where this concept applies.

Regards
I don't really care about the H1B programme now. In fact, I think it would be better for India if it were to end and the brain drain from India were to stop. India should look at China's example. They have managed to build world-class technology companies by retaining their human capital rather than exporting it to the West.

I just find some of the ridiculous and uninformed hopium and copium opinions on this thread funny and am here for the entertainment.
 
He may have time, but he has no power to make the changes he wants to. The rollback was not a diplomatic overture to India, but a face-saving move to avoid humiliating defeats in US courts.
Let's convert MAGA to MIGA

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
He may have time, but he has no power to make the changes he wants to. The rollback was not a diplomatic overture to India, but a face-saving move to avoid humiliating defeats in US courts.
"Rollback" was neither of these suggested strategems.

On the contrary, it was precisely where Trump wanted the matter to equilibrate.
 

H-1B visa program, which allows US employers to hire foreign professionals in specialised fields, is under scrutiny as debates about its impact on American workers intensify on social media.

Many US citizens, especially in fields like software engineering, are expressing concerns that the program puts them at a disadvantage in securing jobs.

One such voice comes from the wife of a US citizen and software professional, who shares the difficulties her husband has faced in finding work, despite his 30 years of experience.

She explained the over-reliance on H-1B visa holders in the tech industry has made it harder for qualified American workers to land jobs.

Her husband has spent over a year going through multiple interviews each week, only to face rejection, often due to the preference given to foreign workers under the H-1B program.

The H-1B visa is a non-immigrant visa that allows US companies to hire foreign professionals with specialized knowledge, typically requiring at least a bachelor’s degree.

Sponsored by employers, the visa is initially valid for three years and can be extended, with visa holders also able to pursue permanent residency through its dual intent provision.

What does the tweet explain?​

An experienced US software engineer’s wife opened up about her husband’s harrowing job search over the past year, exposing what she sees as a flawed hiring process that works against American workers.

The US-citizen software engineer has been waiting for a job offer despite going to several interviews each week, and his wife is complaining about what he sees as a “biased and faulty hiring process.”

She wrote on X, “My husband is a US citizen, software engineer with about 30 years of experience. He was unemployed for over a year. In that time he had multiple interviews every week, but no job offers. He was given “tests” that he didn’t “quite” pass.”

The tweet added, “He wrote code as part of the interview and then it was nitpicked because it wasn’t the way the interviewer would have done it. The process is a scam. HR and interviewers are gatekeepers. H1B visas need to be ended and only American citizens should be in charge of hiring decisions.”

‘These interviews are just useless’​

Netizens posted their concerns and experience on the post. A user noted, “Yes, you are right, the interviews are just for show, they want to show that they are unable to find enough qualified people, get approved to bring more people from India. Ive known of cases where an American is fired, replaced by a less qualified person from India, people fired are in many cases still in touch with coworkers who can easily determine if the replacement is better qualified or not.”

They further added, “In many cases the IT manager and even the CEO are from india, now, how much money are those people getting from India or from the agencies that bring the workers? The entire thing is a big scam played at the expense of Americans.”

Another claimed, “Every US Citizen in tech should go to https://jobs.now and apply for every job in their specialty. Then, when no call backs or passed over, they should file a complaint with DOJ about that company excluding American workers. Start the avalanche now.”

A user stated, “If the recruiter or hiring manager is Indian there is zero chance for Americans. Zero chance.”

“I don’t want to offend but it’s probable your husband didn’t grow his talent stack over those 30 years and that’s why he was let go and also doesn’t have the skills to compete in the modern era of software engineering. Like I said, not to be cruel, but declaring that Americans on balance should be poorer because your husband made poor career choices doesn’t make you the good guy,” added another.

Regards
I have a mix of views about it.

- First, what will happen to hundreds of education factories in India and Pakistan who are producing graduates at phenomenal rate? Where will these guys go?

- H1-B visa? What about other types of visas ? People will anyway try to reach USA. I don't see any other country having this much of a capacity for foreigners. For example L1 visa.

- In my humble opinion, US market doesn't have that many professionals who can fulfill market demands. How will US market handle this situation?
 
I have a mix of views about it.

- First, what will happen to hundreds of education factories in India and Pakistan who are producing graduates at phenomenal rate? Where will these guys go?

- H1-B visa? What about other types of visas ? People will anyway try to reach USA. I don't see any other country having this much of a capacity for foreigners. For example L1 visa.

- In my humble opinion, US market doesn't have that many professionals who can fulfill market demands. How will US market handle this situation?
I don't understand this philosophy.

Why produce graduates solely for export in the first place?

Create jobs in Pakistan.
 
So if I understand this correctly, existing individuals are exempt?

I don't know about the whole constitutionality of the act aspect but it's essentially targeting the newer arrivals right? So the current setup would remain but future hiring will be scrutinized? Fair enough. It's their country their rules.

India benefited 20-25 years from the whole process. Now it's time to diversify services to our own market and in other markets we have FTAs with. STEM is still the most popular choice among new graduates in India. The buffer zone is short but we have to make do with what we have.

There would still be intake of
high skilled professionals albeit in smaller numbers.

This essentially means that hiring from all nationalities will drop. I wonder how big tech in America and the likes of Elon Musk who heaped praise on H1B will counter this. The current American labour force can hardly accommodate all the demand. American graduates prefer to graduate with abstract degrees like "yoga" and "painting", they'll need to produce STEM graduates at a much higher scale.

America is playing the long game, in short run they know the Indians are running the silicon valley.
In brief, the text of the proclamation covered everyone who was ever going to be outside the country, including those with existing visas. This was widely reported as covering everyone, even though one could technically avoid the fee by never leaving the US.

Since then, US officials have said those who already have visas will be exempt from all aspects of the proclamation.

The remaining aspect of the order will also be challenged in courts and, in my opinion, almost certainly be struck down. I have given legal arguments in prior posts, but the essence is that the President cannot overturn a law passed by Congress and cannot impose taxes, which the fee effectively amounts to.
 
I don't understand this philosophy.

Why produce graduates solely for export in the first place?

Create jobs in Pakistan.
India doesn't have the capacity to absorb all the skilled workforce and Pakistan doesn't have the adequate environment required to take in STEM graduates. That's the reality.

Reverse brain drain is a thing but that needs huge ramp of infrastructure.

It's high time India diversify to manufacturing, the occasional make in India and assembling is not gonna cut it.
 
Completely standard Trumpian protocol. Yet you still don't even see it.

He did the same with tariffs and deportation policy in case you have been snoozing during copenomics class.

He states a wholly ridiculous extreme variant of whatever policy he wishes to deploy, and allows some modifier to redress it slightly to the point where he wanted it to come to rest anyway.

This is straightforward chanakiya and trader/baniya playbook mentality.

Everyone outside of the baniya qom knew exactly where the needle would come to its final equilibrium. Well done for extracting victory from this though. Anil Chauhan pulled off the same trick with his "number downed is irrelevant..." doozy.
Well, I was probably the only one who called it on this thread. Most Pakistanis here were celebrating prematurely. I am happy to know you could see through it.
 
Last edited:
bcffa3c0-9647-11f0-90f2-5f87cb020b24.jpg.webp
India's Minister of External Affairs Subrahmanyam Jaishankar, whose office warned the change would disrupt families

The Indian government has said a new $100,000 (£74,000) fee for applicants seeking US skilled worker visas will have "humanitarian consequences".


He is on his knees. 👏 All the tough talk and big attitude gone out of the window.
 
Last edited:
@fitpOsitive

FP bro,

First, what will happen to hundreds of education factories in India and Pakistan who are producing graduates at phenomenal rate? Where will these guys go?

Let us be clear. Indians and Pakistanis are not entitled to jobs in US or Europe. Their country, their rules. They are free to allow (or not) skilled immigrants from developing countries. The long-term solution as @BrigSmart says is for these countries to develop their own industry and markets.

H1-B visa? What about other types of visas ? People will anyway try to reach USA.

Yes, of course. They will use other visas or even illicit routes to enter US.

US market doesn't have that many professionals who can fulfill market demands. How will US market handle this situation?

Exactly. US doesn't produce enough skilled professionals who can fill up roles thrown up by the market at the rate at which Asian immigrants are willing to work. You shut down the immigration, most of these jobs will migrate to places where these professionals are available.

Regards
 
Scroll back. This was known 48 hours ago.

Any veins left for the next copium shot?
No it was not. Microsoft had issued an advisory just about 24 hrs back.

Not only will we get you kicked out of America but we’re going to get you kicked out of the Gulf too.
WE? Coming too tall from a first generation immigrant trying to create a WE vs YOU.
Only a juvenile can make a claim to posses any power to get people kicked out of anywhere.
It is surprising to see that as a Think Tank you are doing high jumps and making claims of this nature. Could be due to loss of your job to an Indian. Skill up and fight them out rather than trying to ride over claims of ‘kicking them out’.

Try and do better.
 
"Rollback" was neither of these suggested strategems.

On the contrary, it was precisely where Trump wanted the matter to equilibrate.
Well, a large portion of the order he signed with much fanfare is going to effectively be withdrawn. So, it is certainly a rollback technically.

I don't disagree with you that he might never have intended to implement the proclamation that he signed, if that is what you are suggesting in your somewhat cryptic post.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Back
Top