SABRE
Registered Member
IMO, it would be better for India to shift resources and efforts from Tejas to AMCA. Going by the trends it seems unlikely that HAL is going to meet the deadline on Tejas and might end up delaying AMCA as well.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
GE would never deliver 32 engine as even they themselves not committing that. Not even 0.00000001% of chance but Indian can live in delusion.
The 25 years spent developing the Tejas Mk1 laid the foundation for India to develop the Tejas Mk1A in just 3 years and simultaneously work on the Tejas Mk2 and AMCA. The time and money invested in building the aerospace ecosystem will continue to pay off and drive future progress. Kaveri engine also failed to power Tejas, but the knowledge and experience gained from that effort have enabled India to launch a new 110 kN engine program.
If U.S. blocks the sale of fighter jet engines to India, I would welcome it—because it would only accelerate indigenous fighter jet engine development. India today has cryogenic engines, nuclear submarines, ICBMs, hypersonic cruise missiles, and a globally respected space program—all of which were developed after U.S. imposed sanctions following India’s 1974 nuclear tests, restricting access to cryogenic engine, missile, and space technologies.GE would never deliver 32 engines as they themselves aren't even committing to that. There isn't even a 0.00000001% chance, and it's been known for a long time that India could develop Tejas with an alternate engine, but Indians love to live in delusion. For HAL, timelines are among the least important things and consistently relegated to the bottom of their priorities.
If U.S. blocks the sale of fighter jet engines to India, I would welcome it—because it would only accelerate indigenous fighter jet engine development. India today has cryogenic engines, nuclear submarines, ICBMs, hypersonic cruise missiles, and a globally respected space program—all of which were developed after U.S. imposed sanctions following India’s 1974 nuclear tests, restricting access to cryogenic engine, missile, and space technologies.
India is able to upgrade the Su-30MKI with indigenous components largely due to the experience and capabilities developed through the Tejas program. Russian avionics are now being entirely replaced with Indian systems, and many Russian components of the airframe and even parts of the engine are gradually being substituted with Indian-made alternatives.yes, it helped knowledge and experiance for sure. Did it provide a low cost, effective fighters on time and in numbers?
No.
If U.S. blocks the sale of fighter jet engines to India, I would welcome it—because it would only accelerate indigenous fighter jet engine development. India today has cryogenic engines, nuclear submarines, ICBMs, hypersonic cruise missiles, and a globally respected space program—all of which were developed after U.S. imposed sanctions following India’s 1974 nuclear tests, restricting access to cryogenic engine, missile, and space technologies.
Gradually, the Indian Air Force will also become 90% indigenous, much like the Indian Navy. The Indian Army is also already significantly indigenized and operates the world’s second-largest fleet of combat vehicles—second only to the United States—all of which are developed and mass-produced domestically.Dear What you are saying actually contains the right question, which some people have not addressed. As long as those some people remain, nothing will change. Unfortunately for India they are not accountable.





Gradually, the Indian Air Force will also become 90% indigenous, much like the Indian Navy. The Indian Army is also already significantly indigenized and operates the world’s second-largest fleet of combat vehicles—second only to the United States—all of which are developed and mass-produced domestically.
View attachment 131595View attachment 131596View attachment 131598View attachment 131599
View attachment 131601
Gradually, the Indian Air Force will also become 90% indigenous, much like the Indian Navy. The Indian Army is also already significantly indigenized and operates the world’s second-largest fleet of combat vehicles—second only to the United States—all of which are developed and mass-produced domestically.
View attachment 131595View attachment 131596View attachment 131597View attachment 131598View attachment 131599
Gradually, the Indian Air Force will also become 90% indigenous, much like the Indian Navy. The Indian Army is also already significantly indigenized and operates the world’s second-largest fleet of combat vehicles—second only to the United States—all of which are developed and mass-produced domestically.
View attachment 131595View attachment 131596View attachment 131598View attachment 131599
View attachment 131601
IMO, it would be better for India to shift resources and efforts from Tejas to AMCA. Going by the trends it seems unlikely that HAL is going to meet the deadline on Tejas and might end up delaying AMCA as well.
If.... If... If...."If" seems to be the word that had dogged this project for 25 years.
I don't see the point of Tejas anymore
India has enough planes for the moment at least
If AMCA is it's 5th Gen option, then it needs to sink resources into the project to get it made and delivered ASAP
India might need a Su57 purchase to cover some years
India would be better placed if it spent it's finance on upgrading the SU35s and getting more Rafael's
The time for Tejas was 20 years ago, at a minimum india might need the Tejas 2 for numbers but is it worth sinking money into the platform
and indigenization is good when it's not couple with loss of capability and happened in right time.
Honestly speaking anything below AMCA is waste of time and resources for India now as in earlier post Yasir also mentioned that. India adversary is China and Pakistan, not Srilanka, BD and myanmar.
I don't see the point of Tejas anymore
India has enough planes for the moment at least
If AMCA is it's 5th Gen option, then it needs to sink resources into the project to get it made and delivered ASAP
India might need a Su57 purchase to cover some years
India would be better placed if it spent it's finance on upgrading the SU35s and getting more Rafael's
The time for Tejas was 20 years ago, at a minimum india might need the Tejas 2 for numbers but is it worth sinking money into the platform
4th-generation fighters will not be obsolete in the 5th-gen era but will shift from frontline dominance to specialized and support roles, especially when paired with networked capabilities. When upgraded, they still offer excellent capability at lower cost in many strategic scenarios.yup. If it cannot give India what Rafale, SU-57 or AMCA can in terms of capability then simply not worth moving forward with it.
PAF is moving on from BIII to PFX.
Introducing a 4th gen after 2025 is madness.
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.