Indian Navy News & Discussions

Is The AIP part of the 60% indigenous content?
The existing 6 Kalvari-class submarines and the future 3 Scorpene-class submarines will be equipped with NMRL PAFC AIP. The contract for fitting this AIP on our lead Kalvari-class submarine, INS Kalvari, has already been signed between L&T and DRDO.
 
GQztrGSXkAAw_n6
 

This has disaster written all over it.

DRDO designing a totally new AIP with no past experience of SSK subs

Cutting open a foreign sub and installing it

Length and weight increases to a design that has not been validated for it

Either this project will flounder or be subject to very very long delays.

Easier would have been to let France install a AIP and let DRDO develop one and use an old Indian Submarine as a test bed.

France will not accept any liability for this project either
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 

Thought money was not a problem?
 
Deal cost submitted by France is estimated at around Rs 56,000 crores (~USD 6.7 billion) for 26 Rafales (22 Rafale M and 4 Rafale D). This may also include the cost of weapons, but this isn't clear as yet.

GSBeHpHXYAAYwpK


This is higher than anticipated, given that some of the costs of the IAF's order for 36 Rafales were into infrastructure that both the IAF and IN fleets can share (e.g. simulators, spares depots, etc.).

Dassault planning to set up a new MRO on it's own in UP to service IAF, IN and possibly Indonesian Rafales is an indication of which direction the wind is blowing.

How Dassault plans to deliver these within the usual 3 years after contract signature will have to be seen. As of now it's only possible with the set up a separate new assembly line in India. Or with French Navy asked to lease some of it's Rafale Ms till the IN can get it's brand new Rafale Ms.

What amuses me is that there are those on this forum who actually think that the IN will ask for Rafales costing billions of USD and then park them (and service them) on the deck since they can't be fit on the lift in any way. Lol. And then people take him seriously.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 

@vikNerv
I just don't understand why we need this tender, what do these subs bring that scorpene doesnt?
 
I just don't understand why we need this tender, what do these subs bring that scorpene doesnt?
Proven AIP and lithium battery combination, along with a non-magnetic steel hull, on Type 214 submarines.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top