Israel’s Genocide in Gaza | 2023- till present

Status
Not open for further replies.
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Hezbollah attacked Israel in support of Gaza only to give up after a peace agreement with Israel? This does not make sense.
It makes sense when you understand why Hezbollah signed the peace deal in the first place- it's national situation because Israel was bombing all over Lebanon to punish hezbollah for attacking israel to support Gaza had gotten too serious and bad for it. Its just hezbollah's bad luck that it's in a precarious situation domestically at home, which reduces the strategic space and time it needs to wear down Israel (its also giving it the punishments it deserves).
Hezbollah gave up after suffering heavy losses in clashes with IDF
This is false. Hezbollah paused fighting israel because that was the necessary thing it had to go in the complex environment and context and situation it found itself in. Why did Israel sign a peace deal with Hezbollah then if it defeated it already? Hezbollah and israel CONSENTED to the leace deal they signed with each other.
. There was an agreement between Israel and Lebanon proper that led to reduced footprint of both the IDF and Hezbollah in South Lebanon.
Ok
The IDF still have limited presence in South Lebanon and attack Hezbollah elements.
Violating the ceasefire fire...aka cheating.....because Israel can't achieve military goals in Lebanon without first " silencing" Hezbollah.
See this, this, this, and this. Hezbollah is virtually crippled and unable to respond effectively.
That's false again- are you so simple to think hezbollah's silence means it's defeated? It fired strong and har
The Lebanese central state is taking charge of different matters in the country slowly.

Hope Trump ends this

he did get the ceasefire even before getting in to power

he is anti war

he has always been anti war

he was against Iraq war
Is Trump really anti war or just anti wars that democrats started?

He fired missiles into Syria and assassinated Soleimani in Iraq in his 1st term and then entered an intense but short war with Yemen in his current term...he is not anti war!
 
It looks like Hezbollah gave up, but it didnt, and definitely not seriously or massively- Hezbollah choose "temporary peace" with Israel out of a consciousness of all the factors and dynamics at play (especially the domestic Lebanese situation) while it was at war with Israel.
You originally assumed and claimed that Hezbollah has destroyed a lot of IDF infrastructure in northern Israel and Hezbollah will finish off the remainder of IDF in South Lebanon and win the war. Did it? NOT BY A LONG SHOT.

The IDF had infiltrated Hezbollah to the extent that it could blow up Hezbollah devices, creating panic and unexpected losses within Hezbollah ranks. The IDF also discovered hiding spots of Hezbollah's most important men including Hassan Nasrallah and destroyed his underground complex killing him along with others. The IDF had a fairly good idea of WHAT and WHERE to attack across Lebanon and managed to degrade Hezbollah arsenal and warfighting capacity in the process.

Now you claim that Hezbollah has considered "temporary peace" with Israel due to following reasons:

It makes sense when you understand why Hezbollah signed the peace deal in the first place- it's national situation because Israel was bombing all over Lebanon to punish hezbollah for attacking israel to support Gaza had gotten too serious and bad for it. Its just hezbollah's bad luck that it's in a precarious situation domestically at home, which reduces the strategic space and time it needs to wear down Israel (its also giving it the punishments it deserves).

This is false. Hezbollah paused fighting israel because that was the necessary thing it had to go in the complex environment and context and situation it found itself in. Why did Israel sign a peace deal with Hezbollah then if it defeated it already? Hezbollah and israel CONSENTED to the leace deal they signed with each other.
So Hezbollah found out that it is not practical to fight a war with Israel and capitulated? Sounds like defeat to me. Not just me but all neutral observers have come to understand that Hezbollah has lost the war (see this, this, this, this, this, this, this and this).

Do you think that Hezbollah had a highly visible force structure with military bases like a conventional army of a country? No, this is not the case. Hezbollah had a much less visible force structure as much of it was underground in urban areas, villages and hills. The IDF had infilitrated Hezbollah to understand its infrastructure and come up with a plan to degrade Hezbollah's arsenal and warfighting capacity. The IDF also created conditions in Syria that led to collapse of the Assad regime. The Israeli agenda was to deny Hezbollah strategic depth in Syria as Hezbollah could obtain supplies from Iran in Syria.

It looks like Hezbollah gave up, but it didnt, and definitely not seriously or massively- Hezbollah choose "temporary peace" with Israel out of a consciousness of all the factors and dynamics at play (especially the domestic Lebanese situation) while it was at war with Israel.

it does, if you open your mind and not look at this conflict from a simplistic black or white way of looking at things.

hezbollah didnt give up. yes it was a bit damaged, but it was still firing rockets and drones at Israel until the last day before the ceasefire and Israel failed to stop rocket fire by Hezbollah and was only able to do so by ALSO signing the ceasefire.

If Hezbollah gave up, why did Israel ALSO sign the peace treaty with Hezbollah? at worst, both parties realized they wanted to destroy each other but realistically couldn't? You are conveniently ignoring the fact that Israel also willingly signed onto the peace deal with Hezbollah- that confirmed Israel surely didnt have the capacity to destroy Hezbollah (Israel hasnt been able to destroy smaller and less resourcecd that Hezbollah).

Which Israel has been violating...which exposed the Lebanese govt as a US lackey (Jolani's Lebanese democratic/suite wearing variant), which is also cheating, that exposes that Israel cann't disadvantage or achieve goals in south Lebanon when Hezbollah is free to act militarily against it.

Ok

Hezbollah's silence =/= Hezbollah being crippled.
That's a simplistic understanding of what is going on between Lebanon and Israel. Israel did some damage to Hezbollah and hit some of its manpower and military resources, but its too still standing and far from destroyed- its well built out, has a committed and large base for support and to recruit from, has strong long term support from Iran (esp. military tech and hardware) etc.

Taking charge in words and reputation, but not really- Israel has over 2000 violations of Lebanon's sovereighty and territory, and the Lebanonese govt has done little against it. The Lebanese state doesn't have enough respect and reputation in south Lebanon to earn more trust than Hezbollah in the eyes of Lebanese living there.
Ok, the Lebanese govt got more authority- what has it done with it? already conditioned Israel to attack Lebanon more because of lack of action against Israeli attacks against Lebanon. But Hezbollah wont be silent for too long. and if you think Hezbollah is quiet because Israel destroyed it- thats propaganda and Israeli bias, and proves a lack of understanding of the intricacies of this regional conflict in the ME.
Your evaluation is incorrect on many counts. The IDF infiltrated Hezbollah to understand its infrastructure, wipe out Hezbollah's leadership and degrade Hezbollah's arsenal and warfighting capacity. The IDF also shattered Hezbollah's strategic depth in Syria. Many in Lebanon are not willing to support Hezbollah's war. Hezbollah was left with no choice but to capitulate.

Violating the ceasefire fire...aka cheating.....because Israel can't achieve military goals in Lebanon without first " silencing" Hezbollah.
Right. As if Hezbollah is able to do anything about it.

Hezbollah has lost the war and its current leadership is found to be ineffective. Yes, Hezbollah continues to exist as a political entity and have sufficient arms to handle potential threats in Lebanon but its warfighting capacity is massively reduced due to loss of good planners and supply lines as noted above. And IDF is not done with Hezbollah yet, the IDF continues to attack Hezbollah elements inside Lebanon to prevent recovery and regrouping.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.


Loosening Hezbollah’s Grip on Lebanon Begins at the Airport

----

Now let me tell you why Hamas is still in the fight. The IDF knows much less about Hamas and is using an AI system to identify people affiliated with Hamas to kill them. The Skynet model of warfare is terrible and horrible, it has led to mass killings and unprecedented destruction in Gaza. But Hamas has lasted longer and put up a better fight than other bigger forces out there. There is some truth in the claim that "it's not the size of the dog in the fight, it's the size of the fight in the dog." Defeat of Hezbollah shows that the size of arsenal does not guarantee success in war but situational awareness and a solid plan. The IDF has defeated near-peer adversaries in war time-and-again but it has found MORE RESISTANCE in the seemingly isolated and grossly underestimated Gaza. People in Gaza managed to conceal their capacity building and showed greater will to fight than many forces out there much like people in the Terminator. CSIS analysts deserve eggs on their faces. You should read Surah Al-Rum, you will understand then.
 
Last edited:
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.


Jews in panic about Qatar
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Nope. They're trying hard to derail ceasefire efforts and bombed a hospital and all surrounding infrastructure near it. Based off spotty intelligence. They committed a massacre against civilians and targeted yet another hospital directly.

Also trying to shift headlines away from murdering a AP renowned reported getting treatment in a hospital.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
The only solution to stop a genocide is a military one. This was the case in WW2, Bosnia, etc....

There must be a military intervention to degrade Israeli military capabilities to stop the genocide.

There is nothing long term about it. It has to happen NOW.
 
Israeli Jewish Nazi terrorists are carpet bombing hospitals with intent to annihilate everything in Gaza.

Retarded Arabs won't do anything to intervene despite that being the clear intent.

The fake headline about killing a military leader is no more than that. Fake. To try to make it a genocide appear lawful.

This requires a military solution by all the good people and nations in the world.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Latest Posts

Back
Top