JF-17 - Updates, News & Discussion

Let's not bring in USAF or PLAAF and keep it to IAF vs PAF. Anyway, too many variables right now, but if 5th gen is inducted, we definitely won't need this many manned aircraft.

Not bringing any air force into it, pointing out that every air force will have an issue with a minimum critical number, no matter how advanced it's aircraft are. That rule applies to PAF. As to how many unmanned or manned we need I do not pretend to have the answers
 
Nope, that assumption isn't right because you need a certain number of aircraft for a mission. A pair of J-10C can cover more area than 3 four-ship of F-7 PG. And this is without aerial refuelling because PG has less loiter time and not all Mirages have refuelling probe. If you have to escort Army Chief to Iran, that is not possible even with 20 squadrons of 3rd gen fighters.
40 J-10C and 36 J-35 is a good number, supplemented by around 200+ F-16/JF-17. IAF's advantage wasn't numbers in air because they didn't challenge PAF in air on 10th. They could have brought 100 aircraft but they chose to fire Brahmos and SCALP only.
Makkah pact is beyond my comprehension. It looks like it is for optics and nuclear umbrella because Saudis have better aircraft. We have many Mirage/F-7 pilots who didn't get Command of a sqn. Saudis can induct them as fighter pilots, or give me a few billion dollars to buy J-10C that are specifically for their defence. A couple of PAF squadrons can't defend whole Saudi airspace.

That is not the pint he is making. Everyone knows a J-10C can do the job of 2-3 or more F-7PGs, but you need a minimum number. As for Saudi pact, Pakistan's effort is part of an overall effort to help, 1 JF-17C sqd can not do that much, but it shows a strategic commitment
 
That is not the pint he is making. Everyone knows a J-10C can do the job of 2-3 or more F-7PGs, but you need a minimum number. As for Saudi pact, Pakistan's effort is part of an overall effort to help, 1 JF-17C sqd can not do that much, but it shows a strategic commitment
And I mentioned multiple times that 40 J-10C and 36 J-35 is a good number for PAF. And if Saudis want a PAF Sqn, they should pay for the extra aircraft and maybe we can get 80 J-10C instead of 40.
 
And I mentioned multiple times that 40 J-10C and 36 J-35 is a good number for PAF. And if Saudis want a PAF Sqn, they should pay for the extra aircraft and maybe we can get 80 J-10C instead of 40.

So PAF should consist of just 76 planes? It needs a mixed force, high and low. That is my point, and no one can really ascertain (other then a very few in PAF) what that ideal force structure would be.

Saudi commitment has already been made with 16 odd planes in the Kingdom. That train has already left the station.
 
Not bringing any air force into it, pointing out that every air force will have an issue with a minimum critical number, no matter how advanced it's aircraft are. That rule applies to PAF. As to how many unmanned or manned we need I do not pretend to have the answers
Mate, didn't I give a number time and again? I don't know what this Pact is all about, but just talking about IAF, I stand with these numbers. If you need something for Middle East, add that to equation. Only question is who will pay for those extra aircraft.
 
Mate, didn't I give a number time and again? I don't know what this Pact is all about, but just talking about IAF, I stand with these numbers. If you need something for Middle East, add that to equation. Only question is who will pay for those extra aircraft.

Fair enough, but as mentioned we will need more then just a few silver bullets, in my opinion (not worth much granted)
 
So PAF should consist of just 76 planes? It needs a mixed force, high and low. That is my point, and no one can really ascertain (other then a very few in PAF) what that ideal force structure would be.
😅 not just 76 planes bhai... these are numbers for hi-tech... maybe you missed my comment about supplementing these with 200+ F-16/JF-17, so around 300 fighters in total. This is good for next 5-7 years. After that, plan can be tweaked if own 5th gen is available, stealth jet drones or Chinese 6th gen... who knows what technology will be there in mid 2030s.
 
😅 not just 76 planes bhai... these are numbers for hi-tech... maybe you missed my comment about supplementing these with 200+ F-16/JF-17, so around 300 fighters in total. This is good for next 5-7 years. After that, plan can be tweaked if iwn 5th gen is available, stealth jet drones or Chinese 6th gen... who knows what technology will be there in mid 2030s.

Yeah, but I think you are agreeing with me here. If we had 76 backed up by 200 it would be around 280 planes, so around 16 fighter squadrons. Not far off what PAF has now in terms of Sqd numbers. So chances of reducing size of PAF is limited. That was my original point. I do agree that your force structure makes sense, most people would
 
Fair enough, but as mentioned we will need more then just a few silver bullets, in my opinion (not worth much granted)
Just like "Lost in Translation", many things are misunderstood in comments... Right now we have 20 fighter squadrons and they will be reduced to 14 to 16, depending on number in each... on average, we take it to be 18 aircraft in 1 sqn, but it can be slightly more or less than that... so I was talking about number of total aircraft instead of sqn strength... to conclude, 40 J-10C, 36 J-35, 180 JF-17 and 75 F-16s are a good number. But these include ADF F-16s and Blk 1 JF, so frontline fighters will be around 260.
 
Just like "Lost in Translation", many things are misunderstood in comments... Right now we have 20 fighter squadrons and they will be reduced to 14 to 16, depending on number in each... on average, we take it to be 18 aircraft in 1 sqn, but it can be slightly more or less than that... so I was talking about number of total aircraft instead of sqn strength... to conclude, 40 J-10C, 36 J-35, 180 JF-17 and 75 F-16s are a good number. But these include ADF F-16s and Blk 1 JF, so frontline fighters will be around 260.
sir delay of j 10s is that of finacial problem?
 
Just like "Lost in Translation", many things are misunderstood in comments... Right now we have 20 fighter squadrons and they will be reduced to 14 to 16, depending on number in each... on average, we take it to be 18 aircraft in 1 sqn, but it can be slightly more or less than that... so I was talking about number of total aircraft instead of sqn strength... to conclude, 40 J-10C, 36 J-35, 180 JF-17 and 75 F-16s are a good number. But these include ADF F-16s and Blk 1 JF, so frontline fighters will be around 260.

Yeah, this is the bit where it gets messy right? 20-16 sounds like a big decrease but then you have to take into account CCS (3 half Sqds?) and OCUs (4 Sqds?)

Then attrition and we now have to assume (as is the case with payment of not) 1 Sqd in KSA.

So I am actually uncertain how many aircraft we need taking into account all of the above (and attrition!)
 
......, 40 J-10C, 36 J-35, 180 JF-17 and 75 F-16s are a good number. But these include ADF F-16s and Blk 1 JF, so frontline fighters will be around 260.
Could you set a timeline for this vision—that is, by when would you like PAF to achieve this?
 
I hope PFX turns out like the KF-21
I hope and pray it does not. Donr get me wrong as Kf-21 is a good design and may turn out to be a great fighter but its what korea needs and is simply an offspring of f16+, f35 and wanna be f22. Its a great design "now" and had it come in late 2010s or max 2020.
A fighter coming out in 2026 will probably survive 35 to 40 years which means post 2060 at the least. World would have moved to generation 7 or 8 fighters and a 4.5 generation then would be what F7pgs are for us in 2026. Just ok to Gr8 for a very few specific tasks but cant be used for the rest.
PFX wont be out by early to realistically speaking mid 2030s. There is no way we would want a new aircraft in mid 2030 that is like Kf-21.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Back
Top