JF-17 - Updates, News & Discussion

How ever iaf will add 6 rafael and 10 teja mk1/2 squadrons over next 10 years to build up the n7mbers to mid 30s. Paf should build 20 top notch squadron strength with technological edge. Since iran war the threat to pakistan is not only from the east but also from the west and then asymmetrical ops. So paf needs the strength and quality with quantity to maintain the balance.

"10 teja mk1/2 squadrons over next 10 years" Sorry, when you wrote this I stopped taking you seriously
 
Yeah, this is the bit where it gets messy right? 20-16 sounds like a big decrease but then you have to take into account CCS (3 half Sqds?) and OCUs (4 Sqds?)

Then attrition and we now have to assume (as is the case with payment of not) 1 Sqd in KSA.

So I am actually uncertain how many aircraft we need taking into account all of the above (and attrition!)
Again, KSA isn't clear to me because 1 sqn can't defend whole Saudi airspace. For India, I think these numbers will suffice.
 
How ever iaf will add 6 rafael and 10 teja mk1/2 squadrons over next 10 years to build up the n7mbers to mid 30s. Paf should build 20 top notch squadron strength with technological edge. Since iran war the threat to pakistan is not only from the east but also from the west and then asymmetrical ops. So paf needs the strength and quality with quantity to maintain the balance.
Rafale deal isn't signed yet and the only aircraft on order is Tejas. My whole point was India centric and if you add Middle East to PAF's responsibility, more squadrons should be added with help from our allies.
 
Rafale deal isn't signed yet and the only aircraft on order is Tejas. My whole point was India centric and if you add Middle East to PAF's responsibility, more squadrons should be added with help from our allies.
can't agree more .. Pakistan is becoming not only India-centric as it can see threats coming from 3000 km away also
 
I am not an air force person but I strongly believe that in any full blown long duration war, numbers matter a lot, as the war drags on and losses accumulate and capabilities degrade, the technological edge does not last very long, one factor that decides who crumbles first or keeps standing till the end depends on the ability to keep injecting more assets. I am giving a less than nuclear doom's day scenario, not the border skirmishes like the balakot or Sindoor where the objective was just a show off. The only reason Iran survived the joint attack of US and the Israel was its ability to keep firing missiles at them in numbers they enemy did not expect.
 
I hope we achieve it by 2030.
If you were merely an ordinary Pakistani military enthusiast, I would consider this perspective understandable. But you are not.

In our eyes, you are a highly respected professional. Yet, this particular view of yours is clearly unrealistic.

40 J-10CE
36 FC-31/J-35
180 JF-17
75 F-16

This is not a goal that has any possibility of being achieved before 2030.

Ordinary military enthusiasts are free to indulge in all sorts of unrealistic, fanciful speculation. But you are a professional—please show some respect for your own standing.
 
Last edited:
If you were merely an ordinary Pakistani military enthusiast, I would consider this perspective understandable. But you are not.

In our eyes, you are a highly respected professional. Yet, this particular view of yours is clearly unrealistic.

40 J-10CE
36 FC-31/J-35
180 JF-17
75 F-16

This is not a goal that has any possibility of being achieved before 2030.

Ordinary military enthusiasts are free to indulge in all sorts of unrealistic, fanciful speculation. But you are a professional—please show some respect for your own standing.
Let me repeat my answer "I hope we achieve it by 2030" which means that I am hoping that it will be completed in 2030, but may get delayed. Where did I say before 2030? PAF already has 20 J-10C, 75 F-16 and about 160 JF-17. That means 20 more J-10C and JF-17 each in next 4 years. About J-35, nobody is sure what is happening right now but it isn't impossible that PAF can have 36 aircraft in next 4-5 years.
 
Let me repeat my answer "I hope we achieve it by 2030" which means that I am hoping that it will be completed in 2030, but may get delayed. Where did I say before 2030? PAF already has 20 J-10C, 75 F-16 and about 160 JF-17. That means 20 more J-10C and JF-17 each in next 4 years. About J-35, nobody is sure what is happening right now but it isn't impossible that PAF can have 36 aircraft in next 4-5 years.
Alright.

You might want to do some quick math: how much would a total of "20 J-10CEs + 36 FC-31/J-35s" actually cost?

BTW, the 20 J-10CE fighter jets previously purchased by the PAF were acquired through an installment plan—a commitment that the PAF will still be paying off as late as 2030.

How much funding do you think the PAF could realistically scrape together to make this ambition a reality?

I haven’t even mentioned other necessary expenses that are not yet included in these procurement items.
 
Again, KSA isn't clear to me because 1 sqn can't defend whole Saudi airspace. For India, I think these numbers will suffice.

Again, I do not think it is about protecting all of KSA, from my understanding Pak has been given responsibility for one sector, but irrespective of that, force structure has to take this deployment into account (obviously the planes will be called back in event of war)
 
i always over estimate the other side to plan for the worst -- this way we are never undercut

Yeah, MK2 has not flown and MK1A not delivered to IAF, yet they will have 10 Sqds in as many years? That is not "planning for the worst". That is a fantasy even IAF Fanboys on here dont admit can happen
 
Alright.

You might want to do some quick math: how much would a total of "20 J-10CEs + 36 FC-31/J-35s" actually cost?

BTW, the 20 J-10CE fighter jets previously purchased by the PAF were acquired through an installment plan—a commitment that the PAF will still be paying off as late as 2030.

How much funding do you think the PAF could realistically scrape together to make this ambition a reality?

I haven’t even mentioned other necessary expenses that are not yet included in these procurement items.
2032 to be precise and that is not the point here. You would have said the same thing in 2021 because there was no money for the 20 J-10C that are already in PAF service. So let's leave that to the government how they are going to pay for it. The context of discussion was the required number of aircraft in PAF.
 
Again, I do not think it is about protecting all of KSA, from my understanding Pak has been given responsibility for one sector, but irrespective of that, force structure has to take this deployment into account (obviously the planes will be called back in event of war)
What can a JF-17 Block 2 protect that a Saudi F-15 with AESA and AMRAAM can't?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Back
Top