Opinion Piece- Beyond Partition: Imagining an India-Pakistan Friendship

We having nothing to do with India. In Fact Pakistanis hate or don't care about India.

Please India leave us Pakistanis alone, we want nothing to do with your kind.
Talking about peace between India and Pakistan in the Indian context is about political opportunism, such rhetoric is used to fuel Hindu-Muslim divisions within India and garner votes.

Making generic statements such as “there should be peace between India and Pakistan” is an oversimplification, much like saying there should be peace between Israel and Palestine. Such statements gloss over the historical, political and ideological realities underlying these conflicts.

And no, Kashmir is not the fundamental issue. The deeper issue is ideological. India is a Hindu-majority secular state, whereas Pakistan is a Muslim Islamic state. The underlying tensions are rooted in fundamentally different national identities and political ideologies. This conflict would persist even if the Kashmir dispute did not exist.

As for the supposed economic benefits of improved trade relations, India has far more significant economic opportunities elsewhere. China, its largest neighbour in terms of both population and economic size, represents a vastly larger economic relationship. Bangladesh also has a larger economy than Pakistan, as do several Southeast Asian countries, including Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore. Sri Lanka, too, offers opportunities for stronger economic engagement.

India has far more to gain by strengthening economic and strategic ties with these countries. Given the persistent political and ideological obstacles, improving relations with Pakistan is not practical proposition.
 
Talking about peace between India and Pakistan in the Indian context is about political opportunism, such rhetoric is used to fuel Hindu-Muslim divisions within India and garner votes.

Making generic statements such as “there should be peace between India and Pakistan” is an oversimplification, much like saying there should be peace between Israel and Palestine. Such statements gloss over the historical, political and ideological realities underlying these conflicts.

And no, Kashmir is not the fundamental issue. The deeper issue is ideological. India is a Hindu-majority secular state, whereas Pakistan is a Muslim Islamic state. The underlying tensions are rooted in fundamentally different national identities and political ideologies. This conflict would persist even if the Kashmir dispute did not exist.

As for the supposed economic benefits of improved trade relations, India has far more significant economic opportunities elsewhere. China, its largest neighbour in terms of both population and economic size, represents a vastly larger economic relationship. Bangladesh also has a larger economy than Pakistan, as do several Southeast Asian countries, including Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia and Singapore. Sri Lanka, too, offers opportunities for stronger economic engagement.

India has far more to gain by strengthening economic and strategic ties with these countries. Given the persistent political and ideological obstacles, improving relations with Pakistan is not practical proposition.
this guy 👆 doesn't practice chankaya doctrine, I appreciate the pragmatism.
 
this guy 👆 doesn't practice chankaya doctrine, I appreciate the pragmatism.
Still, his positioning is not accurate. The conclusion, sure, but he has based his conclusion on several carts of horse manure.

This is the way they function. Nothing new I suppose.
 
I'm sorry but I don't think living side by side like France or Germany is going to occur. Too much has happened between the two nations and given the social, religious, cultural contrast with geo-political aims, this is not feasible.
Ironic enough, on my X feeds, I see nothing but Indians now singing Kumbaya and writing excessively how Pakistan can prosper if they made peace with India and provide access to Central Asia and the Middle East.

I'm sure @Krptonite means well, but this is a pipe-dream. In order for this to occur, Pakistan would have to give up Islam in its entirety core level to placate India because having that many "Muslims" around is dangerous for Indians.
The ultra elite/liberals in Pakistan desire the same thing, rapprochement between the two nations and watering down Islamic values in order to placate the Indians.
 
The Indians literally are vocal about Pakistan loosening its Islamic character in order to have peace in the South Asia. I feel Pakistan can become way more aggressive in this clash of civilization instead of lazily turning the other cheek. The Non-Muslims have billion dollar media and social machines churning anti-Islamic content day in and day out. Why would they do this if they didn't have any problems with Muslims or Islam?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Latest Posts

Back
Top