Opinion Piece- Beyond Partition: Imagining an India-Pakistan Friendship

We are neighbours. We aren't going to stop being neighbours, regardless of who occupies the Red Fort or Islamabad's corridors of power.
Sure but nobody said we should be friends.
And if our relationship is to be permanently defined by the assumption that the other is an adversary, what exactly are we hoping to achieve by perpetuating that relationship?

I'm not suggesting either country abandon its interests, overlook historical grievances or extend unconditional trust.

I'm simply exploring whether we can begin to build a functional relationship without first resolving every disagreement that has brought us to this point.
How exactly do you build trust with a state where the civilian government does not even control the military establishment, and where that establishment has historically treated hostility towards India as a strategic necessity?
I'm not arguing that dialogue should never happen. I'm arguing that dialogue without accountability, reciprocity and verifiable changes in behaviour is simply wishful thinking. Dialogue is a default state so far dialogue in the last 80 years produced no tangible results. So why should this time be any different?
 
Sure but nobody said we should be friends.

How exactly do you build trust with a state where the civilian government does not even control the military establishment, and where that establishment has historically treated hostility towards India as a strategic necessity?
I'm not arguing that dialogue should never happen. I'm arguing that dialogue without accountability, reciprocity and verifiable changes in behaviour is simply wishful thinking. Dialogue is a default state so far dialogue in the last 80 years produced no tangible results. So why should this time be any different?
Coming from a nation where a Muslim gets lynched by a doctor whilst offering to donate blood - you have to right to pollute a thread like this. Shoo off back under the rock
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top