Opinion Piece- Beyond Partition: Imagining an India-Pakistan Friendship

This is a very interesting topic which has begun. I normally just read pdf without logging in but took the pain to reset my password and login in after a long time as I wanted to add my 2 pieces.

My take is that there is a lot of distrust on both sides for reasons everyone is aware. No one is imagining that we will be friends any time soon. No one is asking to forgive or forget. However, we can be intelligent enough to not harm ourselves in our hatred of the other.

Look at China & Japan. They were bitter enemies before and during WW2. China suffered immensely under Japanese colonialism so to say. And I dont think Japan has ever apologized for what it did. China still has several issues with Japan and they both sit on opposite geopolitical camps. But they are smart enough to have healthy trading relationship. Why to import from thousands of miles away and pay extra transport fees when you can find something next door.

I am sure you can google and find numerous such examples around the globe. I will stop here and let people thrash me on this before I speak further.

Pakistanis do not have necessary civilisational experience to be two faced haters. A Pakistanis love has bounds but Pakistani hatred is raw and primal. The Sufis will not rule Pakistan forever, their days are numbered.
 
Pakistanis do not have necessary civilisational experience to be two faced haters. A Pakistanis love has bounds but Pakistani hatred is raw and primal. The Sufis will not rule Pakistan forever, their days are numbered.
sure, please feel to hate India but surely you love your country more than you hate India. For Pakistan to prosper and for India to prosper more, we both need a better trade relationship. Even Vietnam which had millions killed by US had the sense to form normal diplomatic ties with US and do trade.
Apne pair pe kulhaadi maarne mein kaunsi hoshiyaari hai yaar. Fight, yell but trade is what I think. I read somewhere that the Chinese govt even advised Pakistan in the 90s to put border issues with India on the backburner for a decade and focus on economy. I think thats a very sound advice and its coming from a country that has actually done it in practice so khaali bol-bachhan nahin hai. They have kept their heads down and progressed enough that even though India and China are rivals, we appreciate Chinese economic progress and pragmatism.
 
sure, please feel to hate India but surely you love your country more than you hate India. For Pakistan to prosper and for India to prosper more, we both need a better trade relationship. Even Vietnam which had millions killed by US had the sense to form normal diplomatic ties with US and do trade.
Apne pair pe kulhaadi maarne mein kaunsi hoshiyaari hai yaar. Fight, yell but trade is what I think. I read somewhere that the Chinese govt even advised Pakistan in the 90s to put border issues with India on the backburner for a decade and focus on economy. I think thats a very sound advice and its coming from a country that has actually done it in practice so khaali bol-bachhan nahin hai. They have kept their heads down and progressed enough that even though India and China are rivals, we appreciate Chinese economic progress and pragmatism.

Why are you asking Pakistanis to be someone else than what they are? That's a bit condescending.

All change starts from oneself, I am most likely to survive in Pakistan if I advocate for peace with India in some public setting. When and if you have survived your ordeal in India, come to wagah border, I will sling a laced rasgulla towards you.
 
Why are you asking Pakistanis to be someone else than what they are? That's a bit condescending.

All change starts from oneself, I am most likely to survive in Pakistan if I advocate for peace with India in some public setting. When and if you have survived your ordeal in India, come to wagah border, I will sling a laced rasgulla towards you.
Please read again. I am not advocating peace because I understand we are not there yet. I am only advocating for open trade. Ghaas khaake bomb bana liya par ab ghaas hi khaate rehna hai kya?
 
Please read again. I am not advocating peace because I understand we are not there yet. I am only advocating for open trade. Ghaas khaake bomb bana liya par ab ghaas hi khaate rehna hai kya?
I would definitely rather eat grass that read any more of your drivel.
 
sure, please feel to hate India but surely you love your country more than you hate India. For Pakistan to prosper and for India to prosper more, we both need a better trade relationship. Even Vietnam which had millions killed by US had the sense to form normal diplomatic ties with US and do trade.
Apne pair pe kulhaadi maarne mein kaunsi hoshiyaari hai yaar. Fight, yell but trade is what I think. I read somewhere that the Chinese govt even advised Pakistan in the 90s to put border issues with India on the backburner for a decade and focus on economy. I think thats a very sound advice and its coming from a country that has actually done it in practice so khaali bol-bachhan nahin hai. They have kept their heads down and progressed enough that even though India and China are rivals, we appreciate Chinese economic progress and pragmatism.
Let me translate Chanayka for everyone, please open your borders and markets so we can use our overwhelming financial muscle to influence Pakistan and bring it under our hegemonic like we did to Nepal, Bangladesh, and Sikkim.

Giving financial lever to the Indians will economically bring Pakistan unwittingly into Indians economic hegemony. I didn't even bring up the open routes and air space that will come along with these benefits.
 
Let me translate Chanayka for everyone, please open your borders and markets so we can use our overwhelming financial muscle to influence Pakistan and bring it under our hegemonic like we did to Nepal, Bangladesh, and Sikkim.

Giving financial lever to the Indians will economically bring Pakistan unwittingly into Indians economic hegemony. I didn't even bring up the open routes and air space that will come along with these benefits.
Has Bangladesh really come under Indian hegemonic rule? When they felt that their leader was too friendly with India, did they not replace her? However, did the open trade not benefit BD. Their per capita income is neck-to-neck with India now and 60% higher than Pakistan.

Is Mexico under US hegemonic rule just because they have strong trade ties? Mexico lost Texas and California to US, so they should ideally be staunch enemies but they are not.

China keeps publicly proclaiming Taiwan and actively blocks its participation on international forums and yet Taiwan does not hesitate to trade with China.

Saari duniya bevakoof hai, aur sirf aap hi ke paas dimaag hai?
 
Last edited:
I've grown rather concerned that people have stopped calling me racist slurs around here. So, in an attempt to rectify this unfortunate development, expand my vocabulary of creative swear words, and generally demonstrate just how tone-deaf I can be, I'd like to propose a thought experiment: what might the normalisation of relations between India and Pakistan eventually look like, why do I believe it is a possibility rather than an impossibility, and what could the two countries potentially achieve through such a relationship?

I'd like to explore this through four questions:

1. Why do I believe normalisation is eventually possible?

My starting point is that hostility between nations, however deeply entrenched, is rarely a permanent condition. Geography doesn't change, generations change, economic priorities evolve and national interests are recalibrated. What seems politically inconceivable today may become a pragmatic necessity tomorrow. What historical, economic or generational developments could eventually make this possible?

2. What would the economic relationship between the two countries look like?

India and Pakistan have developed largely separate economic ecosystems despite their geographic proximity and shared commercial heritage. What happens when Indian capital, technology, manufacturing scale and consumer markets interact with Pakistani industrial capacity, agricultural potential, workforce and geographic position? Could both countries unlock opportunities that neither can fully realise independently?

3. What happens to the strategic equation of the subcontinent?

Imagine India no longer viewing Pakistan primarily through a security lens, and Pakistan no longer organising a significant part of its national strategy around counterbalancing India. What happens to defence expenditure, regional connectivity, access to Central Asia, relations with China and the Gulf, and the geopolitical standing of South Asia?

4. What would our children's generation inherit?

This is perhaps the most interesting question to me. Would Indians and Pakistanis eventually be able to travel freely, conduct business, study and maintain personal relationships across the border? Could two distinct national identities coexist with a recognition of shared history and cultural heritage? What might the subcontinent look like after 30 years of peaceful competition rather than perpetual hostility?

This is, of course, just a thought experiment, and I'm under no illusion that everyone will share the premise. By all means, poke holes in it, challenge the assumptions, disagree with the arguments or bash the entire proposition to smithereens.
Bro,

10/10 for trying...

 
Let me translate Chanayka for everyone, please open your borders and markets so we can use our overwhelming financial muscle to influence Pakistan and bring it under our hegemonic like we did to Nepal, Bangladesh, and Sikkim.

Giving financial lever to the Indians will economically bring Pakistan unwittingly into Indians economic hegemony. I didn't even bring up the open routes and air space that will come along with these benefits.
India - China are rivals but we trade massively with each other despite the balance of trade being much in China's favor. Have we come under Chinese hegemonic control?
 
India - China are rivals but we trade massively with each other despite the balance of trade being much in China's favor. Have we come under Chinese hegemonic control?
Hello,

Please can you update your flags on your profile in line with forum policy.

 
Please read again. I am not advocating peace because I understand we are not there yet. I am only advocating for open trade. Ghaas khaake bomb bana liya par ab ghaas hi khaate rehna hai kya?

We don't trade with terrorists.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Back
Top