Pakistan-China Deal for 700 Advanced VT-4B Tanks: A Major Challenge for India

700? so many? Has the Al Khalid 2 project encountered difficulties? Or is VT-4B just a supplement to a special anti drone tank?
I think that's pretty much over for Al Khalid 2. Now the main focus is on Haidar (i.e. locally produced VT-4) MBT.
 
End of the day infantry and tanks take and hold ground. Very literally.

Russia had 10,000 tanks before war. Ukraine had probably 1000. With massive infantry, and tanks, superior air power Russia should had swallowed Ukraine years ago when war started.

Ukrainian drones have kept Ukraine alive. Their FPV drones have literally became nightmare of Russian infantry, they chased every single soldiers into even the ditches. They chased their vehicles, and all.

Warfare has evolved. I am not saying we don't need Tanks. We definitely need but they shouldn't be focus anymore. The real focus is on autonomous & smart munitions, killer drones, LMs.

Today you don't need tanks anymore to confront tanks. Imagine a mobile vehicle launches dozens of anti-armor munitions in an instant and a quad copter drone identifies all incoming enemy tanks and guides all the munitions towards their targets. All of your armor will be disabled.

Shoot-on-the-move-drone-container-truck.webp

Bottomline is Tanks are still relevant but it has become hugely vulnerable in modern warfare. In pre-drones era, you had traditional legacy irreplaceable weapons. But warfare always evolves. Battleships were once critical for war at seas. Now they are obsolete. Horse mounted cavalry seems to be irreplaceable once in ancient era. Tanks are not something that will stick for too long. In foreseeable future, unmanned killer vehicles will be able to hunt and pulverize traditional tanks at lightening speeds.
 
Russia had 10,000 tanks before war. Ukraine had probably 1000. With massive infantry, and tanks, superior air power Russia should had swallowed Ukraine years ago when war started.

Ukrainian drones have kept Ukraine alive. Their FPV drones have literally became nightmare of Russian infantry, they chased every single soldiers into even the ditches. They chased their vehicles, and all.

Warfare has evolved. I am not saying we don't need Tanks. We definitely need but they shouldn't be focus anymore. The real focus is on autonomous & smart munitions, killer drones, LMs.

Today you don't need tanks anymore to confront tanks. Imagine a mobile vehicle launches dozens of anti-armor munitions in an instant and a quad copter drone identifies all incoming enemy tanks and guides all the munitions towards their targets. All of your armor will be disabled.

View attachment 223328

Bottomline is Tanks are still relevant but it has become hugely vulnerable in modern warfare. In pre-drones era, you had traditional legacy irreplaceable weapons. But warfare always evolves. Battleships were once critical for war at seas. Now they are obsolete. Horse mounted cavalry seems to be irreplaceable once in ancient era. Tanks are not something that will stick for too long. In foreseeable future, unmanned killer vehicles will be able to hunt and pulverize traditional tanks at lightening speeds.

For sure, the days of WW2 and 1965 where a tank would literally mean you are screwed are long gone. Light anti-tank weapons helicopters, drones etc have ensure the playing field is leveled, but when your forces survive and finally reach that enemy hill or village you wont send just light infantry to go uo against them, you will also send a tank
 
Russia had 10,000 tanks before war. Ukraine had probably 1000. With massive infantry, and tanks, superior air power Russia should had swallowed Ukraine years ago when war started.

Ukrainian drones have kept Ukraine alive. Their FPV drones have literally became nightmare of Russian infantry, they chased every single soldiers into even the ditches. They chased their vehicles, and all.

Warfare has evolved. I am not saying we don't need Tanks. We definitely need but they shouldn't be focus anymore. The real focus is on autonomous & smart munitions, killer drones, LMs.

Today you don't need tanks anymore to confront tanks. Imagine a mobile vehicle launches dozens of anti-armor munitions in an instant and a quad copter drone identifies all incoming enemy tanks and guides all the munitions towards their targets. All of your armor will be disabled.

View attachment 223328

Bottomline is Tanks are still relevant but it has become hugely vulnerable in modern warfare. In pre-drones era, you had traditional legacy irreplaceable weapons. But warfare always evolves. Battleships were once critical for war at seas. Now they are obsolete. Horse mounted cavalry seems to be irreplaceable once in ancient era. Tanks are not something that will stick for too long. In foreseeable future, unmanned killer vehicles will be able to hunt and pulverize traditional tanks at lightening speeds.

I wouldn't take the poor operational tactics and deployment of tanks by Russia as a guide to the demise of the tank. The Russians have FUBAR'ed every part of the deployment of their tactics, people and equipment in the Ukrainian/Russia war. Truly shocking levels of incompetence across all their services..

The value of the tank has decreased, but not to the point where we can question its value on the modern battlefield yet.
 
Pakistan doesn't need more tanks

Real question is how can we protect our Al Khalid, VT-4 and some outdated tanks from massive drone attacks?


The russian tanks are highly sensible to chain reaction. This one may have hit a land mine.
At least the team lost its life without suffering. RIP.
 
Pakistan doesn't need more tanks

Real question is how can we protect our Al Khalid, VT-4 and some outdated tanks from massive drone attacks?


Post # 647



Post # 661

 
Russia had 10,000 tanks before war. Ukraine had probably 1000. With massive infantry, and tanks, superior air power Russia should had swallowed Ukraine years ago when war started.

Ukrainian drones have kept Ukraine alive. Their FPV drones have literally became nightmare of Russian infantry, they chased every single soldiers into even the ditches. They chased their vehicles, and all.

Warfare has evolved. I am not saying we don't need Tanks. We definitely need but they shouldn't be focus anymore. The real focus is on autonomous & smart munitions, killer drones, LMs.

Today you don't need tanks anymore to confront tanks. Imagine a mobile vehicle launches dozens of anti-armor munitions in an instant and a quad copter drone identifies all incoming enemy tanks and guides all the munitions towards their targets. All of your armor will be disabled.

View attachment 223328

Bottomline is Tanks are still relevant but it has become hugely vulnerable in modern warfare. In pre-drones era, you had traditional legacy irreplaceable weapons. But warfare always evolves. Battleships were once critical for war at seas. Now they are obsolete. Horse mounted cavalry seems to be irreplaceable once in ancient era. Tanks are not something that will stick for too long. In foreseeable future, unmanned killer vehicles will be able to hunt and pulverize traditional tanks at lightening speeds.
The other side of the coin,


"A Ukrainian Leopard tank took 45 hits from FPV drones during Operation Vivaldi and is still operational,"

“During the same operation our forces used 52 FPV for a couple of hours against Russian T-62M obr. 2022 and it didn’t burn,”

"Drone videos of tanks being hit are some of the most common footage from the war in Ukraine, and they have left many viewers with the impression that heavy armor is helpless against cheap drones. Units mostly post the strikes that end in an explosion or a burning hull. The failed attacks, and the hits a tank survives, rarely make it online."





Oh and FYI russia HAS swallowed mass swathes of ukraine, and ukraine isn't alone, it is backed by entire western world and their considerable resources.
 
Last edited:
Post # 647



Post # 661


Got it - thank you Signalian!
 
Pakistan doesn't need more tanks

Real question is how can we protect our Al Khalid, VT-4 and some outdated tanks from massive drone attacks?


Cage armour and APS. I wonder if an automatic shotgun can be added for countering drones. APS would be for atgms, automatic shotgun for drones, cage armour for last line of defence.
 
While the video is fake news, it is worthwhile for Pakistan to consider modifying their existing VT4 contract and upgrade them to VT4B standard.

The main reason is that VT4B is maximally designed to handle FPV threat, VT4 itself was designed before the Russo-Ukraine war and we all know how obsolete they are in the modern drone infested battlefield (as obsolete as T-90M, M1A2, Leopard 2A7...etc).

VT4B has AESA radar, APS and RWS. Note that both APS and RWS are designed to engage FPV, RWS deal with drones at a few hundred meters range and APS handles drones that got through the RWS. Such a setup is best equipped to handle saturated drone attack.

We can see the T-90M equipped with APS is already much more survivable in Ukraine, tanking many dozens of FPV attacks before their APS run out of ammo. Integrated RWS will massively improve their odds against sustained drone attack.

Anyhow, protecting the vehicles against drones is only one aspect of the solution, another aspect is to kill the enemy drone team before they kill your tanks, this is a much more complex matter. If people are interested in this matter they should pay attention to the Zhuhai airshow this December, there are a whole range of export ready solutions going to be displayed there.
 
While the video is fake news, it is worthwhile for Pakistan to consider modifying their existing VT4 contract and upgrade them to VT4B standard.

The main reason is that VT4B is maximally designed to handle FPV threat, VT4 itself was designed before the Russo-Ukraine war and we all know how obsolete they are in the modern drone infested battlefield (as obsolete as T-90M, M1A2, Leopard 2A7...etc).

VT4B has AESA radar, APS and RWS. Note that both APS and RWS are designed to engage FPV, RWS deal with drones at a few hundred meters range and APS handles drones that got through the RWS. Such a setup is best equipped to handle saturated drone attack.

We can see the T-90M equipped with APS is already much more survivable in Ukraine, tanking many dozens of FPV attacks before their APS run out of ammo. Integrated RWS will massively improve their odds against sustained drone attack.

Anyhow, protecting the vehicles against drones is only one aspect of the solution, another aspect is to kill the enemy drone team before they kill your tanks, this is a much more complex matter. If people are interested in this matter they should pay attention to the Zhuhai airshow this December, there are a whole range of export ready solutions going to be displayed there.
While I agree that upgrade to B standard will be beneficial but MBTs are not supposed to operate alone.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top