Pakistan-China Deal for 700 Advanced VT-4B Tanks: A Major Challenge for India

Easy:

In defence operations @Signalian is absolutely right that ist very difficult to separate Pakistani infantry from armoured formations/sections because infantry can retreated, regroup in very well prepared defence rooms.

Defence rooms: Bunkers - trenches - urban areas- civilian buildings- firing positions - fox holes- under earth tunnels with firing doors windows - under earth trenches - traps for enemy - Tank holes in earth - Tank bunkers……the list is too long all which are not visible for Indians during peacetime.

In Offense there is no protection when infantry section are running near behind and God forbid in front of Tanks. Our current M-113 is the weakest point - it does not offer any protection against artillery shrapnel’s and Drone attack in his current configuration -

Infantry has limits to fight from within the vehicle and give fire support because the board gun hat not a protected turret.

Configuration of current M-113 must be changed- add better protection - add more fire power - add passive protection.

Explain me how M-113 will operate in current modern drone age scenario against Indian modern warfare. Pakistani armoured personell carrier are configured only as battle taxi for 1970-1980s era. Time has changed. Pakistan has great industry capacity to do better.
This pic makes it clearer.

1795127073924.png
 
Why not MRAPs for PA instead of tracked IFVs
Well for one, better cross country capability...
A true MRAP would be way bulkier I don't think it would work well in many conditions.
A lighter MRAP could be used as battle taxies like the DongFeng.. They also have a smaller silhouette and will provide baseline armor protection similar to the M113s...
( & i think there are versions that could replace the Hiluxes as well )
A few Maxxpros and Hamza 6x6 or 8x8s for LCBs and SSG are ok, but not suitable for Offensive Mechanized operations with large Armor columns...

Likelihood of us replacing all those APCs is bleak... Having some kind of upgradation program for the current one's and some IFV derived from them is likely possible... Expecting a whole fleet of MRAPs replacing them or tracked IFVs.. IMPOSSIBLE.
 
Well for one, better cross country capability...
A true MRAP would be way bulkier I don't think it would work well in many conditions.
A lighter MRAP could be used as battle taxies like the DongFeng.. They also have a smaller silhouette and will provide baseline armor protection similar to the M113s...
( & i think there are versions that could replace the Hiluxes as well )
A few Maxxpros and Hamza 6x6 or 8x8s for LCBs and SSG are ok, but not suitable for Offensive Mechanized operations with large Armor columns...

Likelihood of us replacing all those APCs is bleak... Having some kind of upgradation program for the current one's and some IFV derived from them is likely possible... Expecting a whole fleet of MRAPs replacing them or tracked IFVs.. IMPOSSIBLE.
Moreover the logistical and Maintenance nightmare that are tires !!
Who's going to ensure proper storage procedures for such a large fleet ? ( I remember the Russians suffering in start of the war due to the exact same problem )
&
Who's going to make them ?
Especially considering PA is buying a lot of off the shelf stuff these days in small numbers... Maybe dipping toes before a final large order or ( quite likely ) trying to throw money at the problem at hand....
PA has had logistical issues through out it's history and let's try not make another.
 
Well for one, better cross country capability...
A true MRAP would be way bulkier I don't think it would work well in many conditions.
A lighter MRAP could be used as battle taxies like the DongFeng.. They also have a smaller silhouette and will provide baseline armor protection similar to the M113s...
( & i think there are versions that could replace the Hiluxes as well )
A few Maxxpros and Hamza 6x6 or 8x8s for LCBs and SSG are ok, but not suitable for Offensive Mechanized operations with large Armor columns...

Likelihood of us replacing all those APCs is bleak... Having some kind of upgradation program for the current one's and some IFV derived from them is likely possible... Expecting a whole fleet of MRAPs replacing them or tracked IFVs.. IMPOSSIBLE.
Go step by step.

MRAPS offer the following:

1. Mines and IED Survivability which m-113 doesn't have.
2. High-Speed Road Mobility, not requiring truck-trailers that haul M-113 or MBT on road.
3. Lower Maintenance Vs. Tracked vehicles which require frequent track-pad replacements, tension adjustments, and heavy ARVs.
4. Cheaper to operate.
5. Urban Operations. Especially against ambushes when a town is captured.

Issues:
1. Poor Cross-Country Mobility.
2. High Silhouette makes easy targets for enemy if deployed as IFV.

Now take a look at modern armies and their APCs (such as M-113) deployment as well as wheeled armored/well protected infantry mobility vehicles. Not discussing IFVs yet.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top