Rational Philosopher
Trusted Member
What does the ideal Pakistani Navy look like for full spectrum defence and blockading Indian oil supplies?
Like how many of each asset too
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
What does the ideal Pakistani Navy look like for full spectrum defence and blockading Indian oil supplies?
Get 2 destroyers for Air defence, build Ukraine style sea drones some with AA missiles strapped to them for forward ops keep your ships always under aircraft cover use sea drones for attacking shipping lines once we get 8 hangor and 3 90bs we have use 90bs to secure coast whole hangors hunt isolated ships buy 3 Type41 mini nuclear submarine with stealth cruise missiles for second strike and submarine hunting. This is very hard to defeatWhat does the ideal Pakistani Navy look like for full spectrum defence and blockading Indian oil supplies?
Like how many of each asset too

I would politely disagree with such assessment.Get 2 destroyers for Air defence, build Ukraine style sea drones some with AA missiles strapped to them for forward ops keep your ships always under aircraft cover use sea drones for attacking shipping lines once we get 8 hangor and 3 90bs we have use 90bs to secure coast whole hangors hunt isolated ships buy 3 Type41 mini nuclear submarine with stealth cruise missiles for second strike and submarine hunting. This is very hard to defeat
PN Submarine fleet is it's "cutting edge " the 8-boat Chinese order for S-20 (039) needs to be excellerated.I would politely disagree with such assessment.
What modern destroyers (think burke or type 052DE) offers over what Pakistan already got is long range air defence capability. Compared to area air defence, the main difference is that long range air defence is primarily focused on deterring aerial launch platforms carrying stand-off munitions, while area air defence is focused on providing interception against incoming munitions at intermediate ranges.
The modern Indian standoff munition family is entirely reliant upon the Kh-61 platform, which, while their air-breathing nature makes them inevitably easier to intercept as they need to cruise at substantial altitude to achieve any sort of respectable range, does mean their launch platforms (Su-30MKI for example) can remain relatively safe outside typical long range air defence bubbles, which means the tactical values offered by purchasing destroyers are very limited given the circumstances of the Pakistani Navy.
The Ukrainian drone boat with AAMs is only suitable for the specific circumstance of the littoral waters of the black sea I would say. AAMs like R-73s repurposed to launch from the surface don't really offer any meaningful range after the initial surprise, and I would imagine the drone boat's limited seaworthiness would greatly limited their usefulness in the Indian ocean except for some sort of littoral resistance.
I do agree with your assessment in procuring submarines though. Indian armed forces so far does not possess substantial capabilities to hunt submarines, notably very limited in modern maritime patrol aircraft and effective surface ASW combatants. All the while Pakistan's largest defence collaborators, both China and Turkey, have all achieved recent breakthroughs and have cost-effect solutions that could be offered.
Convocation of 54th PN Staff Course was held at PNWC, Lhr. CNS Adm Naveed Ashraf graced the event as CG. Degrees were conferred upon 118 graduates, incl 74 officers from PN, Pak Army, PAF & 44 officers from friendly countries. Naval Chief congratulated the graduating officers.
CNS highlighted imp of understanding modern warfare &maritime threats & emphasized transformation in warfare marked by asymmetrical conflicts &growing influence of non-state actors & stressed need for traditional military strategies to evolve in response to complex challenges.
CNS noted that IOR remains fluid & contested, with new geopolitical realignments & ongoing power rivalries impacting regional security environment. Referring to recent 4-day crisis b/w India-Pak, he remarked that it stands as testimony to the changing nature of warfare.
www.radio.gov.pk
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.