Pakistan, the IVC, and a Land of continuous migration and mixing

[AjayGhatak]

Indus civilisation is part and parcel of Pakistan.

If you say so~

 

[vasanthm]

You do whatever you want to do.

Remember this Indus priest king belongs to Pakistan.

View attachment 96196

lol ok, I have promised Joe Shearer to rein in my sarcasm, I hope to follow that at least for the day. enjoy your day

 

[Joe Shearer]

I appreciate your feedback and thoughtful critique. I’ll definitely try to rein in my combative and sarcastic tendencies moving forward. It’s just that when I encounter unreasonable, silly arguments and name calling, sarcasm often feels like such an easy shortcut to counter them.

lol ok, I have promised Joe Shearer to rein in my sarcasm, I hope to follow that at least for the day. enjoy your day

Don't.
Replying to a handful of these posters is a total waste of time.

 

[Dalit]

lol ok, I have promised Joe Shearer to rein in my sarcasm, I hope to follow that at least for the day. enjoy your day

Good advice from Shearerjee.

 

[Dalit]

If you say so~

The Indus Valley Civilization, also known as the Harappan Civilization, has a significant historical connection to modern-day Pakistan. After the partition of India in 1947, many of the excavated sites of the Indus Valley Civilization, such as Harappa and Mohenjo-Daro, fell within the territory of Pakistan. This has made Pakistan a key region for archaeological research and understanding the ancient civilization.

The Indus Valley Civilization is one of the world's earliest urban cultures, known for its advanced city planning, architecture, and social organization. The archaeological discoveries in Pakistan have provided valuable insights into the life, culture, and technological achievements of this ancient civilization.

Pakistan is literally the epicenter of Indus civilization.

 

[Farhan23]

Once you are read up on the history of the speakers of Proto-Indo-European and their locations and subsequent movements, you might even contribute meaningfully to this thread.

My brother you will eventually come to terms with the truth. It is as clear as daylight to see

 

[Joe Shearer]

My brother you will eventually come to terms with the truth. It is as clear as daylight to see

Not to a graduate in History, who has kept up his study of the past with assiduity.

 

[Circadian Rhythm]

Pakistan is literally the epicenter of Indus civilization.

Islamic Republic of Pakistan is only the Geographical Epicenter of IVC

IVC was culturally ,.The precursor and predecessor of Indian Vedic and Hindu Civilizational Identity

Those areas where IVC existed, the towns and cities might have been abandoned

But the People Migrated Eastwards and intermingled with Aryans and other Indian communities ie spread all over the Subcontinent

 

[Circadian Rhythm]

Civilizations are not just Archeological Constructs

They are also Cultural Entities

Culture and Religion.are Two Sides of the Same Coin

IVC " MetaMorphosed " or Evolved into Something More Advanced -- the Vedic Civilizations

Present day Hinduism is largely a continuum of Vedic Civilisation

So IVC is the Roots of Indian Hindu Civilisation

 

[Joe Shearer]

The precursor and predecessor of Indian Vedic and Hindu Civilizational Identity

There is nothing to show this.

 

[Joe Shearer]

Those areas where IVC existed, the towns and cities might have been abandoned

But the People Migrated Eastwards and intermingled with Aryans and other Indian communities ie spread all over the Subcontinent

Again, this is pure speculation. There is not the slightest evidence of such developments, only genetic evidence that the Ancestral North Indian profile was composed of IVC genetic profile, + steppe ancestry profile + resident hunter-gatherer profile.

 

[Joe Shearer]

Civilizations are not just Archeological Constructs

They are also Cultural Entities

Culture and Religion.are Two Sides of the Same Coin

IVC " MetaMorphosed " or Evolved into Something More Advanced -- the Vedic Civilizations

There is ABSOLUTELY no connection between the IVC and Vedic culture (not civilisation).

 

[Joe Shearer]

Present day Hinduism is largely a continuum of Vedic Civilisation

So IVC is the Roots of Indian Hindu Civilisation

Both are terribly wrong and ahistoric statements.

 

[Vikramaditya1]

That's a weird way to think about the past, since the idea of 'Indian subcontinent' in our collective psyche itself is new.

I'm pretty sure my ancestor 2000 years ago did not think 'Pakistan is the weakest link in our subcontinent'.

Stop projecting post-colonial thought into the past.

You didn't understand the premise of what I am saying and is now blabbering. Without addressing anything.

 

[Joe Shearer]

@FuturePAF
Do you want disinformation to be restricted? This would have to be done by your formal report.