US Perspective on the Iran - Israel / US War

Please don't flat out lie to my face because if there's anything I can't stand more than hypocrites are liars. Also, you're missing the actual point of my criticism. You yourself acknowledge relying on Twitter feeds during the height of the Iran war. Nobody is claiming you've never questioned a report. The issue is whether you're applying the same evidentiary standards consistently.

Let's look at your own posting history.

On April 15, 2024, you confidently discussed reports of destroyed buildings, damaged runways and a damaged C-130 following Iran's attack on Israel. You referenced emerging footage and reports, but didn't identify or provide independent verification for those claims. https://defencepk.com/forums/threads/iran-launches-operation-true-promise-massive-missile-drone-strikes-across-israel-israel-allegedly-responds-with-quadcopters.5963/page-280#post-158225.

On October 2, 2024, you asserted that Israeli forces had suffered significant damage while simultaneously acknowledging that you didn't know exactly what had been struck. https://defencepk.com/forums/threads/israels-genocide-in-gaza-2023-till-present.272/page-3170#post-361015.

On September 11, 2026, you repeated a claim of $2.5 billion in military equipment losses from Iranian attacks without providing a source or explaining the calculation in your reply. https://defencepk.com/forums/thread...ran-israel-us-war.31323/page-507#post-1400235.

And on October 25, 2026, you explicitly accepted another member's assurance that a Saudi aircraft had been tracked, without the actual tracking evidence being presented in the exchange. https://defencepk.com/forums/thread...n-iran-responds.14927/page-10831#post-1441208.

And the list goes on and on....

Now, none of these examples automatically makes the information false. That's not my argument. My argument is that you have been willing to discuss, repeat and sometimes accept wartime claims without demonstrating independent corroboration. So why should the standard suddenly become more demanding when the subject is the grievances of ordinary Iranian citizens?

And naming three moderators whose judgment you trust doesn't resolve that inconsistency. Taking somebody's word for something is not the same as independently verifying it.

My Fox News remark was obviously sarcastic. The point was never that Fox News is the definitive authority on Iran. The point is that reports about Iranian grievances should be assessed on their evidence, just like military reports: original footage, identifiable locations, credible witnesses and independent corroboration.

If a particular report is misleading, demonstrate why. If footage is fabricated, expose the fabrication. But dismissing an entire category of grievances simply because the reporting does not meet a standard you haven't consistently applied elsewhere is not a credible response.

That's the double standard I was criticizing.
Ok so all I read was I don’t take all my sources from twitter feeds but legitimate news sources thanks for backing that up let’s move on
 
Ok so all I read was I don’t take all my sources from twitter feeds but legitimate news sources thanks for backing that up let’s move on
That's a remarkably convenient interpretation of what I just wrote.

Where exactly did you establish that the claims you repeated came from independently verified, legitimate news sources? Merely asserting that your information comes from reputable outlets doesn't demonstrate that it does.

In fact, you explicitly admitted that you sometimes accept information based on the assurances of other forum members. Your own words were: "if you say it was tracked on open source sites I believe you."

That's not independent verification. That's taking somebody's word for it.

And you're still avoiding the central argument: Why are you comfortable repeating wartime claims without presenting independent corroboration, yet demand a higher standard of verification when the subject turns to the grievances of ordinary Iranians?

Nobody is arguing that every report circulating on Twitter is authentic or that every account of events in Iran must be accepted uncritically. The argument is about applying consistent evidentiary standards regardless of whether the information supports your preferred narrative.

Whether something originates from Twitter, mainstream media or a forum member is secondary to whether the underlying claim can be substantiated.

You haven't addressed that inconsistency. You've simply declared yourself vindicated without demonstrating how.

And no, saying "let's move on" doesn't constitute a rebuttal.
 
That's a remarkably convenient interpretation of what I just wrote.

Where exactly did you establish that the claims you repeated came from independently verified, legitimate news sources? Merely asserting that your information comes from reputable outlets doesn't demonstrate that it does.

In fact, you explicitly admitted that you sometimes accept information based on the assurances of other forum members. Your own words were: "if you say it was tracked on open source sites I believe you."

That's not independent verification. That's taking somebody's word for it.

And you're still avoiding the central argument: Why are you comfortable repeating wartime claims without presenting independent corroboration, yet demand a higher standard of verification when the subject turns to the grievances of ordinary Iranians?

Nobody is arguing that every report circulating on Twitter is authentic or that every account of events in Iran must be accepted uncritically. The argument is about applying consistent evidentiary standards regardless of whether the information supports your preferred narrative.

Whether something originates from Twitter, mainstream media or a forum member is secondary to whether the underlying claim can be substantiated.

You haven't addressed that inconsistency. You've simply declared yourself vindicated without demonstrating how.

And no, saying "let's move on" doesn't constitute a rebuttal.
Ok you win I’m good
 


The acting US Navy secretary says Tomahawk production is well above 60/month which is 720/year.

The US defense industrial base is ramping faster than I thought.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RzA
Iran-Attacked.png

Iran strikes American-Zionist military bases in Kuwait, destroying a lot of stuff. Iran also attacked Bahrain: drone attacks targeting Bahrain’s Sheikh Isa Air Base.

NOTE: Isa Air Base in Bahrain, which houses US forces, was reportedly hit hard by a swarm of kamikaze drones. Some sources are claiming US casualties.
 
Last edited:
Iran-Attacked.png

Iran strikes American-Zionist military bases in Kuwait, destroying a lot of stuff. Iran also attacked Bahrain: drone attacks targeting Bahrain’s Sheikh Isa Air Base.

NOTE: Isa Air Base in Bahrain, which houses US forces, was reportedly hit hard by a swarm of kamikaze drones.

Some sources are claiming US casualties.
1794963309324.png
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top