US Perspective on the Iran - Israel / US War

Omg you didn’t post this joker as backing up your claims he’s the one whose posting those videos that haven’t been verified by anyone seriously raptor I want to take you seriously but start actually opening websites that aren’t twitter feeds or propaganda sites

Again, you’re living in denial. I don’t know if the protest will spread but it most certainly happened. An I use plenty of sources including websites.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RzA
Talk about hypocrisy and double standards. You gobble up all of the twitter feeds when it comes to the war but when it comes to Iranian people's grievances you need it verified by fox news. COPIUM is one hell of a drug. Seriously bro sit this one out you're making yourself look foolish.
Please tell me where and when do I gobble up twitter feeds other than the height of the Iran war even than I would always ask is that real or can anyone back that up but this year has been really been bad with fakes or misleading information regarding many different topics I always ask 3 people if those things were true @Persian Gulf @AZ_HighCountry and @RescueRanger and there are a handful of other moderators that I will take their word at if they say posts are fake or real

To be fair I think your getting a bit out there and I feel like your trying to start problems with people when there isn’t a problem to begin with ttyl buddy take a Xanax
 
Again, you’re living in denial. I don’t know if the protest will spread but it most certainly happened. An I use plenty of sources including websites.
Serious denial here all day long to be fair if these guys are chanting bring back the shah in the 10s of thousands like you say I will apologize…I have no problem admitting to when I’m wrong but since the main guy posting videos of asking for the shah to return is the fake shah I will wait for American or even extreme Israeli news sites so far nothing
 
🤣 🤣 🤣 very sensitive indeed 😆
You know, I've always enjoyed engaging with you, right now there is so much BS propaganda everywhere so it's nice to see you ask difficult questions and challenge the deluge if tweet posts from time to time, especially if it contains a video shot on a potato in 2026. 😂
 
@F-22Raptor and @RzA can you kindly lay off on pile diving @Shags202 he is actually a very sensible poster.

Thanks.

Sure, I’m just tired of being called a liar and a peddler of “fake news.”

I was banned from the main Iran thread because I said hundreds to thousands of Iranian protesters were being killed when the protests broke out in January. I was called a liar and banned. Turns out it was tens of thousands.

I was told TankerTraffic was a fake news source when they stated oil flow through the Strait was back to prewar levels minus Iranian oil. Turns out that was accurate too.
 
Sure, I’m just tired of being called a liar and a peddler of “fake news.”

I was banned from the main Iran thread because I said hundreds to thousands of Iranian protesters were being killed when the protests broke out in January. I was called a liar and banned. Turns out it was tens of thousands.

I was told TankerTraffic was a fake news source when they stated oil flow through the Strait was back to prewar levels minus Iranian oil. Turns out that was accurate too.
Fair enough dude, just share opinions without fighting. This thread has maintained a good balance, let's keep that going please.
 
Sure, I’m just tired of being called a liar and a peddler of “fake news.”

I was banned from the main Iran thread because I said hundreds to thousands of Iranian protesters were being killed when the protests broke out in January. I was called a liar and banned. Turns out it was tens of thousands.

I was told TankerTraffic was a fake news source when they stated oil flow through the Strait was back to prewar levels minus Iranian oil. Turns out that was accurate too.
Before I go I don’t think your a liar you do leave out parts of the story that sides with your narrative but you dig deeper into it and there’s more to it I honestly keep saying it your a hell of a lot smarter than me but you tend to skip details purposely that’s why I say I want to take you seriously but you leave out big parts in your posts and sometimes you post things that you believe to be true but don’t actually verify it with legitimate sources and trust me the other side does it to you want to know the biggest difference to people I don’t take seriously at all and you is real simple I have those guys on ignore and I actually really do want to take you seriously you have a bias or not I know who is actually smart and whose full of crap
 
Please tell me where and when do I gobble up twitter feeds other than the height of the Iran war even than I would always ask is that real or can anyone back that up but this year has been really been bad with fakes or misleading information regarding many different topics I always ask 3 people if those things were true @Persian Gulf @AZ_HighCountry and @RescueRanger and there are a handful of other moderators that I will take their word at if they say posts are fake or real

To be fair I think your getting a bit out there and I feel like your trying to start problems with people when there isn’t a problem to begin with ttyl buddy take a Xanax
Please don't flat out lie to my face because if there's anything I can't stand more than hypocrites are liars. Also, you're missing the actual point of my criticism. You yourself acknowledge relying on Twitter feeds during the height of the Iran war. Nobody is claiming you've never questioned a report. The issue is whether you're applying the same evidentiary standards consistently.
Let's look at your own posting history.

On April 15, 2024, you confidently discussed reports of destroyed buildings, damaged runways and a damaged C-130 following Iran's attack on Israel. You referenced emerging footage and reports, but didn't identify or provide independent verification for those claims. https://defencepk.com/forums/threads/iran-launches-operation-true-promise-massive-missile-drone-strikes-across-israel-israel-allegedly-responds-with-quadcopters.5963/page-280#post-158225.

On October 2, 2024, you asserted that Israeli forces had suffered significant damage while simultaneously acknowledging that you didn't know exactly what had been struck. https://defencepk.com/forums/threads/israels-genocide-in-gaza-2023-till-present.272/page-3170#post-361015.

On September 11, 2026, you repeated a claim of $2.5 billion in military equipment losses from Iranian attacks without providing a source or explaining the calculation in your reply. https://defencepk.com/forums/thread...ran-israel-us-war.31323/page-507#post-1400235.

And on October 25, 2026, you explicitly accepted another member's assurance that a Saudi aircraft had been tracked, without the actual tracking evidence being presented in the exchange. https://defencepk.com/forums/thread...n-iran-responds.14927/page-10831#post-1441208.

And the list goes on and on....

Now, none of these examples automatically makes the information false. That's not my argument. My argument is that you have been willing to discuss, repeat and sometimes accept wartime claims without demonstrating independent corroboration. So why should the standard suddenly become more demanding when the subject is the grievances of ordinary Iranian citizens?

And naming three moderators whose judgment you trust doesn't resolve that inconsistency. Taking somebody's word for something is not the same as independently verifying it.

My Fox News remark was obviously sarcastic. The point was never that Fox News is the definitive authority on Iran. The point is that reports about Iranian grievances should be assessed on their evidence, just like military reports: original footage, identifiable locations, credible witnesses and independent corroboration.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

  • Pakistan Defence Latest

    Latest Posts

    Back
    Top