Western communist soldier says China's Military Isn't Ready for Combat

[MH.Yang]

Even China won't be able to defeat Afghanistan – it's a totally different case scenario.

Anyone can bomb Afghanistan and cause widespread destruction. But actually defeating Afghanistan, establishing control, and maintaining it across Afghanistan is a completely different challenge.

Not as simple a one-to-one military conflict.

Bread and jobs can defeat Afghanistan, not planes and bombs. Give China enough time, and we can prove that China can do it.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Wow this guy totally hit the nail on the head saying the obvious which I've been saying about PLA capabilities

Watch video before commenting (you know who you are) he makes excellent points the problem PLA has.

This is guy is so good and what he says is so true that america should send him in to defeat Iran. He must be captain america.

 

[Pioneer]

Even China won't be able to defeat Afghanistan – it's a totally different case scenario.

Anyone can bomb Afghanistan and cause widespread destruction. But actually defeating Afghanistan, establishing control, and maintaining it across Afghanistan is a completely different challenge.

Not as simple a one-to-one military conflict.

We can understand the despair of the Indians... China indeed possesses and controls Afghanistan

 

[Beijingwalker]

Left: US Right: China

 

[Pioneer]

Lol. What an easy $20 I just made. I made a bet that PDF chinese would go off topic and bring up other crap instead of dissecting the videos claims. Thanks!

Back on topic....

View attachment 212438

The Chinese Military Is Built for Politics, Not Fighting Wars​

Timothy R. Heath
Monday, January 5, 2026, 2:00 PM

China’s military possesses some dangerous weapons, but its ability to outfight the U.S. military is seriously overstated.

The Chinese Military Is Built for Politics, Not Fighting Wars

China’s military possesses some dangerous weapons, but its ability to outfight the U.S. military is seriously overstated.

www.lawfaremedia.org

Seems 40% of PLA training is propaganda or ideology training which makes sense since the PLA is the armed wing of the CCP and PLA loyalty is the CCP first then China. PLA is what protects CCP from its own people therefore they want their service members to be brainwa..... loyal to the CCP which is why ALL PLA generals and admirals are CCP party members and the upper echelon is placed in those positions by whom they are friends with and not merit.

The colonist said, "The fighting ability of four policemen..."

 

[Raj-Hindustani]

We can understand the despair of the Indians... China indeed possesses and controls Afghanistan

Yaar dont be chilidish, shall i post and claim similar way?



Does this kind of useless picture make any sense to this kind of discussion

 

[retaxis]

Yaar dont be chilidish, shall i post and claim similar way?

View attachment 212454

Does this kind of useless picture make any sense to this kind of discussion

He is posting the map saying China has been fighting in afghanistan before lol it has nothing to do with bragging like you are trying to do.

He post map to show you that your comment "Even China won't be able to defeat Afghanistan" is false as China has conquered Afghanistan before. Do you do logic or is that something you missed in school?

 

[Pioneer]

Yaar dont be chilidish, shall i post and claim similar way?

View attachment 212454

Does this kind of useless picture make any sense to this kind of discussion

India is indeed a former colony of China and the UK.

 

[Raj-Hindustani]

He is posting the map saying China has been fighting in afghanistan before lol it has nothing to do with bragging like you are trying to do.

He post map to show you that your comment "Even China won't be able to defeat Afghanistan" is false as China has conquered Afghanistan before. Do you do logic or is that something you missed in school?

Fighting? When?

I was simply showing a map to illustrate that, at one point in the old period, China controlled parts of what is now considered present-day afghan territory. I used the same kind of historical map for the Indian empires as well.

Suddenly, where did the idea of “fighting” come from? The map was meant to show historical territorial control, not warfare or conflict or any connection to present day about fighting ability.

 

[AZ_HighCountry]

The guy talking is not a qualified military analyst. He is an american soldier giving his opinion piece based on what he THINKS he knows about the Chinese mmilitary. Before February 28th 2026, these americans ALSO claimed that Iran would be defeated in less than a week and the Iranian public would overthrow the Iranian government, yet 6 months later, here we are. NEVER trust what these people say.

Not hard to guess what his user name is here.

 

[chinasun]

The U.S. has a penchant for starting wars. China simply needs to ensure that America cannot profit from these conflicts. Given enough time, the U.S. will inevitably collapse

 

[retaxis]

The U.S. has a penchant for starting wars. China simply needs to ensure that America cannot profit from these conflicts. Given enough time, the U.S. will inevitably collapse

If its not demographics or politics that causes it, it will probably be economics.

Global government borrowing costs have surged to multi-decade highs as a massive sell-off in long-dated bonds rattles international financial markets. [1, 2]

What is Happening

• • Surging Yields: The 30-year U.S. Treasury yield spiked to around 5.3%, reaching levels not seen since 2007.
  • Government Intervention: U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent doubled planned debt buybacks to $4 billion to stabilize prices and calm the US Treasury Market, though relief has been short-lived.
  • Global Spread: Borrowing costs in major economies like Germany, France, and Australia have also climbed significantly. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]

Causes of the Turmoil

• • Inflationary Pressures: Ongoing conflict involving Iran has pushed oil prices higher, reviving fears of persistent inflation.
  • Mounting Debt: U.S. national debt has neared $40 trillion with high annual interest payments, raising questions about future debt absorption.
  • Competing Demand: Massive infrastructure and bond issuance by AI technology firms are competing with governments for capital. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]

 

[Sinan]

For 4 minutes, he repeated that Chinese soldiers take indoctrination not actual training. I was bored after listening to some things over and over again.

A typical idiot if you ask me. Where did he get his data? Like, i doubt that he has any experience with PLA, even a visit to China.

 

[retaxis]

For 4 minutes, he repeated that Chinese soldiers take indoctrination not actual training. I was bored after listening to some things over and over again.

A typical idiot if you ask me. Where did he get his data? Like, i doubt that he has any experience with PLA, even a visit to China.

American jar heads with an IQ of a 14 yr old is usually not a good source