Who Created Harappan / Indus Valley Civilisation? | How Did It End? | Samvaad With Devdutt Pattanaik

[FarhanSiddiqui]

At least you are honouring your ancestors which you chose to purposefully forsake all of these years especially after partition

The Indians live their alternate reality. The Greeks and Italians are Christian that does not mean that they don’t honour their ancestors.. Besides Hinduism formed after Indo Aryan migrated from Central Asia centuries after the decline of Indus Valley

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

At least you are honouring your ancestors which you chose to purposefully forsake all of these years especially after partition

We Pakistanis have ALWAYS honoured the Indus Valley, Harappa and Mohenjo-Daro Cvilisations as we Pakistanis are their DIRECT bloodline descendants and inheritors of these civilisations. Modern day indians/dravidians have 0 connection to these ancient civilisations situated in Pakistan so there is no need for those of the indian persuasion to be here.

 

[panzerfaust 3]

The Indians live their alternate reality. The Greeks and Italians are Christian that does not mean that they don’t honour their ancestors..

Yes they do but something was stopping you from doing it
Besides Italians and greeks are at least the intellectual heirs of their philosophy

Besides Hinduism formed after Indo Aryan migrated from Central Asia centuries after the decline of Indus Valley

Please read more about Aryan religion,you are claiming something that is much different from the reality
If you are willing I can elaborate

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

But we just love you ,angrej looking gora chitaa chikna pakis
We absolutely adore you ,you are the living embodiment of beauty and perfection on the earth

We are just kala hindutava al-kafir al-honolulu

Why don't you racially inferior subhuman vermin just all gas yourselves to death and do the world a huge favour.

 

[Neojinnah]

Who created which civilization, does not matter now.
Only thing matters which civilization you followed .
Some chose idol worshiping same as their ancestors(hindus ).
Some chose /got converted to a foreign culture (arab), some indigenous like late budhishm/Sikhism.
Hindus are called inheritor because the culture Hindus followed, is indigenous to land .

It is because of inferiority complex, religious fanaticism, indoctrination, and identity crisis that Gangetic plains dwellers think they can exclusively kang on an pre-Vedic ancient civilization because they do pooja to Aryan gods. Just proving my thesis again that Indians have been indoctrinated to believe that cow fanaticism and idol worship is central to their identity and race.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Who created which civilization, does not matter now.
Only thing matters which civilization you followed .
Some chose idol worshiping same as their ancestors(hindus ).
Some chose /got converted to a foreign culture (arab), some indigenous like late budhishm/Sikhism.
Hindus are called inheritor because the culture Hindus followed, is indigenous to land .

By that definition, sub-saharan black african Roman Catholics are inheritors or the Vatican, Rome and Catholicism whereas pure-breed Italians who are communists are not.........................

 

[Neojinnah]

Yes they do but something was stopping you from doing it

Indians don't honour their ancestors. The vast majority of them are sanskritized and converted products of lowborn dasyu ancestors who have adopted Aryan religion, Aryan names, literally forged fake Vedic Aryan bloodlines and lineages. They spit on their lowborn ancestors who were considered shudra, mleccha, slave, impure, etc by the original Hindus every day being converted Hindus.

The idea of India is literally a slap on the face of the majority of Indians. Ramesh from Bihar IDing as a Bharata while having absolutely nothing to do with the Bharatas beyond the fact that his lineage was conquered and culturally dominated by the actual Bharatas.

 

[peagle]

Who created which civilization, does not matter now.
Only thing matters which civilization you followed .
Some chose idol worshiping same as their ancestors(hindus ).
Some chose /got converted to a foreign culture (arab), some indigenous like late budhishm/Sikhism.
Hindus are called inheritor because the culture Hindus followed, is indigenous to land .

According to your indian logic,
if entire European continent converts to Hinduism, the Indus civilisation belongs to them?
Do you people even think before saying something?

You can change religion every hour of the day and claim the entire world. It's ridiculous logic.
It's time for you people to grow up.

Any claim falls into several categories,
Primary claim,
Secondary claim,
Tertiary claim.

Primary claim belongs to the land and it's people, nothing else matters, it does not change with religion, language or culture. Because these things are evolutionary in nature. The land remains constant and so does the continuous inhabitation by the people.

Secondary claim falls into various categories, for example, religion. History of early Islam happened on the Arabian peninsula, primarily claim to that history belongs to the people who have lived and still live on those lands.
Muslims from rest of the world can feel deeply rooted to that place in a religious sense but their claim at best is secondary, not primary.
Similarly, if today whole of India decided to become Jewish, it doesn't mean you lose claim to your own history. Religion is not the deciding matter, not even the main factor.

Tertiary claim can encompass distant links, such as the South Indians, In fact most of india can at best make a secondary claim or a tertiary to the Indus Valley civilisation.

The primary claim belongs to the entirety of Pakistan and merely the north westerns parts of india. That's it.

India has it's Gangetic civilisation, and the Dravidian civilisation, both of which have nothing to do with the Indus valley civilisation. Some influence is natural due to geography but that's nothing special.