BJP Labels All Muslims in India As Traitors

The poster I flagged up for extra scrutiny himself denies being a bhakt.

It is the typical Hindustani citizen's displacement on display.

"(I agree with the narrative that Muslims, as a group, have leeched off Indian society and were the cause of Pakistan's creation as well as the only - and ongoing - beneficiaries of it as well as an ungrateful group in general who should yield to the writ of the Hindu qom and deserve no legacy rights of their own historical efforts, but despite all those beliefs I hold dearly in my heart,) I do declare that am not a bhakt or a sanghee and I love Modi for his economic policies".

I do not in fact "colour any population because of a single person", rather your citizens are perfectly capable of explaining their own majoritarian populist opinions towards subcontinental Muslims without any assistance from me, as demonstrated ably by the poster in question.

I don't get it man - for the one poster you had Kryptonite and me countering the arguments. I am not sure how you make judgement on entire population when the anecdotal evidence (given behavior of members on this forum) says otherwise...

I can for e.g., take a few nut jobs members which Pakistani flags and make sweeping statements on how they are representative of hatred of all Hindus (and that is majority actively posting members here). But I don't do that because 1) Its not my personal experience 2) Data set is not large enough for extrapolation 3) I want to be conservative when deriving such negative conclusions

Makes sense?
 
I don't get it man - for the one poster you had Kryptonite and me countering the arguments. I am not sure how you make judgement on entire population when the anecdotal evidence (given behavior of members on this forum) says otherwise...

I can for e.g., take a few nut jobs members which Pakistani flags and make sweeping statements on how they are representative of hatred of all Hindus (and that is majority actively posting members here). But I don't do that because 1) Its not my personal experience 2) Data set is not large enough for extrapolation 3) I want to be conservative when deriving such negative conclusions

Makes sense?
When did I say or suggest I harbour "hatred of all hindus"?? Need I remind you that there are 5 million hindu citizens of Pakistan, whom our nation and its armed forces will fight for against any Muslim soldiers or fitna terrorists you deploy against us?

I think you need to read my posts with greater scrutiny. I also do not doubt that there is a very small minority of Indian hindus that genuinely and fearlessly criticise hindutva and Indian nationalist posturing. They are genuine pacifists and are vocally against war with Pakistan and even lobby for a democratic outcome to the Kashmir question and prosecution of parties guilty of war crimes - yes, a few Indian hindus hold this genuinely reasoned and intellectual view.

Do you honestly think anyone from our Indian viewership on this forum represents that particular radical niche?
 
When did I say or suggest I harbour "hatred of all hindus"?? Need I remind you that there are 5 million hindu citizens of Pakistan, whom our nation and its armed forces will fight for against any Muslim soldiers or fitna terrorists you deploy against us?

I think you need to read my posts with greater scrutiny. I also do not doubt that there is a very small minority of Indian hindus that genuinely and fearlessly criticise hindutva and Indian nationalist posturing. They are genuine pacifists and are vocally against war with Pakistan and even lobby for a democratic outcome to the Kashmir question and prosecution of parties guilty of war crimes - yes, a few Indian hindus hold this genuinely reasoned and intellectual view.

Do you honestly think anyone from our Indian viewership on this forum represents that particular radical niche?

I don't think there will be a majority which will agree with everything that is an average Pakistani citizens view (or is in favor of Pakistan). Also, I can put forward my POV and perhaps represent a certain section of Indians. Here is my POV:

1. Hindutva is a much abused word. People across the aisle have used it for their benefits (Pakistani members here equate it with Zionism, while many political leaders in India use it to stoke violence/emotions). I stand more for an ethos that has existed since thousands of years back. The one which made India a melting pot of diversity (across religion, languages etc.). There is sufficient historical evidence to suggest this - we can go at length in another thread if required.
Must read: The Miracle that was India by AL Basham. You can ask GPT for a summary too

2. I believe that the aspirations of Pakistani citizens is no different that an Indian and the day to day problems are also very similar (roti, kapda, makaan, corruption, education, quality of life etc.) - 90%-95% time is spent on this with 5% for other matters - political, religious, take your pick

3. The governance structures are very different. While India's democracy is not perfect by any means (politicians using money and liquor at lower level to influence voters for eg), it works. The biggest reason why it works is that people are very cognizant of the holistic benefit they will get from choosing a particular representative and the election commission is not corrupt. The evidence here is parties in power loosing by considerable margins (wipe-outs) regardless of whatever rhetoric political leaders sell. Take example of Rajasthan, Bihar, Southern India, North Eastern state - many a times the election survey orgs also get it wrong

4. Pakistan's governance structure (for several reasons) don't give as much power to people. An acceptance of hybrid system, a track record of military in power (whatever amli jaama they want to use) takes power away from common people and shifts it towards fairly concentrated centers of power. This also creates issue for delivery of services, goods and overall betterment of society.

5. In last 70+ years, for most years it has been in India's interest to have peace with Pakistan (as India was a struggling economy, had larger number of people below poverty line, limited help from big powers etc.). Right now, the pendulum has swung the other way (not sure how far though). Its in greater interest of Pakistan to have peace with India as its embroiled in a "two-front" internal conflict (Balochistan, KPK, terrorism etc.)

6. Outside-in understanding based on anecdotes, youtube videos coming out of Pakistan (don't have definitive research/data) - Many Pakistani's still think India is lagging (living in the past). E.g., can't believe the cars, the lack of inflation, the infrastructure etc. that exists in country today. Furthermore, the issues of Hindu-Muslim divide in their minds is much bigger than on ground. Data shows that number of riot incidents has been on a down-trend (however that doesn't mean problems don't exist - I have alluded to)

7. Most Indians don't want war with Pakistan but also want to see some action against UN designated POI residing in Pakistan. The only time average Indians start getting on the anti-Pakistan train is post terrorist attacks. The Parliament attack, 26/11 and few others are etched in memories of most Indians (who grew up 80s onwards and will be in position of power for next 1-2 decades)

Lastly, I find it disheartening when people here display a brash hatred of Hindus - calling them cow urine drinkers, Hindutva junkies etc. This is as far from truth as can be. India is a rapidly advancing society. Also, there is a rejuvenation of ancient practices - yoga, ayurveda etc which are helping them lead day to day life better. There are also western influences which I would say cut both ways - kids are more independent but families are nuclear so emotional support system is weak.

In near future, my strong conviction is that India will continue to grow and enrich the world through innovation and revival of ancient knowledge. It will fight anything that wants to destroy the ethos of inclusion, hospitality, selflessness that majority people represent.

There is a dichotomy which I fail to understand: People many a time are not genuine and you have to be careful lest you get duped. On the other hand, they will share their food, whatever little they have, give away stuff to you without asking for anything in return.

Anyways, those were some good Saturday reflections...
 
Disagree that RSS had no influence in the 1940s. Fundamentally so.

As for your Muslim artists succeeding in India but not in Pakistan - damn right. SRK, Salman, Javed Akhtar and the rest of them shamelessly pander to hindutva sentiments and are genuinely overrated as artists. I can guarantee you that such "sucking up" to perceived majority sentiments in lieu of genuine talent will not work with the more discerning and critical Pakistani audience. In fact, it only works as a career strategy in India because of the superficiality of thought of the average citizen. There is a reason Bollywood generates reams and reams of "work" every year - 99% of it is gutter trash but somehow appeals to fragile egos.

Mind you, the minute these "house muslims" step out of line, e.g. Salman wants to play the role of an Indian deity, as is very much his artistic licence in a supposedly secular nation state, all hell breaks loose. Gowalkar's progeny are continuing his legacy with gusto, despite your assertions that they are of little relevance in Indian societal discourse.


I have noted that you seem to forget you are on a Pakistani forum, where the audience you are preaching to knows the behavioural patterns of your citizenry only too well. Indeed, we have known you for generations. So you might need a different angle entirely if you wish to pull the wool over our eyes.
Like I said earlier, a free and fair debate can't occur on an Islamic forum
 
Hindutva is a much abused word.
We define hindutva based on objective evidence, as offered willingly by RSS/BJP nexus operatives. Smashing "Karachi Bakery", destroying Mughal architecture, and lynching beef eaters provides us with the required evidence to enable this definition. If you wish us to define it differently, you should do a better job of reforming it as a concept or, at the very least, concealing it and obfuscating it from public view as the zionists have done.
I believe that the aspirations of Pakistani citizens is no different that an Indian and the day to day problems are also very similar
Agree.
The governance structures are very different.
Agree. So what? Pakistan is fighting an existential war against the dalitised horde of a nation to our east. We shall "govern" as we see fit until victory is achieved. Ukraine is a dictatorship since the Russian invasion. Our political contexts are somewhat similar.
Pakistan's governance structure (for several reasons) don't give as much power to people.
See above.
In last 70+ years, for most years it has been in India's interest to have peace with Pakistan
Disagree. You have simply provided an opinion here without evidence.
Outside-in understanding based on anecdotes, youtube videos coming out of Pakistan (don't have definitive research/data) - Many Pakistani's still think India is lagging (living in the past).
So what if we think this? Why does it offend you? I personally would rather be dead than Indian, regardless of your economy.
Most Indians don't want war with Pakistan but also want to see some action against UN designated POI residing in Pakistan
The UN says a lot about POI in India, about Kashmir and about water rights for riparian nation states also. You can't pick and choose what suits you. Similarly, you can't pick and choose parts of treaties and colonial era edicts or selectively deploy them when your interests are suited, but default to violence when not. We have discussed the contradictions in Delhi's adherence to UN resolutions and treaties in other threads - no need to repeat here.
Lastly, I find it disheartening when people here display a brash hatred of Hindus - calling them cow urine drinkers, Hindutva junkies etc.
Classic obfuscation and conflation fallacy.

"Hatred of hindus" is not acceptable and even if they drink cow urine, this is harmless to others, so should not be a cause for ridicule (though some genuine secularists might disagree and regard ridicule of religion as acceptable in a genuine democratic society). In any event, being a "hindutva junkie" is certainly problematic as hindutva harms others, especially Muslims. You are obscuring the distinction between hindutva and hindu, quite deliberately, as you have attempted to do repeatedly in this thread. This is the way "I vote Modi for economics" types and even Congress voters operate. We have seen it for decades now. Keep holding aloft the mask for the dalitised hordes if you wish. We see right through it.
 
We define hindutva based on objective evidence, as offered willingly by RSS/BJP nexus operatives. Smashing "Karachi Bakery", destroying Mughal architecture, and lynching beef eaters provides us with the required evidence to enable this definition. If you wish us to define it differently, you should do a better job of reforming it as a concept or, at the very least, concealing it and obfuscating it from public view as the zionists have done.

Agree.

Agree. So what? Pakistan is fighting an existential war against the dalitised horde of a nation to our east. We shall "govern" as we see fit until victory is achieved. Ukraine is a dictatorship since the Russian invasion. Our political contexts are somewhat similar.

See above.

Disagree. You have simply provided an opinion here without evidence.

So what if we think this? Why does it offend you? I personally would rather be dead than Indian, regardless of your economy.

The UN says a lot about POI in India, about Kashmir and about water rights for riparian nation states also. You can't pick and choose what suits you. Similarly, you can't pick and choose parts of treaties and colonial era edicts or selectively deploy them when your interests are suited, but default to violence when not. We have discussed the contradictions in Delhi's adherence to UN resolutions and treaties in other threads - no need to repeat here.

Classic obfuscation and conflation fallacy.

"Hatred of hindus" is not acceptable and even if they drink cow urine, this is harmless to others, so should not be a cause for ridicule (though some genuine secularists might disagree and regard ridicule of religion as acceptable in a genuine democratic society). In any event, being a "hindutva junkie" is certainly problematic as hindutva harms others, especially Muslims. You are obscuring the distinction between hindutva and hindu, quite deliberately, as you have attempted to do repeatedly in this thread. This is the way "I vote Modi for economics" types and even Congress voters operate. We have seen it for decades now. Keep holding aloft the mask for the dalitised hordes if you wish. We see right through it.

You are a confused person. Are you dealing with Hindutva or Dalitised hordes (whatever that means) and well the fact that you'd be dead rather than a Hindu tells me of religious fervor and hatred you proudly wear as a batch.

Nothing more to be said. Peace
 
You are a confused person. Are you dealing with Hindutva or Dalitised hordes (whatever that means) and well the fact that you'd be dead rather than a Hindu tells me of religious fervor and hatred you proudly wear as a batch.

Nothing more to be said. Peace
Tsk tsk my boy.

You are yet again hallucinating. It's disgraceful frankly.

I did not say I'd rather be dead than a hindu.

I said I'd rather be dead than an Indian.

Scroll up to review the receipts.

You are DESPERATE to create a religion based discordance when there is none. You are DESPERATE to define Pakistani nationalism as hinduphobic when it is not. Your whole innings is literally falling apart.

This chanakiya is why there can be no peace until hindutva is smashed, along with you fraudus who feign "moderation" while shielding the saffronist trishul wielder behind you.
 
@Master Chief

Do liberals who support Congress or AAP or communist parties happen to be Hinduwadi too?

Do people like me who are fed up with Muslim appeasement of the BJ, Congress,AAP and every other party happen to be Hinduwadis too? My previous posts shed light on how the BJP rule has benefited Muslims at the expense of Hindus .

Do whites of western countries who are resisting Islamic takeover happen to be Hinduwadi too?
 
@Master Chief

Do liberals who support Congress or AAP or communist parties happen to be Hinduwadi too?

Do people like me who are fed up with Muslim appeasement of the BJ, Congress,AAP and every other party happen to be Hinduwadis too? My previous posts shed light on how the BJP rule has benefited Muslims at the expense of Hindus .

Do whites of western countries who are resisting Islamic takeover happen to be Hinduwadi too?
I have made it exquisitely and excruciatingly clear, repeatedly so, that hindutva is facilitated by those who would hold up a mask on their behalf to help conceal them. The mask holders can be Congress voters, muslims, white people, even pixies floating around on clouds. It is tiresome repeating the same explanations for you and one other individual on this thread.

Indeed, this sort of saturation attack feigning ignorance is a well known strategy of your kind.
 
Disagree that RSS had no influence in the 1940s. Fundamentally so.

As for your Muslim artists succeeding in India but not in Pakistan - damn right. SRK, Salman, Javed Akhtar and the rest of them shamelessly pander to hindutva sentiments and are genuinely overrated as artists. I can guarantee you that such "sucking up" to perceived majority sentiments in lieu of genuine talent will not work with the more discerning and critical Pakistani audience. In fact, it only works as a career strategy in India because of the superficiality of thought of the average citizen. There is a reason Bollywood generates reams and reams of "work" every year - 99% of it is gutter trash but somehow appeals to fragile egos.

Mind you, the minute these "house muslims" step out of line, e.g. Salman wants to play the role of an Indian deity, as is very much his artistic licence in a supposedly secular nation state, all hell breaks loose. Gowalkar's progeny are continuing his legacy with gusto, despite your assertions that they are of little relevance in Indian societal discourse.


I have noted that you seem to forget you are on a Pakistani forum, where the audience you are preaching to knows the behavioural patterns of your citizenry only too well. Indeed, we have known you for generations. So you might need a different angle entirely if you wish to pull the wool over our eyes.
Wrong..

Jawed is openly anti Hindutva.

Sharukh was anti Hindutva too. He made many pro Pakistan statements in the past. But his son runs a drugs business. He was caught. Let off easily by the Hinduwadis. So he doesn't comment on politics anymore.

Salman Bhaijaan had serious offences registered against him. He also made many pro Pakistan statements in the past. Hinduwadis buried his cases. So he supports their party for now. But he is a kattar Islamist.


The funny thing is that even after Partition, RSS had no influence and was a toothless organisation.

Besides Indian Muslims, Gandhi ji was responsible for this mess.

He let Muslims stay. He never realized that Islam will always come first for Muslims.

He had no problem with with seperate electorates for Muslims. He had no problem for over representation for Muslims. He had no problem with Muslim reservation.

Gandhi used to tell Hindus to let Muslim rioters murder them and their family. Asked Hindu females to let Muslims rape them. Told Hindus never to retaliate. This is documented history. He suffered from a serious Stockholm Syndrome.

The current crop of BJP and the RSS are too suffering from this Stockholm Syndrome probably induced by petro dollars of Gulf Countries
 
Last edited:
Tsk tsk my boy.

You are yet again hallucinating. It's disgraceful frankly.

I did not say I'd rather be dead than a hindu.

I said I'd rather be dead than an Indian.

Scroll up to review the receipts.

You are DESPERATE to create a religion based discordance when there is none. You are DESPERATE to define Pakistani nationalism as hinduphobic when it is not. Your whole innings is literally falling apart.

This chanakiya is why there can be no peace until hindutva is smashed, along with you fraudus who feign "moderation" while shielding the saffronist trishul wielder behind you.

So let me get this straight, you hate everyone who is Indian regardless of religion.

Lets take you on your word, even then when you start hating almost 18% of humanity (Indians), there is some perennial problem. I have already said in my posts above that religion/politics is maybe 5% of concern of an average Indian. But your hatred of a country is something else...
 
Its easy to hate, but remember the thing/person you're hating is also a product (and has the same essence as you) of supreme consciousness who you seek
You don't have a good understanding of non Dualism.

Didn't Krishna slay the Rakshas who were part of the same universal soul?
 
You don't have a good understanding of non Dualism.

Didn't Krishna slay the Rakshas who were part of the same universal soul?


When Krishna was performing these acts they were not self serving, he was beyond happiness or sadness, doing karmayoga. Even then, Krishna chose war when all other options had ended (not worked)

Your posts here put you on the other spectrum. If you are performing actions (karma) because you're alive and while performing you're above the happiness, sadness, and other emotions that come with success and/or failure, then you are doing your duty and you will attain moksha - whether you slay Rakshas or not.

Follow this:
1. Samarpan/Submit - Submit yourself to the one soul creator the supreme consciousness
2. Arpan/Offer - Offer all your actions and fruits of those actions to that soul for that conciousness is guiding your path
3. Sampoorna/Complete - You're complete as you are. Don't need anything. You need to find the small part of consciousness that resides in you and when you find it, you will find unbound peace and won't need a thing...

You're lucky that you are in India and there are many places which can help you attain above-mentioned peace (or at least give a push on your journey). Go to those places, stay in the silence and peace (not necessarily the fervor and festivity), see in human whats beyond the physical and mental forms.
 
When Krishna was performing these acts they were not self serving, he was beyond happiness or sadness, doing karmayoga. Even then, Krishna chose war when all other options had ended (not worked)

Your posts here put you on the other spectrum. If you are performing actions (karma) because you're alive and while performing you're above the happiness, sadness, and other emotions that come with success and/or failure, then you are doing your duty and you will attain moksha - whether you slay Rakshas or not.

Follow this:
1. Samarpan/Submit - Submit yourself to the one soul creator the supreme consciousness
2. Arpan/Offer - Offer all your actions and fruits of those actions to that soul for that conciousness is guiding your path
3. Sampoorna/Complete - You're complete as you are. Don't need anything. You need to find the small part of consciousness that resides in you and when you find it, you will find unbound peace and won't need a thing...

You're lucky that you are in India and there are many places which can help you attain above-mentioned peace (or at least give a push on your journey). Go to those places, stay in the silence and peace (not necessarily the fervor and festivity), see in human whats beyond the physical and mental forms.
Krishna (Nirguna Brahman) was born as a human. His pious human followers too slayed rakshas.

Slaying Rakshas is your Dharma.

Even he forbade Arjuna from running away from Dharma on the battlefield.

You want to spare Rakshas, Adharmis and cow killers because they are part of the same divine consciousness. No where did Krishna or Ram preach this.
 
Like I said earlier, a free and fair debate can't occur on an Islamic forum
Try debating on an Indian forum and when you say your a Muslim - they lash out like a pack of dogs and abuse is next level. Dont insinuate a platform which even has Indian mods wont allow debate. Calm down and drop the free and fair attitude.....
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top