BJP Labels All Muslims in India As Traitors

1. comparing the Constitution to partition politics is misleading. The Constitution wasn’t written to favor one community — it was written to protect every Indian equally. It has been amended over a hundred times, proving it’s not a rigid “asmani kitab,” but a living document that evolves with the nation’s values.
As you admitted the Congress amended it many times. Destroying its essence. Especially when Indira Gandhi added the word secular to the preamble. Most legal experts agree that original Constitution allowed religious freedom. But it wasn't secular as in complete separation of state and religion. Indira did Muslim appeasement on steroids. Secularism was forcefully enforced on non Muslims. While Muslims were allowed to have their religious special laws.

As you said decisions taken by the past generation shouldnt be forced on the present generation. If the present generation wants to bring a new constitution, there is nothing wrong with that. That's democratic. Majority decide.
2. Blaming one community for the Partition ignores historical nuance. The Muslim League led that demand, but millions of Muslims — especially in what became India — opposed Partition and chose to stay in a secular India. They didn’t “gain” from it; they faced suspicion and hardship for decades.
Are you denying that Muslims demanded a separate country and the non Muslims (majority of them) didn't..

How they gained from it is mentioned in previous post? Minor discrimination is present. No one denies it.

But we have almost 60 y.o Muslim actors having an onscreen romantic relationship with 20-25 year old hindu actresses. This wouldn't happen if they face such severe hardship as people claim.
3. The suffering of Hindus and Sikhs during Partition was immense and undeniable, but pain was on both sides. Millions of Muslims were also killed, displaced, and left destitute when they migrated to Pakistan.
No is denying that Muslims suffered losses too.

But you can't compare the pain of a guy guy who lost 100 rupees to the pain of a guy who lost 1 rupee and took the 100 rupees which belonged to the former guy.

4. Pointing to refugee crises or illegal immigration today doesn’t justify discrimination. Those are governance issues, not grounds for collective blame. Citizenship and equality under the Constitution are about individual rights, not inherited guilt from 1947.
Do you think a government of developing country can magically seal the porous border and stop Muslims from other sides entering?

Even superpower US can't do that.

The question is why do neighbouring Muslims who support 2 nation theory are illegally immigrating to India in such huge numbers? Why do Indian Muslims support that? Are you going to deny that Indian Muslims say that there is no illegal Muslim immigration to India and oppose NRC CAA.
Saying “the majority doesn’t have to abide by an unfair Constitution” is exactly what undermines democracy. The Constitution is what ensures that majorities don’t trample minorities. Rejecting it because it protects everyone equally isn’t strength — it’s regression.
Democracy is of the majority. If we don't like that. We should scrap elections.
So, yes — we should learn from the past, but not weaponize it to justify new injustices
Injustice is subjective too. In India, a Muslim can become a PM.

In Pakistan, a Hindu or a Sikh cannot. Most Pakistani Muslims don't see this as an injustice.

Family of a murder-rape victim think that death penalty is fair.

Rapist thinks it's too harsh. He should have been given a few years in a prison.
 
Last edited:
As you admitted the Congress amended it many times. Destroying its essence. Especially when Indira Gandhi added the word secular to the preamble. Most legal experts agree that original Constitution allowed religious freedom. But it wasn't secular as in complete separation of state and religion. Indira did Muslim appeasement on steroids. Secularism was forcefully enforced on non Muslims. While Muslims were allowed to have their religious special laws.
Amending the Constitution doesn’t destroy it — it’s what keeps it alive. The framers built in Article 368 so the document could evolve with time.

“Secular” wasn’t Indira’s invention; it was India’s practice since 1950. The word came later, but Articles 14, 15, 25, 26 already guaranteed equality and religious freedom. Courts have said this spirit existed long before the word was added.

And Indian secularism never meant cutting religion off — it meant equal respect for all. The state can engage with faith, but not favor any.

On personal laws — they exist for every community. Hindu law was reformed, Muslim law wasn’t. That’s uneven reform, not special privilege.

So no, secularism wasn’t “appeasement.” It’s the very thing that protects both majority and minority from each other — and from the state.
As you said decisions taken by the past generation shouldnt be forced on the present generation. If the present generation wants to bring a new constitution, there is nothing wrong with that. That's democratic. Majority decide.
You’re cherry-picking history to suit your argument. Using 1944 voters who supported Pakistan while ignoring the millions of Muslims who chose to stay in India is not logic — it’s a smokescreen to justify prejudice against today’s Indian Muslims.

Democracy isn’t rewriting the rulebook whenever a majority feels like it. The Constitution isn’t a relic — it’s the framework that lets today’s majority exist, including those who stayed loyal to India despite Partition.

Majority rule only works when rights are protected for everyone. Sidestepping that principle to rationalize bias isn’t clever — it’s mob rule disguised as democracy.
Are you denying that Muslims demanded a separate country and the non Muslims (majority of them) didn't..

How they gained from it is mentioned in previous post? Minor discrimination is present. No one denies it.

But we have almost 60 y.o Muslim actors having an onscreen romantic relationship with 20-25 year old hindu actresses. This wouldn't happen if they face such severe hardship as people claim.
The Muslim League won in Muslim-majority areas, but elections show political preference, not personal destiny. The League’s success reflected a specific agenda, yet over 35 million Indian Muslims chose to stay in India despite the risks. That decision wasn’t opportunism — it meant rejecting partition in favor of a secular, united India, even when leaving would have been easier. Past political mandates cannot be used to justify bias against those who made a different choice. Citizenship, loyalty, and justice are determined by present actions, not the voting patterns of decades ago

And Bollywood isn’t a social barometer. A few Muslim actors in romantic roles don’t erase decades of bias in housing, jobs, or politics. That’s like saying racism doesn’t exist in America because a few Black actors win Oscars.
No is denying that Muslims suffered losses too.

But you can't compare the pain of a guy guy who lost 100 rupees to the pain of a guy who lost 1 rupee and took the 100 rupees which belonged to the former guy.
Pain isn’t an arithmetic to be used to justify actions mate. Partition wasn’t a trade — it was a collapse of humanity on both sides.

Ranking grief by religion reduces a shared tragedy into a scoreboardYour analogy fails because it assumes someone “took” anything. Partition wasn’t a robbery — it was a house that burned down with everyone’s belongings inside.

Yes, some people occupied properties left behind, just as others lost everything overnight. But isolated opportunism in chaos isn’t the same as collective gain — scavenging after a disaster doesn’t mean anyone profited from it.

Both sides buried their dead and tried to rebuild from ruins. Counting who looted more doesn’t change the fact that everyone lost something that can’t be replaced

Do you think a government of developing country can magically seal the porous border and stop Muslims from other sides entering?

Even superpower US can't do that.

The question is why do neighbouring Muslims who support 2 nation theory are illegally immigrating to India in such huge numbers? Why do Indian Muslims support that? Are you going to deny that Indian Muslims say that there is no illegal Muslim immigration to India and oppose NRC CAA.
No one said sealing borders is “magical.” It’s a governance challenge, not a religious one. People cross borders out of poverty or instability — not ideology.

Blaming Indian Muslims for what foreigners do is illogical. Citizenship is a legal status, not a religious label. Holding 200 million citizens responsible for someone else’s actions replaces governance with prejudice.

Opposing NRC or CAA doesn’t mean supporting illegal immigration — it means demanding that laws stay fair, practical, and non-discriminatory. That’s democracy doing its job.

If every policy disagreement becomes a loyalty test, we stop being a democracy and start being a census of suspicion
Democracy is of the majority. If we don't like that. We should scrap elections.
That’s not democracy — that’s mob rule with better branding.

Democracy isn’t “might makes right.” It’s the opposite — it’s restraint by the strong so the weak don’t get crushed. The moment the majority stops being accountable to law, it stops being a majority and starts being a mob.

Elections give you power; the Constitution tells you how to use it. Scrap that, and you don’t get democracy — you get the illusion of strength right before a nation eats itself

Injustice is subjective too. In India, a Muslim can become a PM.

In Pakistan, a Hindu or a Sikh cannot. Most Pakistani Muslims don't see this as an injustice.

Family of a murder-rape victim think that death penalty is fair.

Rapist thinks it's too harsh. He should have been given a few years in a prison.
Using examples like a victim wanting the death penalty versus a rapist’s preference as if both are equally valid isn’t philosophy — it’s absurd. Justice isn’t measured by who feels wronged or who succeeds; it’s defined by rules that protect everyone equally.

And pointing to Pakistan to justify bias in India isn’t logic — it’s rationalizing racism. Just because something exists elsewhere doesn’t make it acceptable here. Cherry-picking examples to claim discrimination is “subjective” masks your real argument: personal prejudice dressed up as reasoning.

India’s Constitution exists precisely to prevent personal or communal bias from shaping policy. Your argument only proves why that protection is needed.
 
Last edited:
You insisted on going down the rabbit hole. So I reluctantly obliged. Just issuing a clarification.

If you say what's happened in the past, doesn't apply to the current era. Then same logic applies to the constitution which was written in the past without consulting ordinary citizens. The constitution isn't same as asmani kitab which cannot be changed.

Non Muslims didn't ask for a separate country. Muslims did.

Punjabi Hindus and Sikhs, Bengali Hindus and Sindhi Hindus were wealthy and hardworking compared to their Muslim counterparts. It's documented history. The former lost everything. While the later captured their wealth.

India had to accomodate to the expelled Hindu and Sikh folks. India still has to accomodate refugees from Pakistan and Bangladesh. Also illegal Muslim immigrants.

Pakistan and Bangladesh both promised religious freedom and protection of their non Muslim minorities. But they didn't fulfil the promise. Indian Muslims might face discrimination but never heard cases of their underage females being abducted and forcibly converted to Hinduism. They are found in Bollywood,media,civil services, private jobs, etc. They are a visible minority.

Partition was unfair to Non Muslims. Muslims gained from the partition as there was no total exchange of population. Non Muslims of India too point out that Indian Muslims have special rights compared to others. So they say India too belongs to Muslims first and foremost like Pakistan and Bangladesh. Former PM Manmohan Singh said that too.

If Congress would have conducted a referendum among Hindus and Sikhs of India whether they wanted Muslims out of India. Even most of Congress supporting Hindus and Sikhs would have voted for emigration of Muslims to West and East Pakistan. But the Congress never did that. They wanted Muslims to stay for their votebank politics. This unfair decision is still affecting non Muslim majority of India.

Going by your logic, the current majority of India doesn't have to abide by the unfair constitution which was written in the past, the terms of unfair partition and unfair decisions of the Congress which were taken in the past.

@Vapnope
Here we have it dear fellow forum goers.

The hatred is civilisational.

This sanghee filth simply cannot contain himself and sees fit to oblige us all with the deep festering historical loathing his kind has for Muslims, Mughals, and Pakistan.

Delhi and Kabul must have taken a severe battering this year that the usual Nehruvian mask of "secularism" has been discarded so willingly and visibly.

Let such posts stay as a stark reminder that we are dealing with an incorrigible people, one that will always link economic or societal "value" of a population to its ethnoreligious identity and nothing else, such that state sanctioned machinations might ensue that will create perpetual discord between various populations.

I applaud you for your vocal and visible honesty @AjitWadhwa while living amidst a veritable hive of those who would quietly urge you to remain faithful to the Nehruvian approach.
 
Here we have it dear fellow forum goers.

The hatred is civilisational.

This sanghee filth simply cannot contain himself and sees fit to oblige us all with the deep festering historical loathing his kind has for Muslims, Mughals, and Pakistan.

Delhi and Kabul must have taken a severe battering this year that the usual Nehruvian mask of "secularism" has been discarded so willingly and visibly.

Let such posts stay as a stark reminder that we are dealing with an incorrigible people, one that will always link economic or societal "value" of a population to its ethnoreligious identity and nothing else, such that state sanctioned machinations might ensue that will create perpetual discord between various populations.

I applaud you for your vocal and visible honesty @AjitWadhwa while living amidst a veritable hive of those who would quietly urge you to remain faithful to the Nehruvian approach.
I am just posting facts. Go through my later posts. Tell me if I am wrong.
 
Amending the Constitution doesn’t destroy it — it’s what keeps it alive. The framers built in Article 368 so the document could evolve with time.

“Secular” wasn’t Indira’s invention; it was India’s practice since 1950. The word came later, but Articles 14, 15, 25, 26 already guaranteed equality and religious freedom. Courts have said this spirit existed long before the word was added.

And Indian secularism never meant cutting religion off — it meant equal respect for all. The state can engage with faith, but not favor any.

On personal laws — they exist for every community. Hindu law was reformed, Muslim law wasn’t. That’s uneven reform, not special privilege.

So no, secularism wasn’t “appeasement.” It’s the very thing that protects both majority and minority from each other — and from the state.

You’re cherry-picking history to suit your argument. Using 1944 voters who supported Pakistan while ignoring the millions of Muslims who chose to stay in India is not logic — it’s a smokescreen to justify prejudice against today’s Indian Muslims.

Democracy isn’t rewriting the rulebook whenever a majority feels like it. The Constitution isn’t a relic — it’s the framework that lets today’s majority exist, including those who stayed loyal to India despite Partition.

Majority rule only works when rights are protected for everyone. Sidestepping that principle to rationalize bias isn’t clever — it’s mob rule disguised as democracy.

The Muslim League won in Muslim-majority areas, but elections show political preference, not personal destiny. The League’s success reflected a specific agenda, yet over 35 million Indian Muslims chose to stay in India despite the risks. That decision wasn’t opportunism — it meant rejecting partition in favor of a secular, united India, even when leaving would have been easier. Past political mandates cannot be used to justify bias against those who made a different choice. Citizenship, loyalty, and justice are determined by present actions, not the voting patterns of decades ago

And Bollywood isn’t a social barometer. A few Muslim actors in romantic roles don’t erase decades of bias in housing, jobs, or politics. That’s like saying racism doesn’t exist in America because a few Black actors win Oscars.

Pain isn’t an arithmetic to be used to justify actions mate. Partition wasn’t a trade — it was a collapse of humanity on both sides.

Ranking grief by religion reduces a shared tragedy into a scoreboardYour analogy fails because it assumes someone “took” anything. Partition wasn’t a robbery — it was a house that burned down with everyone’s belongings inside.

Yes, some people occupied properties left behind, just as others lost everything overnight. But isolated opportunism in chaos isn’t the same as collective gain — scavenging after a disaster doesn’t mean anyone profited from it.

Both sides buried their dead and tried to rebuild from ruins. Counting who looted more doesn’t change the fact that everyone lost something that can’t be replaced


No one said sealing borders is “magical.” It’s a governance challenge, not a religious one. People cross borders out of poverty or instability — not ideology.

Blaming Indian Muslims for what foreigners do is illogical. Citizenship is a legal status, not a religious label. Holding 200 million citizens responsible for someone else’s actions replaces governance with prejudice.

Opposing NRC or CAA doesn’t mean supporting illegal immigration — it means demanding that laws stay fair, practical, and non-discriminatory. That’s democracy doing its job.

If every policy disagreement becomes a loyalty test, we stop being a democracy and start being a census of suspicion

That’s not democracy — that’s mob rule with better branding.

Democracy isn’t “might makes right.” It’s the opposite — it’s restraint by the strong so the weak don’t get crushed. The moment the majority stops being accountable to law, it stops being a majority and starts being a mob.

Elections give you power; the Constitution tells you how to use it. Scrap that, and you don’t get democracy — you get the illusion of strength right before a nation eats itself


Using examples like a victim wanting the death penalty versus a rapist’s preference as if both are equally valid isn’t philosophy — it’s absurd. Justice isn’t measured by who feels wronged or who succeeds; it’s defined by rules that protect everyone equally.

And pointing to Pakistan to justify bias in India isn’t logic — it’s rationalizing racism. Just because something exists elsewhere doesn’t make it acceptable here. Cherry-picking examples to claim discrimination is “subjective” masks your real argument: personal prejudice dressed up as reasoning.

India’s Constitution exists precisely to prevent personal or communal bias from shaping policy. Your argument only proves why that protection is needed.
Article 368 has limitations. You cannot amend the basic structure.

Basic structure wasn't defined by those wrote the constitution but by judges of Supreme who came later.

This debate is futile.

I realized it's pointless to debate with Sangh Bhaktas. They think the Sangh follows Dharma. They want to ignore many crucial facts. Like how the BJP government came up with the many schemes for Muslim, how they awarded most Scholarships to Muslims students, how more than 50 p.c. of the general schemes beneficiaries end up being Muslims.

How BJP forced 5th wave feminism on Hindus. Hindu males end up in jails on fake charges. Hindu families are being destroyed systematically.

While giving a free hand to Muslims to continue their patriarchal culture.

Bhakts don't want to admit the above facts.

I think you are an elite Hindu liberal or a Muslim with Indian citizenship. Like the bhakts, these types have their strong biases too. No offence. I could be wrong.
 
they have to do aarti and other pooja paat participation for the bare minimum.
I don't know much about India's underworld and right wing politics, or the connection between the two, but I think the 'Khans' have the patronage of Mumbai underworld and possibly of Shiv Sena's. I heard long time ago that Salman Khan had a rapport with Bal Thackeray. Also, they might be available for entertaining BJP goons on demand. So, they are probably protected and play monkey to further ensure they remain protected.

This is an extreme view and I might be wrong.
 
Article 368 has limitations. You cannot amend the basic structure.

Basic structure wasn't defined by those wrote the constitution but by judges of Supreme who came later.

This debate is futile.

I realized it's pointless to debate with Sangh Bhaktas. They think the Sangh follows Dharma. They want to ignore many crucial facts. Like how the BJP government came up with the many schemes for Muslim, how they awarded most Scholarships to Muslims students, how more than 50 p.c. of the general schemes beneficiaries end up being Muslims.

How BJP forced 5th wave feminism on Hindus. Hindu males end up in jails on fake charges. Hindu families are being destroyed systematically.

While giving a free hand to Muslims to continue their patriarchal culture.

Bhakts don't want to admit the above facts.

I think you are an elite Hindu liberal or a Muslim with Indian citizenship. Like the bhakts, these types have their strong biases too. No offence. I could be wrong.
Article 368 does have limits — that’s the point. The “basic structure” doctrine was defined by the Supreme Court because no Constitution can foresee every abuse of power. It exists to stop any government — of any party — from rewriting the core of India’s democracy in the name of majority will. That’s not elitism; that’s checks and balances.

It’s completely fine for us to see things differently — disagreement is part of debate. But I’d rather we focus on the ideas themselves instead of making assumptions about who’s saying them. That’s the only way conversations like this can actually move forward
 
Here we have it dear fellow forum goers.

The hatred is civilisational.

This sanghee filth simply cannot contain himself and sees fit to oblige us all with the deep festering historical loathing his kind has for Muslims, Mughals, and Pakistan.

Delhi and Kabul must have taken a severe battering this year that the usual Nehruvian mask of "secularism" has been discarded so willingly and visibly.

Let such posts stay as a stark reminder that we are dealing with an incorrigible people, one that will always link economic or societal "value" of a population to its ethnoreligious identity and nothing else, such that state sanctioned machinations might ensue that will create perpetual discord between various populations.

I applaud you for your vocal and visible honesty @AjitWadhwa while living amidst a veritable hive of those who would quietly urge you to remain faithful to the Nehruvian approach.

Ya - whatever, Indian members here have responded to claims of Ajit W. Why would you color an entire population because of a single person is beyond me. Do you have same bar for yourself/for Pakistan? I don't know how you guys get energy to hate so much, to try to propagate a narrative far removed from reality

When was the last time you said positive things about anyone...
 
Technically they are traitors. Traitors to filth, impurity, idolatry and falsehood.

Their ancestors abandoned the aforementioned and replaced it with Truth, purity and monotheism.

Alhomdillah
Sure.

They should have emigrated to the land of pure which they created. If they did what was expected of them, there would be no issues.

Indians wouldn't have made such statements.
 
Article 368 does have limits — that’s the point. The “basic structure” doctrine was defined by the Supreme Court because no Constitution can foresee every abuse of power. It exists to stop any government — of any party — from rewriting the core of India’s democracy in the name of majority will. That’s not elitism; that’s checks and balances.

It’s completely fine for us to see things differently — disagreement is part of debate. But I’d rather we focus on the ideas themselves instead of making assumptions about who’s saying them. That’s the only way conversations like this can actually move forward
I studied Indian polity. Academically.

Even if you speak to the top constitution experts of the country. Don't matter what political views they hold. They all will say that the constitution is ambiguous and complicated. Also the lengthiest. The common man can't ever decode the Indian constitution. Neither can top legal experts. Why did they create such a complicated constitution by ransacking other constitutions of other countries? They wanted federalism as well centralism. That's impossible. Hence the current mess
Most Indians were illiterate at that time. How would they expect them to understand the constitution?

American constitution is 4 pages long.

Do you think Mr Ambedkar was so naive that he deliberately didn't insert the secular word in the constitution?

Religious freedom is different from Secularism. Constitutions of Pakistan and Bangladesh grant religious freedom to minorities. But we know what happens on the ground.

Ambedkar didn't want any special rights for Muslims. His views on Islam and Muslims aren't state guarded secrets anymore. The Congress didn't let Ambedkar have his way wrt Muslims. To appease him, they let him bully Hindus (Hindu Code bill reforms).

In the defence of Congress, they never forced Muslims to stay in India. As some Muslims members in here think. They were free to emigrate to Pakistan but they didn't.

If they had, there would be peace in South Asia. India wouldn't have Kashmir. But that would be okay.

India Pakistan Bangladesh tensions are not related to just Kashmir or water sharing or land disputes

Huge Muslim population in India is an existential threat to both Pakistan and Bangladesh. Many of their enlightened citizens question Partition. What was the point of it? If Muslims stayed in India. Their numbers continued to grow very quickly.
 
Last edited:
Ya - whatever, Indian members here have responded to claims of Ajit W. Why would you color an entire population because of a single person is beyond me. Do you have same bar for yourself/for Pakistan? I don't know how you guys get energy to hate so much, to try to propagate a narrative far removed from reality

When was the last time you said positive things about anyone...
The poster I flagged up for extra scrutiny himself denies being a bhakt.

It is the typical Hindustani citizen's displacement on display.

"(I agree with the narrative that Muslims, as a group, have leeched off Indian society and were the cause of Pakistan's creation as well as the only - and ongoing - beneficiaries of it as well as an ungrateful group in general who should yield to the writ of the Hindu qom and deserve no legacy rights of their own historical efforts, but despite all those beliefs I hold dearly in my heart,) I do declare that am not a bhakt or a sanghee and I love Modi for his economic policies".

I do not in fact "colour any population because of a single person", rather your citizens are perfectly capable of explaining their own majoritarian populist opinions towards subcontinental Muslims without any assistance from me, as demonstrated ably by the poster in question.
 
Huge Muslim population in India is an existential threat to both Pakistan and Bangladesh. Many of their enlightened citizens question Partition. What was the point of it? If Muslims stayed in India. Their numbers continued to grow very quickly.
This is very much the crux of your continued blabbering eulogy.

No thank you.

We decided, generations ago, that our post-colonialism era legacy as native born muslims of the subcontinent was not assured under the rule of a Hindustani nation state. Due to the pre-independence era indoctrinations and revisionism by the likes of M.S.Gowalkar, the subcontinent's Muslims faced a threat of dalitisation and dissolution by the Hindu majority. That Congress even existed permitted the masking of RSS doctrine for a time, but Jinnah knew it would be temporary.

We are more than happy living in a nation state that safeguards the subcontinenental musulman, his legacy, his history, and his providence. To exist as an Indian Muslim renders us toothless, in spite of our history in this land that is our home.

You forget that we are not travellers or guests in this land, but rather, sons of this soil who made a choice generations earlier. Gowalkar disagreed with that choice and regarded us as the proverbial "other" because of it.

Delhi's deep state has certain specified roles for its Muslims to fulfil, and they willingly oblige. We see the Owais Asaduddin's, the Shah Rukh's, the Javed Akthar's, the Adbullah's of occupied Kashmir, all of whom busy themselves obsessing over varying degrees of false syncretism just to be accepted by Gowalkar's progeny. For all of them, there is a price to be paid in terms of their identity. Jinnah himself warned of this price, telling us generations ago that these Muslims would do everything they possibly could to serve hindutva but it would never amount to enough. Was he wrong?

It all serves as a stark reminder to us that 2 nation theory was fundamentally correct. A hindu qom is, by definition, an incorrigible one.

Much reflection is required by our eastern barhadari in due consideration of the underlying reasons for this incorrigibility.

The reflection should come from Gowalkar's proud progeny, bhakts etc most certainly, but even moreso from Congress aahm aadmi and those who "vote Modi for his economic policy alone", as those are the most deluded Indians of all.
 
This is very much the crux of your continued blabbering eulogy.

No thank you.

We decided, generations ago, that our post-colonialism era legacy as native born muslims of the subcontinent was not assured under the rule of a Hindustani nation state. Due to the pre-independence era indoctrinations and revisionism by the likes of M.S.Gowalkar, the subcontinent's Muslims faced a threat of dalitisation and dissolution by the Hindu majority. That Congress even existed permitted the masking of RSS doctrine for a time, but Jinnah knew it would be temporary.

We are more than happy living in a nation state that safeguards the subcontinenental musulman, his legacy, his history, and his providence. To exist as an Indian Muslim renders us toothless, in spite of our history in this land that is our home.

You forget that we are not travellers or guests in this land, but rather, sons of this soil who made a choice generations earlier. Gowalkar disagreed with that choice and regarded us as the proverbial "other" because of it.

Delhi's deep state has certain specified roles for its Muslims to fulfil, and they willingly oblige. We see the Owais Asaduddin's, the Shah Rukh's, the Javed Akthar's, the Adbullah's of occupied Kashmir, all of whom busy themselves obsessing over varying degrees of false syncretism just to be accepted by Gowalkar's progeny. For all of them, there is a price to be paid in terms of their identity. Jinnah himself warned of this price, telling us generations ago that these Muslims would do everything they possibly could to serve hindutva but it would never amount to enough. Was he wrong?

It all serves as a stark reminder to us that 2 nation theory was fundamentally correct. A hindu qom is, by definition, an incorrigible one.

Much reflection is required by our eastern barhadari in due consideration of the underlying reasons for this incorrigibility.

The reflection should come from Gowalkar's proud progeny, bhakts etc most certainly, but even moreso from Congress aahm aadmi and those who "vote Modi for his economic policy alone", as those are the most deluded Indians of all.
RSS had no influence in 1940s. It was irrelevant.

Socialist and Communist parties were powerful than the RSS.

Sharukh Khan, Jawed Khans and Owaisi would be nobodies in Pakistan. Hindus made them what they are today....

Jinnah was right. No one denies that. Tommy Robinson is right too.

Gandhi was suffering from a Stockholm Syndrome
 
RSS had no influence in 1940s. It was irrelevant.

Socialist and Communist parties were powerful than the RSS.

Sharukh Khan, Jawed Khans and Owaisi would be nobodies in Pakistan. Hindus made them what they are today....

Jinnah was right. No one denies that. Tommy Robinson is right too.

Gandhi was suffering from a Stockholm Syndrome
Disagree that RSS had no influence in the 1940s. Fundamentally so.

As for your Muslim artists succeeding in India but not in Pakistan - damn right. SRK, Salman, Javed Akhtar and the rest of them shamelessly pander to hindutva sentiments and are genuinely overrated as artists. I can guarantee you that such "sucking up" to perceived majority sentiments in lieu of genuine talent will not work with the more discerning and critical Pakistani audience. In fact, it only works as a career strategy in India because of the superficiality of thought of the average citizen. There is a reason Bollywood generates reams and reams of "work" every year - 99% of it is gutter trash but somehow appeals to fragile egos.

Mind you, the minute these "house muslims" step out of line, e.g. Salman wants to play the role of an Indian deity, as is very much his artistic licence in a supposedly secular nation state, all hell breaks loose. Gowalkar's progeny are continuing his legacy with gusto, despite your assertions that they are of little relevance in Indian societal discourse.


I have noted that you seem to forget you are on a Pakistani forum, where the audience you are preaching to knows the behavioural patterns of your citizenry only too well. Indeed, we have known you for generations. So you might need a different angle entirely if you wish to pull the wool over our eyes.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

  • Country Watch Latest

    Back
    Top