AjitWadhwa
Registered Member
As you admitted the Congress amended it many times. Destroying its essence. Especially when Indira Gandhi added the word secular to the preamble. Most legal experts agree that original Constitution allowed religious freedom. But it wasn't secular as in complete separation of state and religion. Indira did Muslim appeasement on steroids. Secularism was forcefully enforced on non Muslims. While Muslims were allowed to have their religious special laws.1. comparing the Constitution to partition politics is misleading. The Constitution wasn’t written to favor one community — it was written to protect every Indian equally. It has been amended over a hundred times, proving it’s not a rigid “asmani kitab,” but a living document that evolves with the nation’s values.
As you said decisions taken by the past generation shouldnt be forced on the present generation. If the present generation wants to bring a new constitution, there is nothing wrong with that. That's democratic. Majority decide.
Are you denying that Muslims demanded a separate country and the non Muslims (majority of them) didn't..2. Blaming one community for the Partition ignores historical nuance. The Muslim League led that demand, but millions of Muslims — especially in what became India — opposed Partition and chose to stay in a secular India. They didn’t “gain” from it; they faced suspicion and hardship for decades.
How they gained from it is mentioned in previous post? Minor discrimination is present. No one denies it.
But we have almost 60 y.o Muslim actors having an onscreen romantic relationship with 20-25 year old hindu actresses. This wouldn't happen if they face such severe hardship as people claim.
No is denying that Muslims suffered losses too.3. The suffering of Hindus and Sikhs during Partition was immense and undeniable, but pain was on both sides. Millions of Muslims were also killed, displaced, and left destitute when they migrated to Pakistan.
But you can't compare the pain of a guy guy who lost 100 rupees to the pain of a guy who lost 1 rupee and took the 100 rupees which belonged to the former guy.
Do you think a government of developing country can magically seal the porous border and stop Muslims from other sides entering?4. Pointing to refugee crises or illegal immigration today doesn’t justify discrimination. Those are governance issues, not grounds for collective blame. Citizenship and equality under the Constitution are about individual rights, not inherited guilt from 1947.
Even superpower US can't do that.
The question is why do neighbouring Muslims who support 2 nation theory are illegally immigrating to India in such huge numbers? Why do Indian Muslims support that? Are you going to deny that Indian Muslims say that there is no illegal Muslim immigration to India and oppose NRC CAA.
Democracy is of the majority. If we don't like that. We should scrap elections.Saying “the majority doesn’t have to abide by an unfair Constitution” is exactly what undermines democracy. The Constitution is what ensures that majorities don’t trample minorities. Rejecting it because it protects everyone equally isn’t strength — it’s regression.
Injustice is subjective too. In India, a Muslim can become a PM.So, yes — we should learn from the past, but not weaponize it to justify new injustices
In Pakistan, a Hindu or a Sikh cannot. Most Pakistani Muslims don't see this as an injustice.
Family of a murder-rape victim think that death penalty is fair.
Rapist thinks it's too harsh. He should have been given a few years in a prison.
Last edited:



