BJP Labels All Muslims in India As Traitors

Is it off topic?

BJP leader called Indian Muslims 'Namak Haram' for this very reason. Because they supported Muslim League, religious separation and created Pakistan.

I did not start the discussion. I am just posting some facts. Ironically which a Pakistani forum member asked me to do.


It's the other way around.

Large portion who supported Jinnah stayed back.

To prove my point I will post a speech made by a top Congress leader who explicitly says that most Indian Muslims who created Pakistan stayed back in India.






Was Sardar Vallabhai Patel misinformed or a bigot? @Vapnope

You've missing the point in its entirety, for argument's sake, let us accept at face value that those who voted for a seperate nation state stayed back

How would this be of relevance today or the topic under discussion?
 
Sure - there are structural inequalities but not just by religion or caste but a lot due to economic, regional and cultural differences. The way I look at it is that are differences getting more pronounced or the gap is filling up. I believe that later is true.

E.g., affirmative action in admissions, jobs, most other places. I am a "member" of a "general" class who had to be in top 1% to get admission. While SC/ST candidates with similar economic resources (not all but many) only had to score 30%-40% of what I scored to get in. Also, folks who get affirmative action once (in their family) continue to avail such benefits so the gap becomes harder to fill - even though with best intentions.

As I opined earlier, when I am recruiting, availing services, interacting with folks, I am doing from a merit basis (merit of candidate, argument etc.). That is what I can do from my vantage point, government is doing what it can. Does every Indian citizen in privileged class do the same - I am not sure.

Lastly, the largest discrepancy is economical. A rich Dalit, supresses other Dalits/Hindus. Same for Muslims, Hindus, any religion, community etc. People in "power" are taking advantage of the "system" across all lines...

That is India - far from perfect, chaotic but still progressing, growing at a rapid place, reforming, challenging cultural norms (for good and bad)
You my sir maybe a saint in real life and this must be true for many Indians like you, however, remember you asked about one policy that is indiscriminating and i quoted two and now you are saying generic things that don't change the facts that there are structural inequalities and there are inequalities even from the laws perspective.

You know an ahmadi was an air chief marshal? Does it change anything wrt to ahmadis in general? No it doesn't.
 
Is it off topic?

BJP leader called Indian Muslims 'Namak Haram' for this very reason. Because they supported Muslim League, religious separation and created Pakistan.

I did not start the discussion. I am just posting some facts. Ironically which a Pakistani forum member asked me to do.


It's the other way around.

Large portion who supported Jinnah stayed back.

To prove my point I will post a speech made by a top Congress leader who explicitly says that most Indian Muslims who created Pakistan stayed back in India.






Was Sardar Vallabhai Patel misinformed or a bigot? @Vapnope

Abdul kalam voted for Pakistan and is namak haram?
 
I already posted 1946 elections results.

Now let's go little back.

Early Period (1906–1936)​


  • The All-India Muslim League (AIML) was founded in Dhaka (now Bangladesh) in 1906.
  • During this time, it had very limited popular support, especially outside elite Muslim circles.
  • The League was stronger in minority-Muslim provinces — such as:
    • United Provinces (U.P.)
    • Bihar
    • Bombay
    • Madras
  • These areas are all in present-day India.

Turning Point — 1937 Elections​


  • In the 1937 provincial elections, the Muslim League performed poorly:
    • Won only 109 of 482 Muslim seats across India.
    • Almost no success in Punjab, Bengal, or NWFP — which would later form Pakistan’s core.
  • Muslims in those provinces supported regional parties:
    • Unionist Party (Punjab)
    • Krishak Praja Party (Bengal)
    • Congress and Frontier Party (NWFP)
That proves nothing to be honest. There are muslims who voted BJP, does that mean they want a hindu rashtra too?
 
You my sir maybe a saint in real life and this must be true for many Indians like you, however, remember you asked about one policy that is indiscriminating and i quoted two and now you are saying generic things that don't change the facts that there are structural inequalities and there are inequalities even from the laws perspective.

You know an ahmadi was an air chief marshal? Does it change anything wrt to ahmadis in general? No it doesn't.

I thought I already replied for the two specific instances (to MasterChief who had raised the same questions). Here is a brief response:

1. CAA - nothing to do with religion, it does have disproptionate impact for Muslims and there were rampant protests but there is nothing in law which is related to religion
2. Head scraf - a local issues (non-issue). Its private, limited premises nothing to do with state/central govt legislation

Sometimes we blow things out of propotion, for e.g., there is ban on women in Sabrimala temple as there is on men in a temple in Assam. People can see that as anti-woman. I don't because it is only limited to a single place of worship and there is a "logic" to the ban. Similarly, in Mumbai there was a case where Muslim women were not allowed in Sanctum Santorum, which is again fine as long as its at 1-2 places and takes context in account.

What I mentioned (inequalities) are bigger drivers of quality of life in India vs. religion. I firmly stand by that and my 28 yrs of living in the country gives me sufficient evidence to back it up. I don't think its any different in Pakistan or other developing economies.
 
1. CAA - nothing to do with religion, it does have disproptionate impact for Muslims and there were rampant protests but there is nothing in law which is related to religion
2. Head scraf - a local issues (non-issue). Its private, limited premises nothing to do with state/central govt legislation
Again, what you say does not change what Human right organizations are saying. Both explicitly are directed at muslims, i mentioned sikh for this specific reason as well.
 
Again, what you say does not change what Human right organizations are saying. Both explicitly are directed at muslims, i mentioned sikh for this specific reason as well.

Sure - people/org are free to derive their own conclusions. Afterall, many people/orgs/govts still support Israel's actions in Palestine. For some, its genocide and against a particular religion for others is self-defense.

In the specific CAA case, is there any language in the law itself which is against Indian Muslims? Don't think so. One aspect of the law that's debatable is certainly non-Muslims who migrated to India before 2014 but even the staunchest critics know that the number and % of non-muslims in the neighboring countries (Afg, Pak, BD) is very small.
 
Sure - people/org are free to derive their own conclusions. Afterall, many people/orgs/govts still support Israel's actions in Palestine. For some, its genocide and against a particular religion for others is self-defense.
Its not some org or people it is human right watch (HRW) i hope i dont need to tell you what it is. And no human right organization calls israeli actions as defense. You are diverging.
 
In the specific CAA case, is there any language in the law itself which is against Indian Muslims? Don't think so. One aspect of the law that's debatable is certainly non-Muslims who migrated to India before 2014 but even the staunchest critics know that the number and % of non-muslims in the neighboring countries (Afg, Pak, BD) is very small.
Took It from an AI search engine.
  1. The Specific Clause: The core provision of the CAA amends the Citizenship Act, 1955, to state that any person belonging to the Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi or Christian community from Afghanistan, Bangladesh or Pakistan who entered India on or before December 31, 2014, shall not be treated as an "illegal migrant."
  1. The Effect of Exclusion:
    • By naming only these six non-Muslim religious groups, the law effectively excludes Muslims from the fast-track path to Indian citizenship based on the claim of religious persecution from those three neighboring countries.
 
Took It from an AI search engine.
  1. The Specific Clause: The core provision of the CAA amends the Citizenship Act, 1955, to state that any person belonging to the Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi or Christian community from Afghanistan, Bangladesh or Pakistan who entered India on or before December 31, 2014, shall not be treated as an "illegal migrant."
  1. The Effect of Exclusion:
    • By naming only these six non-Muslim religious groups, the law effectively excludes Muslims from the fast-track path to Indian citizenship based on the claim of religious persecution from those three neighboring countries.
`
1. Yes, so the whole sentiment behind the bill is: Non Muslims have faced persecution in neighboring countries and sought refuge in India (and you can check the numbers, they are miniscule). So anyone inside before 2014, will be a citizen - you know how many Hindus, Jains, Sikhs etc are in the Muslim dominated neighborhood so in effect its a few thousand people maybe

2. Then it doesn't say that Muslims before 2014 who have migrated from neighboring countries can't be Indian citizens/go through the process, it doesn't grant that right automatically. The rationale is that the Muslims have migrated for economic reasons, not religious persecution.

3. Then it lays down a framework for any citizen requests (regardless of religion) for anyone entering India post 2014

The argument in #2 is not far from what US and many other countries are doing i.e., people who are migrating for pure economic reasons and not to seek refuge from govts/other groups will not be considered aliens/granted citizenship outright.
 
Some? Which ones exactly?

Some communities like Siddi community and other first inhabitants of the region.

Many nations like Sikhs, Maratha and Tamilians are also finding it genocidal, the imposition of Hindi and Indian identity.
 
You've missing the point in its entirety, for argument's sake, let us accept at face value that those who voted for a seperate nation state stayed back

How would this be of relevance today or the topic under discussion?
It might not be of relevance to you and many others.

But it bothers many Indians.

These Indians feel that Muslims should have left India for Pakistan. Why did they create it in the first place if they didn't to emigrate to their Islamic republic? Direct Action Day wasn't a non violent moment.

And these Muslims who stayed back in secular India, ironically demanded special religious rights for themselves.

Many Indians view them as betrayers and Traitors. Hence the Namak Haram jibe

Others might not.

That proves nothing to be honest. There are muslims who voted BJP, does that mean they want a hindu rashtra too?

your argument doesnt hold any weight

Muslim league contested 1946 elections with Creation of Pakistan as their main agenda. 98 percent of Indian Muslims voted for it.

Muslim vote share of BJP is very low. If the BJP fields a Muslim candidate, it gets some Muslim votes.

BJP never contested elections on creating a Hindu Rashtra till now.
 
Last edited:
It might not be of relevance to you and many others.

But it bothers many Indians.

These Indians feel that Muslims should have left India for Pakistan. Why did they create it in the first place if they didn't to emigrate to their Islamic republic? Direct Action Day wasn't a non violent moment.

And these Muslims who stayed back in secular India, ironically demanded special religious rights for themselves.

Many Indians view them as betrayers and Traitors. Hence the Namak Haram jibe

Others might not.
For arguments sake, let us accept these points, they would still only be applicable to voters of that era

What agency does this line of reasoning have on current crop of Indian muslims, do they inherit the traitorship or as the constitution says, are considered Indian citizens
 
For arguments sake, let us accept these points, they would still only be applicable to voters of that era

What agency does this line of reasoning have on current crop of Indian muslims, do they inherit the traitorship or as the constitution says, are considered Indian citizens
You are asking me to take you down the rabbit hole.

We both know such discussion isn't possible on this forum.

A neutral western forum would be for suited for it.
 
State authorities in India have implemented laws and policies which clearly discriminate against Muslims, including the anti-conversion law, bans on wearing headscarves in school and the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA), all of which have existed for many years now. More recently there have been "love jihad" legislations and moves to dissolve waqf ownership rights.
Conversion through force influence like money are all illegal in India. It is not a new law. Even relationship with false promises of marriage is a crime. These laws are created so that women don't get cheated into a relationship and Indian laws are heavily biased when it comes to women's rights.

Private institutions can frame their own rules. Headscarfs or Hijab ban is mostly followed in schools who are particular about uniform rules. For example the school I went, St. Teresa Public School had a rule that won't allow any religious symbols in school, like lockets of Hindu gods, kalwa or wrist band, not even gold ornaments. Muslim students are not allowed towear Hijab or headscarf, or scullcap. They however had Catholic sisters with full headscarfs or Christian priests with their gown. Private institutions and private rules. You don't like it, go to a school that allows it.

CAA is a law that gives fast-track citizenship to minority communities from neighbouring states. Another law which existed after independence. Particularly important right now given the number of illegal BD Muslims who have no excuse to be in India illegally.

Waqf ownership rights are not reduced or repealed. Waqf claims based on bullshit and ownership of land without proper documentation became hard. So you can't go around owning lands of someone else.
Stop hunting headlines, India has around the same number of Muslims as Pakistan they are not oppressed, depressed, benchpressed. Most importantly they are generally safe than they were in either of those countries. No blasts in their mosques, no military opression, no Muslim soldiers get randomly bombed while traveling in their APCs because they passed through the wrong tribal area.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top