hyperman
INT'L MOD
Just because Russians invested heavily in AD capabilities since WW2 out of their doctrinal neccessity doesn't make them better at making superior AD system.
Russian electronics are decades behind that of what west has. In fact they used to use lots of COTS electronics in their AD systems from Western civilian manufacturers. (Now being replaced by Chinese components.)
In Ukraine Russia Ukraine is the weaker party. The best striking system they have is ATACMs. On the other hand Russia has more capable deep strike capabilities. Both in terms of technology and volume. Kiznal, Iskander, P-800, etc and of course a big air force. Yet the destruction of S400s and S300s are greater in numbers than destruction of Patriots and SAMP/T or IRIS-T SLM in the battlefield just going by the visual evidences available.
France didn't supply Ukraine with SAMP/T NG yet. It was the older version. Neither did US supplied LTAMDS and IBCS. It was older variant of patriot batteries.
Russian despite having invested heavily in AD as their primary defense, couldn't develop hit to kill tactical interceptors like Western PAC-3 or Aster 30. They are yet to field an AESA MFR with S400. Just like Russians couldn't put APG-81 like radar on their fighter, they can't make GaN based next gen AESA like LTAMDS, GroundFire and EL/M2084 yet.
In fact, Aselsan developed SIPER with its GaN based AKREP-1000G and ALP-310 AESA systems has more advanced sensor architecture than that of S400.
I can bet Block 2 interceptor is also better than anything russians fields in the same range.
No AD is foolproof, yet second tier Western AD systems perform better than Russian ones in Ukraine given the volume and variety of sophisticated russian systems it faced compared to what Ukraine threw at Russian AD systems.
Far more has gotten through Ukrainian air defense than Russian Air Defense, despite Russian air defense being more spread out and covering larger areas and gaps. Ukraine has been able to saturate Kiev and it covers most of the country, this is not the case with Russia.
You cannot compare Soviet Era S-300s with S-400s and its performance.







