It's in international waters. There was also a similar incident in 2011, so given the reported circumstances and the previous incident, there are certainly questions about the Pakistani Navy's professionalism. Still, we'd need video evidence, similar to what was available in 2011. That would help clear up many of the doubts about what actually happened.
If you ask me, internationally, I don't think people would trust the statements coming from either side. That's why independent evidence, especially video or other verifiable data, would be helpful... Waiting for the same.
Likely if someone recorded from the Indian side, after the opreational deployed completed and returned, someone might upload.