Hardline Rabbi Says Israeli Jews Should Support Pakistan over India in a War

[Rattle Snake]

This whole trivialising of wars where millions of lives are in question is quite hateful.

In India they have a whole music industry dedicated to the hate genre.

I believe these videos of Pakistanis making hateful comments about Hindus and Hinduism should be publicised even more widely in India so that people can understand Pakistan better. This would create greater awareness of Pakistani society and its prevailing mindset, which I think is currently lacking in India.

The Pakistani in the video also said that he is a proud Wahhabi. I remember a recent song released by Iran in which they said "Takfiri o Wahhabi o Daesh shode hamdast." (Takfiris, Wahhabis and Daesh have formed an alliance).

 

[El Sidd]

I believe these videos of Pakistanis making hateful comments about Hindus and Hinduism should be publicised even more widely in India so that people can understand Pakistan better. This would create greater awareness of Pakistani society and its prevailing mindset, which I think is currently lacking in India.

The Pakistani in the video also said that he is a proud Wahhabi. I remember a recent song released by Iran in which they said "Takfiri o Wahhabi o Daesh shode hamdast." (Takfiris, Wahhabis and Daesh have formed an alliance).

Strict media control by Indian state hampers such initiatives.

 

[mnztr]

The reason they support Pakistan is the same reason Christian Evangelicals support Israel. And its NOT because they love them

 

[lightning f57]

I think you are deliberately overlooking the bigger picture. If his argument is purely theological and aligns with Islamic principles, then why is he specifically expressing support for Pakistan and not Iran or other Muslim-majority countries?

You cannot conveniently separate his theological argument from its political implications, especially when he explicitly identifies Pakistan as an ally. Furthermore, calling Israel an ethno-nationalist state does not change the fact that religious and political interests often overlap. The question is not whether Judaism and Islam share certain theological principles; the question is why an Israeli Jewish rabbi is singling out Pakistan as an ally and what political message that sends.

The question your asking his already answered in his video.

His saying India you can argue is Israels best Ally overall, and if you go with that train of thought his then looking at Pakistan that is Indias greatest enemy, not Iran or any other Muslim country. So then his comparing a very close ally with a state which is close enemy, then he makes the theological argument.

I really am baffled how you dont get that. His not talking politics his talking religious theological point.

Also Israel is an ethno nationalist state thats why its allied with India, otherwise theologically and ideologically from a Judaism lens as that's what his using India - Hinduism are polar opposites to a Israel run by pure Judaism principles.

 

[Master Chief]

I think you are deliberately overlooking the bigger picture. If his argument is purely theological and aligns with Islamic principles, then why is he specifically expressing support for Pakistan and not Iran or other Muslim-majority countries?

He is making a point by picking Pakistan. Yes, the same applies to Iran. If Iran and India went to war, he and any religious Jews would choose Iran. The argument is explicitly made because Hindus are idolatrous in his scripture. Not only are you idolatrous, you are also an idiot that you fail to understand the rabbbi's argument.

 

[Master Chief]

The question your asking his already answered in his video.

His saying India you can argue is Israels best Ally overall, and if you go with that train of thought his then looking at Pakistan that is Indias greatest enemy, not Iran or any other Muslim country. So then his comparing a very close ally with a state which is close enemy, then he makes the theological argument.

I really am baffled how you dont get that. His not talking politics his talking religious theological point.

Also Israel is an ethno nationalist state thats why its allied with India, otherwise theologically and ideologically from a Judaism lens as that's what his using India - Hinduism are polar opposites to a Israel run by pure Judaism principles.

Sir, he really doesn't understand basic English rhetoric. In fact, he is illustrating the rabbi's point that ingesting urine can have a harmful impact on health.

 

[Master Chief]

The reason they support Pakistan is the same reason Christian Evangelicals support Israel. And its NOT because they love them

And you think Pakistanis actually want Israelis to like them?

 

[mnztr]

And you think Pakistanis actually want Israelis to like them?

I don't think most people want that. Maybe the whores in the UAE.

 

[Rattle Snake]

The reason they support Pakistan is the same reason Christian Evangelicals support Israel. And its NOT because they love them

The question your asking his already answered in his video.

His saying India you can argue is Israels best Ally overall, and if you go with that train of thought his then looking at Pakistan that is Indias greatest enemy, not Iran or any other Muslim country. So then his comparing a very close ally with a state which is close enemy, then he makes the theological argument.

I really am baffled how you dont get that. His not talking politics his talking religious theological point.

Also Israel is an ethno nationalist state thats why its allied with India, otherwise theologically and ideologically from a Judaism lens as that's what his using India - Hinduism are polar opposites to a Israel run by pure Judaism principles.

He is making a point by picking Pakistan. Yes, the same applies to Iran. If Iran and India went to war, he and any religious Jews would choose Iran. The argument is explicitly made because Hindus are idolatrous in his scripture. Not only are you idolatrous, you are also an idiot that you fail to understand the rabbbi's argument.

Listen to Dr. Foad Izadi, a professor at the University of Tehran and an official spokesperson for the Iranian government and the IRGC, who has described Pakistan’s Chief of Defence Forces as an “American spy” and accused him of visiting Iran to gather intelligence for the CIA.

 

[Maira La]

If his argument is purely theological and aligns with Islamic principles, then why is he specifically expressing support for Pakistan and not Iran or other Muslim-majority countries?

When it's about Jews vs Shia, he obviously supports his own people because (in his view) they are God's chosen Monotheists vs Goy Monotheists (Muslims).

And when it's Pakistan vs India, he prefers the Goy Monotheists (Muslims) over the 'Idolators'. According to this Rabbi, all idolators deserve death (he refers to the Torah).

 

[I*R*A]

then why is he specifically expressing support for Pakistan and not Iran or other Muslim-majority countries?

Pakistan is the only Muslim country that has fought direct wars with hindutva india. Possesses nuclear weapons pointed at and for india only.

Pakistani majority believe in ALLAH, the one and only Creator and sovereign. Whereas majority india believes in countless gods. This is where Judaism and Islam align and Rabbi is simply stating that, per his religion, he cannot side with people who believe in and worship countless gods.

iran has civilizational ties with you, in fact the cow worship may have been influenced by those ancient historical ties

"Ancient Indo-Iranians (ancestors of both early Vedic Aryans and ancient Iranians) held cattle in high esteem as symbols of wealth, purity, and ritual life. Early texts from both traditions viewed the cow and bull with deep reverence"

 

[vasanthm]

Pakistani majority believe in ALLAH, the one and only Creator and sovereign. Whereas majority india believes in countless gods. This is where Judaism and Islam align and Rabbi is simply stating that, per his religion, he cannot side with people who believe in and worship countless gods.

what abt ppl like me who worship a single god like the Flying Spaghetti Monster?