Israel’s Genocide in Gaza | 2023- till present

Status
Not open for further replies.
They can not and those systems are siting ducks without air fighters to fend off SEAD missions.

Right.
There are weapons being manufactured in Syria and then shipped to Lebanon. But Israelis manage to destroy even smaller transport vehicles into Lebanon.
Nothing short of Russian-manned anti-aircraft systems deployed in various places in Lebanon will do the job. But we know that is not happening, at least not right now.
 
So its quite clear that HZ cannot deter Israeli terrorism against Lebanon

It's time for the people of Lebanon to throw out this foreign state within state proxy and build an actual military force that can actually deter Israel from violence

May be like Egypt.
Hezbollah does not have the capacity to engage in open war with Israel. If they try the conventional way, they will lose catastrophically. Their best way to avoid defeat is to avoid open conventional combat and pursue a strategy of resistance, inflicting losses and wearing down the Israeli army.
 
This is not a question of bias but international law.

While it is true that other armies have killed civilians, they usually write them off as collateral damage or claim that they were terrorists. Those claims may be nonsense but, at least, they use that excuse to shrug off the civilian deaths.

What Israel did was indiscriminate targeting. They had no way of knowing if the person holding the pager was someone's child or even a reservist. It is illegal under international law to target reservists. This is the same as if someone rigged mobile phones to blow up if somone received a call from the Israeli ministry of defence. The person answering the call could be a reservist or someone's child.

What Israel did was a war crime, plain and simple.



This is what Israel wants and it rewards Israel for its brutality. It may be the short term solution but there is no way that Israel as a military colonial outpost can be allowed to get away with it. The Nazis were held to account decades later. Israel's turn will come.
I agree that this incident is a matter of concern and indicates a terrifying attack vector. There should be debate about rules of war or how to end war before it gets more ugly. Mossad manipulated a particular batch of pagers that it was sure that Hezbollah will use. However, the nature of attack is such that it will not distinguish between innocent and fighters. I am cool with how you perceive this attack but I don't think Russian barrel bombing tactics distinguish between civilian and fighters either. To me, both kill indiscriminately in pursuit of goals. Gone are the days when battles were fought in open grounds away from population centers. Now everything goes. Iss humam main sab nangay hain.

When it gets really bad in a particular place, do you stay there? When Holy Prophet PBUH and his companions faced significant threats in Mecca, they migrated to Medina. So whatever happened to our common sense and humanitarian considerations? WE don't know how this war will conclude but we can do something about the innocent and particularly children by offering them shelter and opportunities to live normally. This is better than letting Israel crush all at some point.
 
Hezbollah does not have the capacity to engage in open war with Israel. If they try the conventional way, they will lose catastrophically. Their best way to avoid defeat is to avoid open conventional combat and pursue a strategy of resistance, inflicting losses and wearing down the Israeli army.
What's the alternative,, allow a rabid apartheid colonial State to endlessly force brutality and occupation upon the people???

Or you endlessly harass the entity, target it across the world, use laws, boycott, protest to keep it in a constant state of conflict and let demographics do its job
 
You’re really given no choice in the matter. If you want to use computers you have to agree to let them collect and use your private data. Almost no one actually reads the privacy agreement.

Sometimes they don’t even tell you what they’re doing. A while ago I upgraded to Windows 11. After several months of using it I found that all my private data, eg. the Documents folder, was automatically being uploaded to Microsoft OneDrive. My local drive didn’t even have a copy of my Documents folder, it was all uploaded to Microsoft’s servers. I’m an experienced computer user and I still didn’t know what they were doing. I wasn’t told this was happening and wasn’t given the choice to opt out. They just transferred all my files to their own servers and that’s the default. Probably 99% of users don’t know it.
I remove Google activity data or refuse some data collection requests. However, a web user cannot be a ghost all the time. I never felt the need to because I am a normal citizen. I might reconsider my approach but Pakistani networks are shit anyways.

Cloud storage is now common. So make sure to store important files in another disk. Nevertheless, those who come to investigate will literally want to check one's items so who is safe? God help us all, my dear.
 
I agree that this incident is a matter of concern and indicates a terrifying attack vector. There should be debate about rules of war or how to end war before it gets more ugly. Mossad manipulated a particular batch of pagers that it was sure that Hezbollah will use. However, the nature of attack is such that it will not distinguish between innocent and fighters. I am cool with how you perceive this attack but I don't think Russian barrel bombing tactics distinguish between civilian and fighters either. To me, both kill indiscriminately in pursuit of goals. Gone are the days when battles were fought in open grounds away from population centers. Now everything goes. Iss humam main sab nangay hain.

When it gets really bad in a particular place, do you stay there? When Holy Prophet PBUH and his companions faced significant threats in Mecca, they migrated to Medina. So whatever happened to our common sense and humanitarian considerations? WE don't know how this war will conclude but we can do something about the innocent and particularly children by offering them shelter and opportunities to live normally. This is better than letting Israel crush all at some point.

I know many Syrian refugees tried to flee to Europe.

For Gazans, there isn't much option sadly. It is like a prison. Israel's tactics in Gaza are expensive and impractical in my view. Given Mossad's competence, they could have just toppled Hamas and allowed Fatah in (after talks) without a single bullet. That way an independent Palestinian state could finally be in the map.

Today, the current Israeli government appears to be dominated by settlers. They are not interested in a Palestinian state and would rather opt for a sea view in Gaza. This partly explains the bloody nature of the war.
 
I know many Syrian refugees tried to flee to Europe.

For Gazans, there isn't much option sadly. It is like a prison. Israel's tactics in Gaza are expensive and impractical in my view. Given Mossad's competence, they could have just toppled Hamas and allowed Fatah in (after talks) without a single bullet. That way an independent Palestinian state could finally be in the map.

Today, the current Israeli government appears to be dominated by settlers. They are not interested in a Palestinian state and would rather opt for a sea view in Gaza. This partly explains the bloody nature of the war.
I have humanitarian personality. If I ever had the means or resources, I would have offered Palestinian non-combatants including women and children shelter and the option to live a normal life with permission of relevant authorities (legal channels). I read stories of war and I fully understand how terrifying it is. So this is my personal view and some can disagree with it but humanity is in my soul. The state is in the best position to help though. Better than private channels. God bless or reduce pain of innocent and underpriviledged.
 
Last edited:
What's the alternative,, allow a rabid apartheid colonial State to endlessly force brutality and occupation upon the people???

Or you endlessly harass the entity, target it across the world, use laws, boycott, protest to keep it in a constant state of conflict and let demographics do its job

I don't understand why people get into breast-beating and defeatism over the deaths of a few thousand Hezbollah fighters and a few dozen commanders. I don't think Hezbollah has lost too much. Plus there are reportedly hundreds of thousands of fighters from Yemen, Iraq and even as far as Pakistan and Afghanistan ready to join a regional war if that happens. In 2006, Hezbollah suffered even more casualties but is widely thought of as having 'won'. Yes, they have suffered recent setbacks; but they will regroup, change strategies and resume bleeding Israel. They win by not losing. Israel loses but not having a total victory; and Israel needs the total victory asap. Remember the old Afghan Taliban saying about Watch and Time.

All Israel and its allies have is sabotage and aerial bombardment. They are not substitute for ground invasion and occupation. American firepower--which was much more powerful in early 2000s--could not tame the resistance in Iraq and so the ground forces had to go into places like Fallujah.
 
It seems to me that Hezbollah ain't any worse than Iranians?
But anyway, let's not dream the dreams here. Isreal run this show completely from day 1.
And us here or unfortunately those who are in command can't even guess what's coming. Oh yes , I believe that Shin Bet had prior knowledge of 7th October. But I have to give credit to Hamas , they showed themselves magnificently.
Maybe I might sound silly but when I see those faces of Hezbollah or Iranians, none of them look like the soldiers or particularly intelligent people
They look like Sawarma joint owners. Even their body language is like that.
Anything that they say and the way they carry themselves, doesnt inspires any confidence
 
Hezbollah is not stupid and neither is the resistance

They won’t fall for the Israeli trap and go to war

They have survived before and will survive again
I think you're coward but idk yet if Hezbollah is. There's no trap or trying to draw into war. They're doing a war on Lebanon since few days ago and every day there are hundreds of strikes.

Today so far over 100 airstrikes. Meanwhile the weapons in stores are just rotting or being destroyed. While ground invasion may be on the way. So you amass 150,000 rockets so they can rot while your enemy destroys you, doesn't make any sense unless cowards like you and Meengla are decision makers in Hezbollah.
 
So its quite clear that HZ cannot deter Israeli terrorism against Lebanon

It's time for the people of Lebanon to throw out this foreign state within state proxy and build an actual military force that can actually deter Israel from violence

May be like Egypt.
That wont work as no countries especially western will provide any decent arms to protect Israel. Also Lebanon is in an economic crisis and probably have little ability to pay add to the fact there is still some division internally, not everyone backs Hezbollah. This is likely a factor helping israel with intelligence.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
They can not and those systems are siting ducks without air fighters to fend off SEAD missions.


These systems are more effective when not used, with the enemy not knowing how good or bad they are and just leaving them in areas to deny airspace because the fact that AA systems are there is enough to deter the enemy.
 
@Mehmed Beg

I guess strategy is to allow Israel to destroy any anti-Israel capabilities and do nothing about it. But just keep their ones for local power/businesses and for internal business with Iran.

One thing you are wrong about is Israel did not about October 7. But otherwise agree with your assessment.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Back
Top