Pakistan-Af: Operation Khyber Storm

Status
Not open for further replies.
There are quite a few advocates of the Iranian approach to Afghanistan


The approach which is not so concerned with abstract ideas of brotherhood but more with tough love and enforcement of correct behavior
Tough love with Taliban? I have no idea about what you say, but as a matter of fact, millions of Afghans live in Iran. Pakistan does not have that many refugees in other countries but Afghanistan has.

So?
 
There are quite a few advocates of the Iranian approach to Afghanistan


The approach which is not so concerned with abstract ideas of brotherhood but more with tough love and enforcement of correct behavior

There will always be a few because vast majority of Pakistanis believe Iranian approach to Afghans is dehumanising and counterproductive.
 
Are you one of those individuals who believe that the Taliban is a Pakistani creation and somehow Pakistan has a god given right over Afghanistan or Pakistanis are their keepers?

No, I have no interest in their brand of Islam or sharia nor I am interested in who they are and where they came from. My interest is to humiliate them proper, that too because they showed aggression towards my country and killed my fellow countrymen and not that I hate them. They can meet Israeli PM all I care, but if any such meeting is planning against my country, then they deserve a counter response.

Ap log khailtay raho in kay sath madni madni bai.

Pakistanis would appreciate a sovereign independent Afghanistan which does not host anti Pakistan elements within striking distance. Otherwise whole of Europa and the rest is filled with anti Pakistani elements under guise of one argument or the other. I don't see Pakistani jets bombing Switzerland or the UK targeting known terrorists roamimg freely.

I will not want a military strong afghanistan. Stable or not is up to them. Pakistan should explore and keep the option of civil war alive.
 
No, I have no interest in their brand of Islam or sharia nor I am interested in who they are and where they came from. My interest is to humiliate them proper, that too because they showed aggression towards my country and killed my fellow countrymen and not that I hate them. They can meet Israeli PM all I care, but if any such meeting is planning against my country, then they deserve a counter response.

Ap log khailtay raho in kay sath madni madni bai.
We have responded. They have asked for ceasefire and mediation. It's time to talk the matter out.
I will not want a military strong afghanistan. Stable or not is up to them. Pakistan should explore and keep the option of civil war alive.
This is just insecure paranoia not prevalent in the Pakistani national psyche.
 
Seriously now we are stooping to the level where we are bragging about beating up the disabled kid in a wheelchair in the class?

Probably posted already, but this is from ISPR official.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.


Nothing wrong with showing auqaat to disabled kid who brag about beating superpowers. Pindi made this myth and Pindi will break it. Enjoye new normal.
 
We have responded. They have asked for ceasefire and mediation. It's time to talk the matter out.

Okay they asked for ceasefire, and you wish Pakistan to just bend over and accept it? Why?

There is no point in talking to them. Futile, waste of time. Humiliation is the proper answer for them.

This is just insecure paranoia not prevalent in the Pakistani national psyche.

I am more realistic than you then. I want respect for Pakistan shoved down their throats and up their rears by all possible means.

Answer me this, imagine if they had capable missiles, sows, proper strong air force, trained military .. what would have been the outcome of this misadventure from their side? Would Pakistan be able to afford such a situation (keep in mind friends of your afghan brothers in the East)?

Do not let them become militarily strong ever, it is an existential threat for Pakistan. If they do not show respect to Pakistan, create situation and reasons for civil war.
 
Okay they asked for ceasefire, and you wish Pakistan to just bend over and accept it? Why?

There is no point in talking to them. Futile, waste of time. Humiliation is the proper answer for them.
Pakistan should offer realistic terms for the ceasefire or make it conditional if objectives have not been resolved.
I am more realistic than you then. I want respect for Pakistan shoved down their throats and up their rears by all possible means.

Answer me this, imagine if they had capable missiles, sows, proper strong air force, trained military .. what would have been the outcome of this misadventure from their side? Would Pakistan be able to afford such a situation (keep in mind friends of your afghan brothers in the East)?

Do not let them become militarily strong ever, it is an existential threat for Pakistan. If they do not show respect to Pakistan, create situation and reasons for civil war.

There are no existential threats to Pakistan barring Indian water terrorism. Rest is all manageable by diplomacy.
 
We have responded. They have asked for ceasefire and mediation. It's time to talk the matter out.

This is just insecure paranoia not prevalent in the Pakistani national psyche.

Talking isn't the problem

They want to talk, trade, keep open borders
***WHILST*** supporting attacks on Pakistan and hosting TTP and BLA

That is not tolerable, so either they kill or control the TTP and BLA or let us do it

Useless talks are pointless if they can't agree
 
Talking isn't the problem

They want to talk, trade, keep open borders
***WHILST*** supporting attacks on Pakistan and hosting TTP and BLA

That is not tolerable, so either they kill or control the TTP and BLA or let us do it

Useless talks are pointless if they can't agree

You can condition these for ceasefire along with a simple statement that our war is with TTP and BLA and not Afghans or Afghanistan.

One of the 2 parties must become reasonable. We cannot waste ammunition on the west bank of Indus for too long.
 
You can condition these for ceasefire along with a simple statement that our war is with TTP and BLA and not Afghans or Afghanistan.

One of the 2 parties must become reasonable. We cannot waste ammunition on the west bank of Indus for too long.

What's unreasonable about wanting a end to TTP or BLA terrorism and the terrorists arrested or killed?

Why was the head of the TTP living in Kabul whilst he organised attacks against Pakistan?

Why are BLA allowed space to train and organise in Afghanistan???


Either the Afghans see sense, or we are entering into a long conflict in which they will suffer
 
Pakistan should offer realistic terms for the ceasefire or make it conditional if objectives have not been resolved.

What has Pakistan been doing for this long and before this conflict? You are making it look like Pakistan wanted to wage a war on them from the get go.

I think Pakistan should make it a mandatory policy to invite soldiers who have served and fought on this front to visit across Pakistan and instead molvis delivering useless Urdu sermons on Friday, let the gullible Pakistanis know what we are up against. I hope uss kay badh ap kay roshan khayalat aur in k liay jazbat may shayad kuch tabdeeli a jy gi.


There are no existential threats to Pakistan barring Indian water terrorism. Rest is all manageable by diplomacy.

Kiss dunia kay basi ho bai? You wanted a diplomatic answer to indian aggression and now this afghan stupidity?

Diplomacy works with people who have some honor and show you some respect, not with people who are hell bent on wiping you out from the face of the world and do not accept your existence as a state.
 
Pakistan should offer realistic terms for the ceasefire or make it conditional if objectives have not been resolved.


There are no existential threats to Pakistan barring Indian water terrorism. Rest is all manageable by diplomacy.
to further elaborate, these are imminent threats to Pak. existence:

1. incompetence to handle any significant challenge (which should not exist in the first place, if there is competent leadership, businessmen and judiciary!)

2. sell out politicians (who are only successful lawyers and businessmen!)


essentially, there is no external existential crisis!

if this persists (as it has for over more than 40 years), then, sorry, our civilian leadership, societal structure and civial bureaucracy needs a complete revamp!

there are no honest, hard working and truth seeking (different from truth speaking) individuals!
now, questions remains, if there are no honest and truth seeking individuals, then what are they?!!!

Vultures and thugs to breed more like them

sorry to be rude!
 
Guys I am going to need you to bring it back in and make this about strikes inside Afghanistan and less about TLP.

ELSIDD...
 
Guys I am going to need you to bring it back in and make this about strikes inside Afghanistan and less about TLP.

ELSIDD...

I would appreciate if you could be fair in your treatment.

I would like that iranian poster's post removed as well, do not need lectures on morality from people who have killed unarmed innocent afghan refugees. Thanks!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest Posts

Back
Top