BJP Labels All Muslims in India As Traitors

When you stay somewhere for 40 plus years, you are no longer a guest you practically become a native for all intents and purposes.There is an entire generation of Afghan refugees that have never seen Afghanistan in their life.All the know is Pakistan.

Our establishment likes to tout what a great charity they did by opening the borders for them. How about telling the country how many dollars they have earned destroying their country and forcing them to become refugees in the first place whether it was Afghan jihad or War on Terror.


No doubt there are criminals and subversive element in Afghan community.But many Afghans have started businesses invested and contributed to the economy
40 years or so means nothing if they dont have the citizenship and it doesnt make them native even if they get the citizenship.
Now coming to the usual rhetoric of Pakistan got this much dollars to destroy Afghanistan, why don't you tell us what has been happening in Afghanistan in last 200 years?
Why don't you start the history where Faqir of Ipi was given refuge in Afghanistan while he and his militants were waging a war against Pakistan.

Lastly, are you an Afghan or a PTIan?
 
Well they supported Pakistan movement and Jinnah. When it was time to leave, they stayed and asked for special religious rights in a secular country.
Well we have a BjP tout here and no the muslims who stayed in India stayed with their choice and they never supported the creation of Pakistan. Stop lying through your teeth all the time.
 
Well we have a BjP tout here and no the muslims who stayed in India stayed with their choice and they never supported the creation of Pakistan. Stop lying through your teeth all the time.
Are we re writing history?
 
I don't know I should say it here but before BJP if someone talk about democracy I have always admired India although in heart but now from bottom of my heart I must India is the house of most poorest people on earth and least democratic country, Only few people holds billions of USD and rest of all living on food ration of 5 KG each but still don't forget to brag about billion of economy but never talk back when ask per capita income.

@RescueRanger
 
If you mean BJP by "we", then yes. Everyone knows it !
If I share legit sources, you will call them bjp sources right.

Even though BJP wasn't in existence at that time
 
I don't know I should say it here but before BJP if someone talk about democracy I have always admired India although in heart but now from bottom of my heart I must India is the house of most poorest people on earth and least democratic country, Only few people holds billions of USD and rest of all living on food ration of 5 KG each but still don't forget to brag about billion of economy but never talk back when ask per capita income.

@RescueRanger
Same, I do admire some aspects of India, their insistence of self-reliance and industry is somthing to respect.
 
Same, I do admire some aspects of India, their insistence of self-reliance and industry is somthing to respect.
We have and we had more potential in this field but due to nature of taking bribes from Japan and other manufacturing nations we were deprived to build our own industries.
 
Already replied to @Master Chief you had raised same questions in this thread. Now can you answer my questions to him and you below:
The sources i posted are from human right organizations not from any pakistan sunni muslim. Your answer mean nothing when human right organizations calls it what it is.

How do you see flight of Abdul Salem and ahemadias at large in Pakistan?
2) How do you reconcile the dichotomy of your protests towards India with the fact that no non-muslim can lead the nation (no matter how qualified) ? Should Pakistan reform its laws?
3) How do you defend blasphemy laws and the way these laws are implemented? Doesn't blasphemy laws for one religion a) show superiority of a certain religion b) make citizens following other religions 2nd class citizens c) open door to abuse
For all three questions, state of Pakistan has to do a lot to make all citizens equal and unfortunately that's not the case ATM.

Now can you tell me why there hasn't been a muslim head of R&AW or PM or a chief of staff in India? Muslim population is 14% of the total population. Should i start talking about Dalit who make another 16%?
I wonder why a muslim was only chosen on a celebratory position and not on the position of power?
1- Do you support this?
2- What do you have to say about sachhar report?.
 
If I share legit sources, you will call them bjp sources right.

Even though BJP wasn't in existence at that time
You can share your sources. Lets put those through the scrutiny.
 
The sources i posted are from human right organizations not from any pakistan sunni muslim. Your answer mean nothing when human right organizations calls it what it is.


For all three questions, state of Pakistan has to do a lot to make all citizens equal and unfortunately that's not the case ATM.

Now can you tell me why there hasn't been a muslim head of R&AW or PM or a chief of staff in India? Muslim population is 14% of the total population. Should i start talking about Dalit who make another 16%?
I wonder why a muslim was only chosen on a celebratory position and not on the position of power?
1- Do you support this?
2- What do you have to say about sachhar report?.

There is no law against having a Muslim head of RAW, PM or Chief of Staff. And in due time we might have one or more.

Infact, APJ was President but before that he headed India's successful missile program. Every Indians Indepedence Day started with Ustad Bismillah Khan's Shehnai. The Banarasi Sarees that are worn by Indian women (primarily Hindu) are all manufactured by Muslim owned and operated mills (craftsman are also Muslim). Same with Chicken work in Lucknow.

SY Quereshi was India's election commissioner. Not going into bollywood or music etc - muslims rule that industry if I may say so. In terms of Khana, ITC Dum Pukht founder was Qureshi.

Take any field, you will find Muslims excelling. Here is my assumption (no data) - there is a strong correlation between doing well in India and your economic background - much more than correlation between religion and doing well.

FWIW, the argument about a particular post or person in general is short-sighted. What one needs to analyze is 1) Are there any systems that favor a particular religion, creed etc. 2) If no, is there evidence that some communities remain backward 3) If so, what is the root-cause (economic background, education, implicit bias, cultural norms etc.)

Depending on root-cause you will find a way to bridge the gap. Saying Hindus are bad and they don't allow Muslims to flourish is lazy and laced with implicit bias (as there is no data but only anecdotes to support the argument)
 
You can share your sources. Lets put those through the scrutiny.
C0s9pjAUAAAo5-W.jpg

Let's start with the basic stuff.

As you can see Muslim league, won all Muslim reserved seats in Bombay (Maharashtra+ Gujarat), Madras (South), Orissa. Also it won most seats in other present Indian states.

But it couldn't win all seats in Sindh, Punjab and NWFP.

Jinnah was a Gujarati Muslim. Most Muslim league leaders and supporters were from present day India.
 
40 years or so means nothing if they dont have the citizenship and it doesnt make them native even if they get the citizenship.
Now coming to the usual rhetoric of Pakistan got this much dollars to destroy Afghanistan, why don't you tell us what has been happening in Afghanistan in last 200 years?
Why don't you start the history where Faqir of Ipi was given refuge in Afghanistan while he and his militants were waging a war against Pakistan.

Lastly, are you an Afghan or a PTIan?

Whataboutism At It's Finest Still Doesn't Disprove The Fact That Generals Made A Killing Both In 80s and 2000s.My Father Was Also A Senior Bureaucrat And I Can't Dream Of Owning A Sugar Mill Unlike A Certain Humayun Akhtar Khan.

Don't Have Citizen ROFL An Entire Generation of Afghans Were Born Here and Have Never Seen Afghanistan Their Entire Lives.Go and Google Right of Soil Before Talking About Citizenship
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top