BJP Labels All Muslims in India As Traitors

CTD is still looking for some bad blood and I have list may I have recommend some people.
 
It was same some 30 years ago for many of us too then many realized enemy is within core of pat

I did not teach him a word of saraiki he is english speaking kid .he wears tie daily and go to school where no one speaks saraiki urdu .
Good, I don't like "Doo doo tey Doo chaar they dhaan rupey daa glass". lols
 
In 78 years, India did not have Head of R&AW from muslim or dalit community neither for Chief of army and prime minister, thats 30% of the population for you. And the answer lies in the structural inequalities built into the systems while on paper everything remains hunky dory.

You didnt talk about sachhar report because it shows some realities which are not acceptable to many in India.

Sure - there are structural inequalities but not just by religion or caste but a lot due to economic, regional and cultural differences. The way I look at it is that are differences getting more pronounced or the gap is filling up. I believe that later is true.

E.g., affirmative action in admissions, jobs, most other places. I am a "member" of a "general" class who had to be in top 1% to get admission. While SC/ST candidates with similar economic resources (not all but many) only had to score 30%-40% of what I scored to get in. Also, folks who get affirmative action once (in their family) continue to avail such benefits so the gap becomes harder to fill - even though with best intentions.

As I opined earlier, when I am recruiting, availing services, interacting with folks, I am doing from a merit basis (merit of candidate, argument etc.). That is what I can do from my vantage point, government is doing what it can. Does every Indian citizen in privileged class do the same - I am not sure.

Lastly, the largest discrepancy is economical. A rich Dalit, supresses other Dalits/Hindus. Same for Muslims, Hindus, any religion, community etc. People in "power" are taking advantage of the "system" across all lines...

That is India - far from perfect, chaotic but still progressing, growing at a rapid place, reforming, challenging cultural norms (for good and bad)
 
Go on i am waiting
I already posted 1946 elections results.

Now let's go little back.

Early Period (1906–1936)​


  • The All-India Muslim League (AIML) was founded in Dhaka (now Bangladesh) in 1906.
  • During this time, it had very limited popular support, especially outside elite Muslim circles.
  • The League was stronger in minority-Muslim provinces — such as:
    • United Provinces (U.P.)
    • Bihar
    • Bombay
    • Madras
  • These areas are all in present-day India.

Turning Point — 1937 Elections​


  • In the 1937 provincial elections, the Muslim League performed poorly:
    • Won only 109 of 482 Muslim seats across India.
    • Almost no success in Punjab, Bengal, or NWFP — which would later form Pakistan’s core.
  • Muslims in those provinces supported regional parties:
    • Unionist Party (Punjab)
    • Krishak Praja Party (Bengal)
    • Congress and Frontier Party (NWFP)
 
Go on i am waiting
I asked chatgpt the following:

Did Muslims of UP, Bihar, Gujarat, Maharashtra, South India play a bigger role in creating Pakistan? Short answer

Excellent and very perceptive question — and one that professional historians actively discuss.


In short: yes, Muslims from minority provinces such as UP (United Provinces), Bihar, Bombay/Gujarat, and to some degree South India, played a disproportionately larger political and ideological role in creating Pakistan — even though Pakistan was actually established in Muslim-majority regions (Punjab, Bengal, Sindh, NWFP, Baluchistan).
 
I asked chatgpt the following:

Did Muslims of UP, Bihar, Gujarat, Maharashtra, South India play a bigger role in creating Pakistan? Short answer

Excellent and very perceptive question — and one that professional historians actively discuss.


In short: yes, Muslims from minority provinces such as UP (United Provinces), Bihar, Bombay/Gujarat, and to some degree South India, played a disproportionately larger political and ideological role in creating Pakistan — even though Pakistan was actually established in Muslim-majority regions (Punjab, Bengal, Sindh, NWFP, Baluchistan).
The argument you're trying to peddle here is twofold:

1. Since muslim league got a majority from muslim majority areas in 1946, the entirety of the voter base Is complicit in wanting a sperate nation state

2. Now that the entirety of muslim populace has decided to move to pakistan, some decided to stay in India and thus the subsequent generations born 75 years henceforth should forget the nation they were born in, brought up, to uphold that promise and go ?

Ofcourse a large portion supported and emigrated to pakistan, but some chose to stay back because the founding fathers of Indian constitution were explicit in their message that this was not a hindu rhastra as pakistan was an islamic entity but a secular nation bound by laws and not by religion

Quoting election results from a century ago proves nothing, either concisely state your points or stay on topic, this tongue in cheek messaging is ironic by the fact that you're on a pakistani forum trying to flame bait on religious lines
 
Quoting election results from a century ago proves nothing, either concisely state your points or stay on topic, this tongue in cheek messaging is ironic by the fact that you're on a pakistani forum trying to flame bait on religious lines
Is it off topic?

BJP leader called Indian Muslims 'Namak Haram' for this very reason. Because they supported Muslim League, religious separation and created Pakistan.

I did not start the discussion. I am just posting some facts. Ironically which a Pakistani forum member asked me to do.

Ofcourse a large portion supported and emigrated to pakistan, but some chose to stay back because the founding fathers of Indian constitution were explicit in their message that this was not a hindu rhastra as pakistan was an islamic entity but a secular nation bound by laws and not by religion
It's the other way around.

Large portion who supported Jinnah stayed back.

To prove my point I will post a speech made by a top Congress leader who explicitly says that most Indian Muslims who created Pakistan stayed back in India.






Was Sardar Vallabhai Patel misinformed or a bigot? @Vapnope
 
Last edited:
When you stay somewhere for 40 plus years, you are no longer a guest you practically become a native for all intents and purposes.There is an entire generation of Afghan refugees that have never seen Afghanistan in their life.All the know is Pakistan.

Our establishment likes to tout what a great charity they did by opening the borders for them. How about telling the country how many dollars they have earned destroying their country and forcing them to become refugees in the first place whether it was Afghan jihad or War on Terror.


No doubt there are criminals and subversive element in Afghan community.But many Afghans have started businesses invested and contributed to the economy
These simplistic assumptions aren't reality. If you live somewhere for 40 or even 100 years, your mindset needs to change. Just bc you live somewhere as an alien immigrant does not make you aligned with the native masses.

The entire Pakistani nation feels that those we hosted as guests and absolutely opened our hearts and doors to have stabbed us in the back. What did Pakisan get in return? A billion dollars aid package from 1982 to 1990 when Pressler sanctions were imposed.

This is not a narrative peddled by any establishment because ppl see these things with their eyes and have been seeing since the 1980s. The drugs, the Kalashnikov culture etc. were all begotten from hosting refugees from Afghanistan.

How many dollars did the establishment earn? Do you have an idea since you are claiming this with such great abandon?

Come the Americans and the so called "earning of dollars" charge; the vast majority of the coalition support fund was being diverted to keep the economy afloat. Did you know that the military was siphoning CSF funds to keep Pakistan from defaulting and using the moneys to repay loans?

Name me one capital weapon system that was inducted by the military using the CSF funds except for the 18 odd F-16s? The military kept the lights on by indigenous efforts and getting support for small arms (M-4s, Sniper rifles, fuel etc.). Nothing more.

$14B was provided to Pakistan over 16 years which accounts for less than a billion each year. Of these, the GoP got permission from the Americans to use some of the moneys for retiring bi-lateral/multi-lateral debt owed to the Western countries (no servicing of Chinese loans etc.)

"destroying their country and forcing them to become refugees in the first place whether it was Afghan jihad or War on Terror."

How did Pakistan force ANYONE to become refugees? Did Pakistan entice the Soviets or the Americans to invade and occupy Afghanistan? Give us a break on these silly charges. It was Afghans who first colluded with the Soviets on account of their own in-fighting and the exact same happened with the post 9/11 scenario. Afghans, like always, played to both sides of the gallery milking money from Soviets and Americans alike for development and lining the pockets of their elite.
 
Some Muslim communities in India should be under genocide watch. It's a precarious situation.
 
India is like a giant Yugoslavia. It is simply too big and dense to ensure the rights of their minorities. Jinnah was right.
 
Last edited:
I never did - all I claimed is no government law based on religion. I have already opined on the disconnect between Muslims and other communities in India.
Either way we can agree to disagree.

Good on Pakistan for abolishing triple talaq. I am aware of Pakistan being ahead of India here. Congratulations.

Don't deflect on three questions I had raised.Putting them below again.
1) How do you see flight of Abdul Salem and ahemadias at large in Pakistan?
2) How do you reconcile the dichotomy of your protests towards India with the fact that no non-muslim can lead the nation (no matter how qualified) ? Should Pakistan reform its laws?
3) How do you defend blasphemy laws and the way these laws are implemented? Doesn't blasphemy laws for one religion a) show superiority of a certain religion b) make citizens following other religions 2nd class citizens c) open door to abuse

And if you don't have a POV, before pointing fingers for once, look deep down within.
Let me make this very simple for you.

You claimed "no law based on religion". I have already demonstrated multiple laws and statutes in the Secular Republic of Hindustan that discriminate against Muslims SPECIFICALLY. You have said "we agree to disagree" on this....no we have not agreed to disagree - rather, I have demonstrated how your initial claim is incorrect. This is not "disagreeing", but a simple refutation. Your "opinion" is not relevant in the face of objective facts.

The second part in bold - I have not deflected. In fact, you deflected away from and obfuscated my evidence.

I will not respond to your questions until you have addressed the multiple issues I raised. Indian law functionally and definitively discriminates against Muslims, as per the evidence cited.
 
Let me make this very simple for you.

You claimed "no law based on religion". I have already demonstrated multiple laws and statutes in the Secular Republic of Hindustan that discriminate against Muslims SPECIFICALLY. You have said "we agree to disagree" on this....no we have not agreed to disagree - rather, I have demonstrated how your initial claim is incorrect. This is not "disagreeing", but a simple refutation. Your "opinion" is not relevant in the face of objective facts.

The second part in bold - I have not deflected. In fact, you deflected away from and obfuscated my evidence.

I will not respond to your questions until you have addressed the multiple issues I raised. Indian law functionally and definitively discriminates against Muslims, as per the evidence cited.

LOL... As I said, you see it anti Muslim, I don't. I am not here to convince anyone but offer my perspective. Whether you believe it or agree with it or not is of little consequence to me.

As for you not answering my questions well I call that a cop out.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Latest Posts

Back
Top