Oscar
Moderator
Technically the PN Atlantique is paraded by them as a kill.
And there is the asset at Bholari.
Then apparently there is even bragging of the assets supposedly lost to terrorists in Mehran, Kamra and Mianwali
8 Pakistan Air Force Officers Awarded Sitara =e-Jurat Medals
- Thread starter Windjammer
- Start date
And there is the asset at Bholari.
Then apparently there is even bragging of the assets supposedly lost to terrorists in Mehran, Kamra and Mianwali
Atlantique was not flown by paf
Bholari was damaged not destroyed. Not technically a kill
side-winder
Moderator
Apologies for late comment - Don't know what's the latest on said inquiry. Alot of questions which need the formal answering :-
Did concerned AD setups inform the Base authorities about incoming missiles?
How much time did they take for dissemination of information?
What were the actions of base authorities upon receiving the call from AD setups?
Was the air raid alert siren working at the time?
Was it audible at hangar?
When was the siren blown?
Were the people at base briefed about actions in case of air raid alarm?
Were the trenches available for shelter during air raid alarm?
Are recordings of Motorolla channels available?
Under whose authority was that SAAB standing inside hangar? Did AHQ authorise it or AHQ was consulted? When was the last state submitted to AHQ?
When were emergency response teams (fire / rescue / explosive disarmament) informed?
What was the response time of emergency response teams?
Is there any possibility of a "inside help" about location of aircraft?
That's lots of statements to record - and it's going to take a while.
Last edited:
Ali_Baba
VIP Member
Do large planes like the Erieye have HAS shelters ? The fighter fleet certainly has, so the question is how can such an asset be protected other than moving it around, alot.
side-winder
Moderator
No HAS exist for large body aircrafts yet at our bases.
Im sure that would be part of the inquiry board's recommendations.
Ali_Baba
VIP Member
HAS and underground facilities, and location of bases ( to give better incoming time of attacks ). Some of the bases in the cities are difficult to defend them given that they may cause civilian casualties. Time to think about larger super bases in the middle of nowhere that can be made more sterile and easier to defend them.
side-winder
Moderator
You cannot just build more bases or shift exisiting ones - Its a matter of billions of dollars.
Major cost contributors:-
1. Infrastructure including offices, runways, HAS, Ops facilities, maintenence facilities, storage facilities, support facilities, hospital, accomodation for people and all the other basic facilities which make the life livable for 5-10 K people.
2. Equipment for Ops, maintenence and support facilities.
3. Communication setups which includes laying of OFC all way from nearest base and wireless links for interbase connectivity. Then laying of Communication wires in each office / facility.
Remember - aviation is a costly business.
Vkdindian1
Registered Member
What is the way out then?
How does one protect such assets?
They can’t be kept in air all the time. They would need some repair etc and would need to be on ground.
Last edited:
side-winder
Moderator
That's one problem with our geographical boundaries. We lack strategic depth. We can not hide any high value assets in depth to minimize chances of hit or even afford more reaction time for an appropriate reactive action.
However, that still can not be excuse for the mistakes at Bholari. Im sure alot of peope would get appreciations and alot would be getting a major dent to their careers.
So what can be the solution?
Atleast a couple of HAS at each base for large body aircrafts have to be built. Yeah - still alots of aircrafts won't be safe including the C130s but atleast you can put the HVAs like AWACS in them.
Installation of more effective anti-drone systems to rule out any possibility of hit through killer drones.
Even if none of such things is done - Better judgement of the situation and events building up can still save valuable lives and equipment. Given the circumstances - that aircraft should never have been there - given the fact that Jacobabad and Sukkur Hangars had just been hit.
Windjammer
VIP Member
- Thread starter
- #387
I think one has to be a little realistic here.
Israel with it's Iron Dome with other sophisticated AD equipment and all the hi tech gadgetry couldn't stop all the Iranian missiles and we are not talking about just few getting through, even it's F-35 base took multiple hits. India fired some 50 BrahMos missiles, how many did hit worthy military targets. All 7 fired at Rafiqui were neutralised through hard and soft kills. Rahim Yaar Khan is like a private civilian facility. Was India able to intercept all the projectiles fired at Adampur, Avaintpura and few others, it's another thing for whatever reasons Pakistan is withholding satellite Imagery. The much fabled S-400, whether it was neutralised or paralysed, it didn't stop PAF from conducting a daring raid against it . There are hangars at every base, even bigger ones at Nur Khan but one lucky hit at Bholari gets all the attention. Someone should ask Shiv Aroor to follow up on his tweets on Srinagar under air attack with two aircraft being shotdown.
Israel with it's Iron Dome with other sophisticated AD equipment and all the hi tech gadgetry couldn't stop all the Iranian missiles and we are not talking about just few getting through, even it's F-35 base took multiple hits. India fired some 50 BrahMos missiles, how many did hit worthy military targets. All 7 fired at Rafiqui were neutralised through hard and soft kills. Rahim Yaar Khan is like a private civilian facility. Was India able to intercept all the projectiles fired at Adampur, Avaintpura and few others, it's another thing for whatever reasons Pakistan is withholding satellite Imagery. The much fabled S-400, whether it was neutralised or paralysed, it didn't stop PAF from conducting a daring raid against it . There are hangars at every base, even bigger ones at Nur Khan but one lucky hit at Bholari gets all the attention. Someone should ask Shiv Aroor to follow up on his tweets on Srinagar under air attack with two aircraft being shotdown.
Panzerkiel
Professional
There are specific reasons, all known, due to which this thing happened. Can't specify them here, but I must say that it was unavoidable.
Panzerkiel
Professional
Like... Just a teaser.... No one will talk about three strike packages of SU30 sent for this general location, what happened to them... Etc... Etc.... It's overall an interesting story once you know what PAF, army and PAF AD assets did against IAF guys... Very interesting....
Still not over with my popcorns.
onlinpunit
Trusted Member
Is there any image whatsoever of the any indian assets ( base, airbase, drop, SAM site anything) damaged by PAF attack. Satellite, aerial, gun camera anything. There are thousands of Freelance, non govt sites having such image taking capacity.
Users who are viewing this thread
Pakistan Defence Latest
-
-
-
Killings linked to illegal intrusion or criminal acts should not be called border killings: Salahuddin (11 Viewers)
- Latest: baldfish
-
-
