(GRAPHIC) Muslim man beaten to death after offering blood at hospital in India

Whatever happened is very sad but judging entire country on such incidents is wrong.... Do we even know anything about that Muslim person, his past, his present , his enemies anything else?

How you are so sure that just because he offered blood to Hindu women he was immediately killed and iron rods and weapons were already available with attackers? How do we know if he already had enemies and they were following him to that hospital?

In India opposition parties make issue of everything to show how minorities are not safe in India and Media is purchased many times to portray in negetive way....

Abdul Kalam was top Indian scientist and have served as a president of this country..... Along with Hindu and Punjabi how many Muslims have been top cricketers and Bollywood celebrities in India? So please stop judging someone just by going on some news....

Y'all nigga's kill one for eating meat, and many have died due to false accusations, so stop trying to act as if there was some conspiracy behind this.
 
Whatever happened is very sad but judging entire country on such incidents is wrong.... Do we even know anything about that Muslim person, his past, his present , his enemies anything else?

How you are so sure that just because he offered blood to Hindu women he was immediately killed and iron rods and weapons were already available with attackers? How do we know if he already had enemies and they were following him to that hospital?

In India opposition parties make issue of everything to show how minorities are not safe in India and Media is purchased many times to portray in negetive way....

Abdul Kalam was top Indian scientist and have served as a president of this country..... Along with Hindu and Punjabi how many Muslims have been top cricketers and Bollywood celebrities in India? So please stop judging someone just by going on some news....

Individual example in an ocean of oppression.
Nothing but figure head examples to hide obvious and glaringly extreme discrimination where Muslims are under represented in every metric.
They face discrimination in the constitution, legal system and the courts up to and including the Supreme Court of India.
 
I understand that. But am I incorrect that Bangladesh was created from Pakistan during the 1971 war?

Therefore, what difference would there be then for Indian Muslims to choose the emigrate to either Pakistan or Bangladesh then to escape the persecutions of Indians?

The two Nation theory is preached in an extremely poor manner.
I will try to explain but will deliberately keep it short unless you ask me otherwise.

South Asia does not have two nations, it has dozens. It is far more diverse then the entire continent of Europe, possibly even Africa.

It has ethnic/linguistic nations, plus religious nations, these two being the dominate defining identifications.


Tamil are a nation as are the Maratha, the Gujurati and so on.
Muslim are a nation as are Hindus, Christians and Sikhs. They all reside within their own daily lived experiences separate from other groups.

Formation of India and Pakistan was the result of post British power sharing settlement. Muslims and Hindus are the two largest group in South Asia so the power equilibriums needed to be fair for a lasting peace. Independence for Pakistan and India was the solution.

Much of the mess is the result of how it was handled, not because of the solution itself.



Now to your core question, it was never a case of Pakistan gets independence and all the Muslims run to Pakistan. That was never part of the plan.

Ultimately, there were three groups of refugees, not just one, which is a factually incorrect formulation, although it is what’s generally taught.

To explain, let’s get the facts straight. India was not divided, India did not exist, you cannot divide something which has never existed in history.

The British created a colony by conquering various kingdoms in South Asia and they decided to name their colony India. Clarity is important otherwise the discussion gets into lazy interpretations.
Even saying British India was divided is a murky territory but that would divert the discussion.


Only Punjab and Bengal were divided, not India. It matters also because it explains the refugee dynamics as they actually existed. People, including so called experts fail to recognise essential facts and the entire discussion turns to shyt.

Western Punjab had a Muslim majority, while East Punjab had a Hindu and Sikh majority.
West Bengal had a Hindu majority, while East Bengal had a Muslim majority.


First group, by far the largest group.
There was internal migration between each of these two provinces of British colony of India.
Muslims from East Punjab moved to West Punjab. Hindus and Sikhs from West Punjab moved to East Punjab.
The same pattern was formed between West and East Bengal, respective minorities moved to their respective areas.
Both of these groups were moving towards their co-ethnic groups and ancestral lands.

Second group, second largest group.
This is the only group which moved due to ideological reasons. Muslims from what became India moved to the independent state of Pakistan.
Hindus and Sikhs from non Punjab areas of Pakistan moved to the newly created country of India.

Third group, the smallest of the three.
This is from the princely state of Jammu and Kashmir. A princely state with a overwhelming Muslim majority but ruled by a Hindu maharaja.


This princely state had three broad internal areas, Kashmir region, Jammu region and Ladakh.
Almost all, possibly around 80% of the refugees in this group came from Jammu. Jammu had a Muslim population of figures ranging from 50-60%. The Muslim percentage in Jammu region after the genocide dropped to about 30%.

There was an organised ethic cleaning and a genocide, which resulted in the murder of around 100,000 Muslims. There has never been a proper study to establish these figures, but all estimates are in six figures, where people were carted into trucks taken to rural areas and shot, not unlike some of what the Jews suffered in the hands of the Nazi's. The higher estimated figures are close to 300,000

This genocide was organised by the Maharaja forces jointly with the RSS and other Hindu groups. There are also reports of ex Indian army personal taking part in this genocide. My family, including my father came out of this process as a young teenager.

The actual reality is somewhat different from the simplistic lie of two nation theory.

First group were the Punjabis and the Bengalis moving to another part of their own ancestral lands.
Second group moved due to ideological reasons.
Third group came out of an actual genocide.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top