Opinion Piece- Beyond Partition: Imagining an India-Pakistan Friendship

We are neighbours. We aren't going to stop being neighbours, regardless of who occupies the Red Fort or Islamabad's corridors of power.
Sure but nobody said we should be friends.
And if our relationship is to be permanently defined by the assumption that the other is an adversary, what exactly are we hoping to achieve by perpetuating that relationship?

I'm not suggesting either country abandon its interests, overlook historical grievances or extend unconditional trust.

I'm simply exploring whether we can begin to build a functional relationship without first resolving every disagreement that has brought us to this point.
How exactly do you build trust with a state where the civilian government does not even control the military establishment, and where that establishment has historically treated hostility towards India as a strategic necessity?
I'm not arguing that dialogue should never happen. I'm arguing that dialogue without accountability, reciprocity and verifiable changes in behaviour is simply wishful thinking. Dialogue is a default state so far dialogue in the last 80 years produced no tangible results. So why should this time be any different?
 
Sure but nobody said we should be friends.

How exactly do you build trust with a state where the civilian government does not even control the military establishment, and where that establishment has historically treated hostility towards India as a strategic necessity?
I'm not arguing that dialogue should never happen. I'm arguing that dialogue without accountability, reciprocity and verifiable changes in behaviour is simply wishful thinking. Dialogue is a default state so far dialogue in the last 80 years produced no tangible results. So why should this time be any different?
Coming from a nation where a Muslim gets lynched by a doctor whilst offering to donate blood - you have to right to pollute a thread like this. Shoo off back under the rock
 
Neither of the countries are in a position to military impose themself on the other. Also issues like Kashmir are not going to be solved in the current atmosphere.
@Krptonite , it would be interesting to know what the members here want. Options would be
Mutual destruction
Status Quo with occasional clashes
Ignore one another
Normal relationship and solve our problems later.

images - 2026-11-19T074142.764.jpeg
 
Watch and compare sportsmanship

They are truly in a clash of civilization. They are fully bought into the ideas. What are we doing in return? Singing kumbaya because the esteem rules currently ruling Pakistan as viceroys busy forcing aggressive Western Liberalism into the eastern of the country while getting ready to abandon the western part - meanwhile the wolves are at the gate culturally, civilizationally, and socially.
 


WTF is going on with these types in Pakistan. This is the failure at the state level indoctrination.

@Yasser76 @PK781 @Master Chief @PAKISTANFOREVER @hussain0216


Such things occur when we as a nation, become softie, looking to please or impress others (such as amreeka or european or brits or japs etc) and not realizing or being able to properly use our God-given advantages to the fullest.
Then we have these various NGO-run projects (west used to fund these in Pak) to make room for their softpower projection amongst the populations.

example: hey if u want that student scholarship visa or free visa/stay/edu in West just spread softism or bending over for the benefits we'll pay for it, just be a cuck!
Local desperates fall for it and thus develop a soft belly and become "non-aggressive"........

How we have completely forgotten who our real heroes were, like Jinnah, Allah Iqbal, Yousaf Tashfeen, Tariq bin Ziyad, Sultan Salah ud Din Ayyubi, Hazrat Ali, and countless Sahaba..........our new young gens have heroes or images of stupid shit these days. We have ignored our islamic history (its no longer taught).....we are utterly divided into sectarian sects of our religion (shia vs sunni vs wahabi vs ahle hadis etc)........our books and curriculum have been changed, even Ahmadis have gotten hold of that shit and tried to change........there was even an attempt to change the wordings in some bills (remember Sheikh Rasheed caught it and raised a storm about it years ago).

Our foreign office and also military have ignored, or did not give it importance to counter the indian narratives and propaganda.......yes our ISPR gave them befitting replies to threats etc but never on propaganda until recently.......even the abhinandan and kulbhushan yadav captures we did not fully encash!

We are too busy trying to be super friendly or trying to impress others at the cost of our own peril. The victories of 2019 and then May 2025 were God-given to push us to finally realize our potential and to wake up and grab our destiny and future path into the future. The tenure of Gen Bajwa was the worst time for the country!

I'm glad the things are changing under the new/current COAS and the aggressive posture now and the cooperation and work with China will ensure we take a new approach, but the young generation needs to realize.
People criticize Zaid Hamid and the likes on many things, but they says the bitter truth out loud.....

F the bjp and their shit minions or supporters of the 'aman ki asha', rather, there will be Ghazwa e Hind soon. The decider. Only then will there be real peace in the region
 
When you don't teach your history, culture, heritage and nationalism/patriotism to your kids, this is the eend result.

Every one of the things you mentioned are not only taught but propagated by the State in every spectrum. Every subculture takes great pride in themselves which come from appreciation of their heritage which they preserved through history.

This is what the great Saints and Buddhist heritage and noble genetics have taught us, to offer peace even if it means suicide.

To change the state of affairs, all heritage, cultures and history should be reworked in a sacrificial culture movement led by unmarried individuals of the society. All married people are compromised.
 
Every one of the things you mentioned are not only taught but propagated by the State in every spectrum. Every subculture takes great pride in themselves which come from appreciation of their heritage which they preserved through history.

This is what the great Saints and Buddhist heritage and noble genetics have taught us, to offer peace even if it means suicide.

To change the state of affairs, all heritage, cultures and history should be reworked in a sacrificial culture movement led by unmarried individuals of the society. All married people are compromised.


WTF??????????? What are you going on about????????.................:ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO::ROFLMAO:
 
I've grown rather concerned that people have stopped calling me racist slurs around here. So, in an attempt to rectify this unfortunate development, expand my vocabulary of creative swear words, and generally demonstrate just how tone-deaf I can be, I'd like to propose a thought experiment: what might the normalisation of relations between India and Pakistan eventually look like, why do I believe it is a possibility rather than an impossibility, and what could the two countries potentially achieve through such a relationship?

I'd like to explore this through four questions:

1. Why do I believe normalisation is eventually possible?

My starting point is that hostility between nations, however deeply entrenched, is rarely a permanent condition. Geography doesn't change, generations change, economic priorities evolve and national interests are recalibrated. What seems politically inconceivable today may become a pragmatic necessity tomorrow. What historical, economic or generational developments could eventually make this possible?

2. What would the economic relationship between the two countries look like?

India and Pakistan have developed largely separate economic ecosystems despite their geographic proximity and shared commercial heritage. What happens when Indian capital, technology, manufacturing scale and consumer markets interact with Pakistani industrial capacity, agricultural potential, workforce and geographic position? Could both countries unlock opportunities that neither can fully realise independently?

3. What happens to the strategic equation of the subcontinent?

Imagine India no longer viewing Pakistan primarily through a security lens, and Pakistan no longer organising a significant part of its national strategy around counterbalancing India. What happens to defence expenditure, regional connectivity, access to Central Asia, relations with China and the Gulf, and the geopolitical standing of South Asia?

4. What would our children's generation inherit?

This is perhaps the most interesting question to me. Would Indians and Pakistanis eventually be able to travel freely, conduct business, study and maintain personal relationships across the border? Could two distinct national identities coexist with a recognition of shared history and cultural heritage? What might the subcontinent look like after 30 years of peaceful competition rather than perpetual hostility?

This is, of course, just a thought experiment, and I'm under no illusion that everyone will share the premise. By all means, poke holes in it, challenge the assumptions, disagree with the arguments or bash the entire proposition to smithereens.

Interesting piece. It's certainly a topic which rarely gets touched upon in this new forum although it was all the rage in the previous forum. Should be interesting.
But largely it's just questions without ideas but I'll save it and go through the thread before forming an opinion.

There are some misunderstandings, and glaring shortcomings, although with some points of agreement, it seems I will largely disagree. I will reply once I form an opinion and then I hope we can have a decent discussion.
 
Sure but nobody said we should be friends.

How exactly do you build trust with a state where the civilian government does not even control the military establishment, and where that establishment has historically treated hostility towards India as a strategic necessity?
I'm not arguing that dialogue should never happen. I'm arguing that dialogue without accountability, reciprocity and verifiable changes in behaviour is simply wishful thinking. Dialogue is a default state so far dialogue in the last 80 years produced no tangible results. So why should this time be any different?
Your newly acquired machismo is entertaining....why shall it be any of your business whether it's military or civilian calling the shots in Pakistan as long as Pakistani public is not hostile towards you and the state of Pakistan is asking for a resolution of Kashmir issue in a fair and internationally recognised manner ? .....why don't you accept the reality that you don't have the capacity to browbeat or hurt Pakistan in any conceivable way .
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top