‘I want to cry’: Afghan medical students in Pakistan face expulsion fear

[Goenitz]

We have been showing the afghans we are their bum lickers for 47 years YET ALL Pakistanis got was 90,000+ Pakistanis murdered by afghan terrorist scumbags.

Really doesn't matter. If our policy is different, then we should show it.
We hosted 8 million and some or most were hostile, but not all. Lastly, we lost 90k Pakistanis due to our own policy. The hired guns were Afghans, Pakistanis, Tajiks, etc.
Also, the real culprits behind our suffering were India and the US, and possibly the UAE, Iran, etc. Did we do anything about it?

 

[fitpOsitive]

This will send a very negative message towards international community. These students were completing there studies. They are 1000 times better than Talibs in my opinion.
Let's not waste this chance of peace. Let's invite them back with apology and compensate for their time wasted and emotional damage. I hope after completion of their studies they will have at least some positivity in hearts for us.

 

[El Sidd]

If I am not wrong Iran reached same conclusion this year and is carrying out mass deportations.

Not just war, Iran had been deporting Afghans ever more in increasing numbers. Half of Tehran is built by Afghan manpower but they face halal racism there and there were videos circulated where Iranian officials had them placed in chicken wire cages.

 

[r3alist]

Let's not waste this chance of peace

What chance for peace

As if Pakistan does not need it's own educated


Why is generosity expected to be one way

 

[El Sidd]

What chance for peace

As if Pakistan does not need it's own educated


Why is generosity expected to be one way

Whats with all the gender inequality in the human rights equation in the thread?

 

[r3alist]

Whats with all the gender inequality in the human rights equation in the thread?

It's actually equality

 

[Master Chief]

This will send a very negative message towards international community. These students were completing there studies. They are 1000 times better than Talibs in my opinion.
Let's not waste this chance of peace. Let's invite them back with apology and compensate for their time wasted and emotional damage. I hope after completion of their studies they will have at least some positivity in hearts for us.

My perspective on this matter is different and is based on evidence, not emotion.

The Afghan female, regardless of positive modifiers received by way of Pakistani favours extended towards them and their well being, is not able to think or act independently to the point that she might influence the Afghan male. On the contrary, if her fate is in her own hands, the best escape for the Afghan female would be (and often is) an escape from Afghans altogether. They are so damaged by Afghan society that they are often found in the west (when they have managed to escape the orbit of their own diaspora) pursuing relationships away from Afghan men and indeed away from Islam altogether.

In short, they're really not something that Pakistan directly can, or even should try, to "fix" or "influence", as their ability to "return any investment we make" is virtually nil - and that is even if they ever WANTED TO return that investment. As I said before, removal of Talibs will indirectly help the Afghan female (and is the only way to achieve this).

Genuine Afghans (NOT Pakistani pashtuns, who are as Pakistani as you or I) themselves despise any association with Pakistan, even when we have provided refuge and safe haven for them since their birth.

 

[Aziqbal]

Sorry guys you have to go back

enough is enough

 

[flyingorca]

Maybe a solution would be to send them back after completion of their studies.

Let the female doctors remain if they wish/ask to become full Pakistani citizens(and they revoke their Afghan citizenship).

Send the blokes back - judging by the video's, it seems to be men making the idiotic statements.

Slightly sexist approach that probably won't stand up in court, etc. If not, then send them back after their studies and not accept new students of course.

I came across a tweet of a Pakistani junior doctor relative... she said that one of her Afghani colleague who is also a junior doctor used to give as much pain to Pakistani patients when when treating them. Now imagine what else these Afghans be doing to ordinary Pakistanis. Like those naan walas may be using their piss to make your naans. the amount of hatred they have for Pakistan I wont be surprised.

 

[flyingorca]

 

[safriz]

I guess Pakistan is going over the top and creating unnecessary hardship for Afghans living peacefully in Pakistan.
There's no reason and no point in throwing people out because of their ethnicity.

 

[hasssanali8998]